26 Best American Restaurants in Williamsville

“The Wood Roasted Lemon Garlic Chicken was made perfectly with a crispy skin, and the roasted fingerling potatoes were spot on. The Grilled Faroe Island Salmon was incredibly tender, fell apart under the fork, and paired beautifully with a smooth Pinot Noir. Will recommend either of these main courses. For the appetizer the Burrata was delicious, although the sweet corn pepperonata was slightly sweet for my taste, it balanced well with the wine. Overall a great dining experience!“

“Had dinner at Share last night with my fiancé and a couple friends. We always have an incredible experience at Share. The owner and his staff is friendly, hard working and fantastic. The food is on point every time and we always enjoy our experience there. Thank you!“

“Great food. Great atmosphere. Super cool staff. Definitely recommend.“

“This old gem doesn't need another glowing review, but here it is anyway! Classic dishes like pot pie and open faced turkey sandwiches are perfect for a chilly Buffalo night. Gorgeous building with a great bar area. Good local beers on tap and decent wine list. Friendly service.“

“Always stop there when I’m in town“

“Hudson who served us was very friendly. We had an appetizer and two meals. It was very good and worth the price. The Brisket is amazing ... !!“

“Always stop there when I’m in town“

“Went here for lunch. Fantastic. Great food as always!“

“Always a great experience! The prices however are going up and the pepper dip that is awesome no longer comes with bread which sucks because tortilla chips just don’t cut it and I refuse to pay $3 for a small loaf of bread. Otherwise service, atmosphere and food are awesome!“

“I went for the first time today. I ordered the chicken in the grass. It was fantastic. By far the best I ever had.“

“Just the best & fresh seafood in Buffalo“

“The Britesmith has the best burger I have ever had! Will definitely go back!“

“You must get the hot wings if you are a hot lover. No questions asked. Best hot wings you will ever have for heat and flavor mixture. I assure you on everything holy, you will not die a happy person unless you have a duffs hot wings. That or the extra hot. No questions asked. Stop asking yourself dumb questions, and come eat the hot and the extra hot. You will not have lived up to your full potential until you've tried these wings.

Kid-friendliness: Just amazing people“

“A Buffalo institution and one of my must visit place(s) if I'm in the area. Personally, I like the original Anderson's location on Sheridan (in Tonawanda) better than the other locations. But this one is not bad. Only got a twist of chocolate and vanilla custard this time but I've had majority of the items on the menu. The custard is always creamy and flavorful. Try one of the special flavors, like pistachios or strawberry, if they have it. You won't regret it and it's worth the calories.

Dietary restrictions: Dairy

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly - who doesn't like custard/ice cream?

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“Excellent Cajun wings and good service!!!“

“Mom and Pop feel for a quick greek styled lunch or dinner. I got the chicken soulaki meal which was a large portion and was good. They did forget my rice pudding in the order. Atmosphere was okay and mostly to blame from this customer who seemed to berate the employee while I was waiting for my pickup order.“

“I’ve been coming here since I was 5 with my dad, and my sister and I decided to celebrate my dad’s 75th birthday with some family and friends. We knew they didn’t make reservations and only seat up to 12 people at tables. Understandable and we said no problem, we’ll make it work! When we arrived the hostess had a real attitude about our large party and was very rude. Yes, we knew we would have to wait about an hour (it was not a problem, in fact BBP capitalized on this by us buying drinks at the bar!). Luckily that was the only bad experience. The two servers we had (one each for our 12 top and 4 top) were wonderful! The host or hostess really sets the first impression when coming in and it was really the only bad experience of the night.“

“Had my wife’s 40th surprise party here, the food was incredible, atmosphere is like nothing around here, and the service was too knoch. Christy B and her staff are fantastic.“

“Blue Fire BBQ recently catered a large family event. Our order included pulled pork, pulled chicken, jerk island chicken and mac & cheese. Everything was delivered exactly on time and included serving utensils. It was all delicious ( esp. the bbq chicken!) and there were many compliments! We will definitely be calling again for the next party.“

“Good old fashion diner. Good food, good service, good price. CLEAN!“

“We had a funeral luncheon at the Irishman and we worked closely with Mike for it. It turned out absolutely perfect. The food was delicious (which isn’t always easy when you are making such large quantities) and Mike was so kind, helpful, and efficient. Last minute our numbers increased as they sometimes do with these things and Mike was so understanding and supportive. On one of our hardest days, Mike and the Irishman helped our family enjoy ourselves. Thank you.“

“Great food but the soda is too expensive“

“Upon my first visit i fell in love with everything from the food to the atmosphere. Im a bit of an adult child and i love chicken tenders and tullys is right they make the best around! If your a bit of a sport nut that loves a good applebeesish atmosphere then this is the place for you.“

“Great vegan options, would 100% recommend the vegan Big Phil mac n cheese“

“Good evening! I could not go to bed tonight without acknowledging the fabulous service my two friends and I received at the Acropolis on Main Street. Our server Anthony C was outstanding! All three of us commented that we could not remember a time where we had such an attentive server that was also entertaining and gracious. You are blessed and lucky to have some like him on your team. We do a monthly dinner on Main Street and are already planning on coming back to Acropolis for our September dinner (if we can find out when Anthony C is working!) Thank you Anthony for a night of fabulous service and great laughs!!“

“TRANSIT ROAD location. Horrible experience. Pizza is not good at all. OVERBAKED, TOO MUCH SAUCE....and we asked for light sauce and light bake! Nachos were good but not good enough to make us return. Manager was told about our pizza and did nothing. Just a crappy meal.“