17 Best American Restaurants in Amherst

“After unpacking our son at his apartment near UB we found Tito’s Tavern to grab a quick bite and we were not disappointed at all!! Food was fresh and made to order! Owners father was running it today and friendly. Would definitely recommend and can’t wait to go back!“

“Unfortunately they forgot my sausage in the seasonal special which made the dish very bland. They brought it out when I asked, but it took away from the dish. The shrimp was also overcooked and a little burnt. They did discount my meal (some Cajun pasta special feature), but I would have preferred the dish came as advertised. The other dish we got was great - the chicken pot pie. Highly recommend that in cooler months. Overall was a fine place that filled us up without breaking the bank while staying in the area.

Parking: The restaurant has a parking lot“

“The food was outstanding! Service amazing! Beautifully remodeled, my husband and I will definitely be back ????“

“When I visit Buffalo, I always have to stop in for Duffs wings. I was there today 2-27-2024 with friends from high-school“

“Newly renovated/updated interior. Looks great! Very fresh and inviting. Staff are super friendly and helpful. Food arrives hot ? and cooked as requested. Bottomless cup of coffee. Breakfast here starts our day on the right track. Great prices too.“

“Great atmosphere and staff. Been coming to this location for 5 yrs. and will continue coming. Thank you!!!“

“My husband and I have always enjoyed the great food and drinks at Jazzboline, and the waitstaff consistently provides excellent service. Recently, I had the pleasure of throwing a surprise birthday party for my husband there, and I can't say enough about how helpful Mike Overdorf was! He answered all my questions and made the party planning process seamless, from selecting the drink menu to choosing the meals, even including little boxes of chocolates as a special touch.

During the party, the waitstaff, Michelle and Sara, were gracious, kind, patient, and attentive throughout the celebration.“

“Blue Bull is a great casual bar with great food & great atmosphere“

“Endless fries soda refills All around great place“

“The fish dinner was awful.Very very nasty.The fish was fried hard on the outside and it was mushy on the inside.The fries were nasty too as if they were fried in grease that wasn't hot then taken out until the grease got hot,then put back in.In the past the fish was delicious.So I bragged to my house guest about the fish,only to be disappointed.So my guess is they hired a new cook.The Cole slaw was good though.I took one bite of the fish and fries and threw the dinner out.So did my house guess.It was a waste of my money.I will never order a fish dinner from here again.“

“5⭐ So, I've only **Uber eats** (for people talking bout they can't order online!!), from family tree, but I've done it 5x so far. The food has been excellent every single time! The gyro is bomb! they don't give you those skinny slabs of lamb, you get some diesel slabs of lamb. my girlfriend loves the Chicken souvlaki. and I just ordered the steak sandwich, they literally put a 10 oz strip steak on some delicious bread. it was so good, I felt like a Viking eating it, super manly sandwich. I've literally never had an issue with the quality or quantity of the food. it's been delicious every single time. 10/10 honestly, and I'll keep ordering my Greek and steak from them. the quantity can't be beat and the price ain't bad“

“Phenomenal service with a smile food is always hot delicious and very appealing plating“

“Great food. Great service“

“amazing food. great atmosphere and fantastic wait staff. I had the Western Cheddar omelet and it came with 3 full sized pancakes. delicious!“

“Fast and Friendly Service!I ordered from this restaurant during my stay at the Bufaloo Marriott. The food was absolutely delicious, and the bartender was friendly. I enjoyed the Strawberry Salad, also. Overall, a great restaurant

Vegetarian options: Strawberry Salad- arugula, spinach, feta cheese, walnuts, and strawberry dressing“

“Thank you Soooo much!! December 27, 2022 at 2:00 Very few restaurants open. Gail was great!!! Friendly, professional and efficient! Great to find you open. Our first time out after the driving ban and she was perfect! Glad to find you open and serving. Food was delicious and coffee was needed. I would hope management knows what a person like Gail is worth . Priceless to us :-) Lynn & Rick Lent Kenmore, NY 14217“

“I had a group catering order from here and this was my first time dealing with CoreLife. Everything was delivered on time (early, actually) and perfect. My group loved their bowl and wrap combos. Excellent all the way around and I'll definitely order from them again.“