11 Best American Restaurants in Lancaster

Lancaster's Broadway Deli Sandwich Shop • $
5430 Broadway, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tarragon Soup Du Jour
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Raspberry Smoked Turkey
Voodoo Chicken Sandwich
BBQ Pulled Pork Panini
Voodoo Buffalo Chicken
New York City Reuben
Macaroni Salad
Whole Pickle
Grilled Royal

“Our 2nd time here and like the 1st time nothing but amazing food and love everything about this place!!!!Parking: Not sure how many parking spots both times had any issues to find a parking spotKid-friendliness: Would definitely Bring our kids back here!!!“

4.7 Superb50 Reviews
99 Brick Oven Bar & Grille Bar & Grill • $$
99 Aurora St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza with Extra Mozzarella
Crock of French Onion Soup
Chicken Caprese Sandwich
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Stuffed Banana Peppers
Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel
Chicken Alla Milanese
German Potato Salad
Jumbo Chicken Wings
Sweet Potato Fries

“Drinks are great! Bartenders know what they're doing! Don't screw around, get the rosettes or a pizza! Amazing! Awesome service EVERY TIME!Parking: Small, tight lot especially trucks. But, there are sidewalks so street parking isn't too bad and Lancaster is a safe place.“

4.5 Superb62 Reviews
Lancaster Coffee Co. & Cafe Cafe • $
24 Central Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Avocado Toast
Sandwich
Bagel

“During a very difficult time for our family, Tracy and Jess went above and beyond to provide a beautiful breakfast tray of sandwiches with both regular and gluten free bread, bagels, cream cheese and more. The recipients all commented on how delicious everything was and how much they appreciated breakfast. More than anything, their care and compassion will not be forgotten. Thank you so much!“

4.5 Superb48 Reviews
Flavor Restaurant and Bar Sports Bar • $$
6432 Genesee St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Flavor Famous Chicken Thingers
Chicken Thinger Sandwich
Loaded Fries

“Our first time. We're "locals". We will DEFINITELY be frequenting! Had the Shep' Pie. Let me just say, mmm mmm MMM! The beef just melted and the sauce was exquisite! The veggies were perfectly cooked and everything was seasoned JUST RIGHT! No extra salt OR pepper needed!!! Other party members ENJOYED the thinger tenders, and thinger sandwich. (* explanation below)Their list of sauces is just WOW! It can be found on the chalkboard on the wall. ;) The fries, fresh cut of course (delightfully, a common theme of the menu!) Soups were PIPING hot! Also very, VERY good! We will definitely return and sample other items. * - Thinger - the are fresh made and not prepackaged. Party members indicated it was dark meat (thighs) or maybe a 50/50? I can not personally attest to that.“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews
Skoob's Village Grille Bar & Grill • $
50 Central Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

1 2 Beer Battered Fish Fry w Sides of Fries Cole Slaw Potatoes Salad and Macaroni Salad
Garlic Parmesan Fingers with Onion Rings
Hottest on the Menu- Skooby Lovin'
Chicken Tenders with Fries
Royal Submarine Sandwich
Royal Sub Outstanding
Beer Batter Fish Fry
Pot Roast Sandwich
Scooby Crack'd Corn
French Onion Soup

“We (my gf & I) come here very often, at least once a week & often bring our kids along too. The food is always amazing/ damn near perfect & so is the service. We often compliment our waiter or waitress & tell them how awesome their service is, you can ask them. Stephanie is awesome. If it’s slower, she’ll sit for a min & chat w/ us which we enjoy. Mandy is also awesome & one of our favorites! I personally like Colin best, very good server & always there to refill drinks & bring extra napkins, etc. He can take an order for a party of 5 without writing any of it down & not make a single mistake. On the other hand, Ellie is our least favorite & we dread getting her as our waitress. We’ve even brought company & without us saying a word they’ve commented on her poor service. She also never writes anything down & then makes several mistakes. I ordered 6 tacos w/ no sour cream & they came out w/ sour cream & I said I definitely didn’t order sour cream. No apology or anything just walked away w/ the food & later returned w/ 6 more w/ no sour cream. No, I’m sorry for the error/ delay or anything. Then the bill comes & the sour cream is on the bill for $4.50 which is 75¢/each. Not being a cheapskate but I’m not paying for something I didn’t get strictly out of principle. I questioned it & she was snippy & rude & says you’ll notice I took of the $4.50 at the bottom. I said no u took off 4.5% which is $1.20. She seemed even more annoyed & brought back the bill & it was finally correct. I’m definitely NOT that guy that likes to complain, bit#h & moan but not once was there any apology on any of the errors & she definitely lacks personality. Would it hurt to smile & be nice? I eat out often & again I love your food, several of your staff & love supporting a local family owned business that gives back to the community but I dread going there when I get her as my waitress cuz I don’t wanna be rude & refuse her but I’m very tempted to do so.“

4.2 Good83 Reviews
The Olive Tree Family • $
5240 Broadway, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Friday Fish Fry Mac Salad Potato Salad Cole Slaw Rye Bread
Bacon Cheeseburger w Extra Crispy Sweet Potato Fries
Double Trouble Bacon Cheese Burger
Chicken Souvlaki Breakfast
French Onion Soup
Chicken Souvlaki
Chicken Fingers
Home Fries
Chef Salad
Coleslaw

“Excellent greek food and homemade tzatziki. Personally we come for the souvlakis, gyros and greek potatoes. So delicious! The french onion soup is also very good- with rich broth and tons of cheese. Service is incredible and you really feel like family when you walk through the doors. They are so kind to the kids too. Always having coloring art displayed. Its one of our favorite places to go to. No matter day or night.“

4.2 Good64 Reviews
Green Buffalo Pub Pubs • $
165 Lake Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings
Fries

“Decent neighborhood bar. Not a huge draft selection but they have some good offerings on tap, including Warsteiner Dunkel the last time I was there. Didn't get food this time but previously have had their wings which were good. Service was fast and friendly.“

4 Good22 Reviews
Mooney's Sports Bar & Grill Sports Bar • $
6513 Broadway, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Rodeo Mac and Cheese
Macaroni and Cheese
Chicken Wings
Lobster Mac

“We saw the sign about Mac and cheese on our way to work... And stopped that evening lol. It was quite good. HUGE portion! As in we have eaten off it 3x! We got pizza rolls for an app, also good. My husband got the stinger Mac and I got chicken, bacon ranch Mac. I was stuffed and ate maybe 1/4?! We had some for lunch today, and there plenty for dinner left! Staff all very friendly. Food was out at a good pace too.“

3.8 Good34 Reviews
Al-E-Oops Barbecue • $$
5389 Genesee St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

The Hickory House BBQ Sampler
The Hickory House Combo
Authentic Pulled Pork
Haddock Fish Fry
Disco Fries
Chef Salad
Potato
Ribs

“Food was very hot and packed with flavor. The sever was friendly and had great suggestions on parting items. The atmosphere was coozy and modern. Chef visited the table and made small talk which never happens anymore. Was a life changing experience I would recommend to anyone.“

3.8 Good55 Reviews
Frank's Grille Grills • $
5820 Broadway, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Grouper Dinner
French Onion Soup
Grouper Fish Fry
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Wings
Beef on Weck
Cheeseburger
French Fries
French Dip

“Went in on a Friday night with my family and parents. I started with they're French Onion soup which was delicious, nice side small salad and has quesadillas. The quesadillas we're much larger than I anticipated and had nice big chunks of chicken. My husband has the grouper fish fry which I tried and was also extremely tasty! I feel like there's very few restaurants in the area (at least that I know of) that have Grouper on the menu regularly. My parents both had delicious meals, my toddler's chicken fingers were good. And if you get the chance to try the pistachio ricotta pie... It's to die for! Needless to say we will definitely be going back soon!Parking: Parking was packed but it was a Friday night. We were lucky to get a spot but I don't know where else you could park if the lot is full.Kid-friendliness: We have the absolute sweetest waitress whom my son fell in love with, but the staff was so nice about bringing over colored pencils and bringing his food out as soon as it was ready.“

3.8 Good80 Reviews
Two Guys Pizza Pizza • $
3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Finger
Cheeseburger
Meatball
Turkey
Wings
Pizza

“Variety of pizza topping and sauce make them unique in the specialty pizza game. But their subs are no joke either and they have a large variety of drinks to go with their food.Dietary restrictions: Hubby is gluten intolerant and when he worked close to hear they would be able to make his sub without cross contamination during lunch rush“

3.5 Good40 Reviews
Loading...
map Map