15 Best American Restaurants in Orchard Park

“As always, Mangia does not disappoint. Our only critique is the service time. We waited ages for our drinks, for our server to take our order and had to get up and request the bill long after we had finished dessert. The service itself was great, friendly and professional. Food was delicious. The tortellini is the underdog as our server noted, it has a light cream sauce and crispy meat—filling yet light.

We also enjoyed the pistachio cheesecake paired with the vanilla ice cream and wow, what a delight!

Kid-friendliness: We were able to bring our stroller in with no issues!“

“Went there for my birthday burger which I really loved. The waitress never came back after I requested additional fries until it was time for us to leave which she gave me a container to take some home... not the same as eating them with my birthday burger. Appreciate the kind gesture of offering the birthday burger. Waitress was not very attentive We asked for other things. She just didn't get for us. . She didn't deliver our food she delivered our bill.... We had a small child with us we asked for a small spoon that never happened we had to find one ourselves. It's for the burger it was delicious. Cook to perfection.

Wheelchair accessibility: No issues“

“Always stop there when I’m in town“

“Nice atmosphere, great food and service!“

“3rd or 4th time here! Had a taste for a burger so looked at menus around town. Found the Mac Daddy here and was sold!! Nice, thick 10 oz burger, med rare, juicy and delicious! Tots were excellent also. Crispy and well seasoned. My girl had a chicken sandwich which she enjoyed as well. 5 cheese stuffed peppers may have been the star of the show!! Fantastic!!
Only minor thing is thr road noise. Through no fault of prohibition, sat outside and that busy intersection was LOUD!
Still goin back!!“

“Buffalo's Best Grill in Orchard Park, NY, offers a casual dining atmosphere praised for its friendly staff, quality food, and a wide selection of craft beers and cocktails. The establishment is celebrated for its home-cooking style comfort food, with a menu that boasts favorites like The Prime Rib Sandwich, House Smoked Beef Brisket, and a unique take on Pizza Logs​​​​. The venue features 7 flat-screen TVs and hosts special events, making it a perfect spot for relaxing meals or gathering for drinks​​.However, based on your personal experience, while the service was adequate, the overall dining experience didn't stand out as exceptional. The prime rib, a highlight for many visitors, was found to be overly fatty by your family, contributing to an overall perception of the food being average for bar fare but not compelling enough to warrant a special trip. Despite the large space being seen as an advantage for pre-game gatherings for Bills games and concerts at the stadium, the combination of the drive and the overall dining experience doesn't encourage a return visit on your part.This reflects a broader spectrum of experiences at Buffalo's Best Grill, where, alongside many positive reviews, there are instances of customers having expectations that weren't fully met. As with any restaurant, experiences can vary, and what might be a draw for one visitor—such as the ambiance and suitability for large events—may not compensate for perceived shortcomings in food quality and overall value for another.“

“Fantastic food as always!!!!“

“great food, great service and friendly atmosphere.“

“Absolutely wonderful experience. Our server Bobby Jo was excellent. Apologized for our wait, which actually was no wait at all. Checked on us often Refilled Drinks in a timely manner.
Food was excellent (turkey dinner ,salad). My dinner companion had chicken tenders which he said was just right (and he is picky).

Manager Todd came to check on us as well, very friendly,and made sure we didn’t need anything. Definitely going back.“

“First time in the area for a Bills game- From Toronto, Ontario..was trying to find a place that was open for some food for after the game. Stumbled upon Kettles. We called from the car asking if we could do an order for pick up. They initially said they usually don’t do that on game nights and prefer people to dine-in. We mentioned that we were driving back to Toronto that night- agreed to make the wings and could pick them up in 20minutes.Did not realize they were a cash only and explained that I didn’t know if my bank card would work in their atm being from Canada- the lady that I was dealing with offered that I could venmo her the amount (Canada doesn’t have venmo) ATM worked. Wings were paid for. Service was great. Staff was very friendly. Wings were AMAZING. Will be a for sure stop every time I’m back on American soil.“

“Always great food. I have been a customer since they opened and have never had a bad meal.“

“Always enjoy. Would definitely recommend…love the real cream served with coffee…!“

“Good menu , food is good, served hot and timely, the staff is friendly, and the restaurant is clean!“

“While we have always enjoyed our meals at The Mansard in the past, our last two visits have been uninspiring. Our most recent visit on 8/3 was average at best. The bartender had BOTH sliding glass doors (no screens) open in the bar area causing swarms of flies to circle us our ENTIRE meal, in the dining area. Although friendly, our waitress said there were no specials that evening, after I specifically asked what the specials were. I overheard other waitresses telling patrons what the specials were, so I knew there WERE specials. The musty smell of the stained drapery needs to be replaced ASAP, as the odor hits you as soon as you get to the front door. Please be better and ACT like the "fine" dining restaurant you want to be! Very disappointed...The food is the ONLY thing worth coming to The Mansard for...We miss Steve!!“

“Great meal..fast friendly service!our server Sam was the best ..he went above and beyond! Super place! The filets are the best!!

Parking: Just a great place for dinner..fast great service I've never had a bad steak there!“