14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Orchard Park

Toni's Deli Deli • $
5490 Lake Ave, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Finger
Toni's Sub
Royal Sub
Steak
Wings

“My go-to sub place. I live right down the road and go there ALL THE TIME. The subs are delicious and are -in my opinion- 10/10 subs. If you are looking for something new to try I totally recommend Toni's Deli. Amazing service as well everyone is very nice I always know I'm getting what I want when I go there because some places mess up orders or give you the wrong things, Toni's Deli? No way never not once have I gotten what I didn't want. 10/10 recommend.“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Pappaceno's Pizza Pizza • $
4151 N Buffalo St, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings
Sheet Pizza
White Pizza

“It may be a little small inside, but don't let looks deceive you because this is where you'll find the best pizza in the area. Not only is the pizza great, but their subs and wings are fantastic too. I'll be coming here for food as long as they keep making it.“

4.3 Superb24 Reviews
Black Smoke Bourbon Bar Bar • $$
50 Buffalo Street, Hamburg

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Pizza

“Bottomless Mimosas ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Black Smoke Bourbon Bar, I had brunch, the menu was simple, the main squeeze of the menu was the Bottomless mimosas option.There are no vegan options, they should have vegan Chorizo.The pay person is 10-20pp if you’re not having cocktails. Parking is available in the lot a couple doors down from the restaurant.Enjoy“

4.1 Good48 Reviews
Anjon's Pizzeria Pizza • $
5427 S Abbott Rd, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Finger
Stinger Sub

“I never leave reviews but in this case one needs to be written! Simply put, pizza is incredible! Ordered 4 sheets for a birthday party and everyone came away very impressed and asked about where it was from! Kids that normally do not eat pizza, could not get enough! I called the day before and they were very appreciative. I will definitely order from here again! Great job!“

4.1 Good25 Reviews
Genesse Pizza • $$
7025 Ellicott Rd, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Finger
Caesar Salad
Large Pizza
Fish Fry

“It's on my way home from school now. I stop about every day. I'm never disappointed. I've been eating their pizza for a long time and still love it. I'll be making my stops there on my way home until further notice. It's great there“

4 Good9 Reviews
Pino's Pizza Italian • $$
3864 Abbott, 3864a Abbott Rd, Orchard Park

“I thought this was going to be your typical “Buffalo” pizza. It’s not! It’s so much better! The crust is incredible! Very tasty pizza! Service was awesome! I just don’t like that you have to pay at the bar, sometimes. They do have a few tables for sit down and the parking is great! I can see this place being packed for The Bills game for sure!!! It is a little pricey for a pizza as a large cheese pizza was $25.01. I usually don’t buy pizza over $20. I would definitely come back, here though. Very yummy!!!!Kid-friendliness: As long as they don’t have you paying at the bar, you can bring the kiddos for sit down on the pizza side.“

3.8 Good8 Reviews
Rix Country Store Pizza • $
3545 N Buffalo St, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tikka Masala
Chicken Vindaloo
Butter Chicken
Chicken Curry
Samosas
Naan

“While you might not expect to find delicious, authentic India flavours here, don't worry...you will.Cleverly placed in a convenience type store location, is a kitchen staffed with folks who know how to deliver great food.You can see them as they cook, which is always appreciated.The lamb was marvelously tender and the butter chicken did not disappoint.“

3.8 Good37 Reviews
Buffalo's Best Grill American • $
3700 Southwestern Blvd, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza
Open Prime Rib Sandwich
Stinger Mac & Cheese
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Buffalo's Best Wings
Bacon Cheddar Burger
Antipasto Platter
Chicken Wing Dip
Stuffed Peppers
Grouper Reuben

“Buffalo's Best Grill in Orchard Park, NY, offers a casual dining atmosphere praised for its friendly staff, quality food, and a wide selection of craft beers and cocktails. The establishment is celebrated for its home-cooking style comfort food, with a menu that boasts favorites like The Prime Rib Sandwich, House Smoked Beef Brisket, and a unique take on Pizza Logs​​​​. The venue features 7 flat-screen TVs and hosts special events, making it a perfect spot for relaxing meals or gathering for drinks​​.However, based on your personal experience, while the service was adequate, the overall dining experience didn't stand out as exceptional. The prime rib, a highlight for many visitors, was found to be overly fatty by your family, contributing to an overall perception of the food being average for bar fare but not compelling enough to warrant a special trip. Despite the large space being seen as an advantage for pre-game gatherings for Bills games and concerts at the stadium, the combination of the drive and the overall dining experience doesn't encourage a return visit on your part.This reflects a broader spectrum of experiences at Buffalo's Best Grill, where, alongside many positive reviews, there are instances of customers having expectations that weren't fully met. As with any restaurant, experiences can vary, and what might be a draw for one visitor—such as the ambiance and suitability for large events—may not compensate for perceived shortcomings in food quality and overall value for another.“

3.8 Good94 Reviews
Ricotta's Pizza Pasta Subs Pizza Delivery • $
7025 Ellicott Rd, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fingers
Chicken Wings
Pizza Sub
Steak Sub

“Took a cruise out from So. Buffalo to get a couple of subs. It was worth the ride. It's the only place we know of that melts the cheese, and that's makes the sub. Also, the price doesn't break the bank. We will definitely be back.Parking: You can eat in, or they have tables outside when the weather is nice out. Handicap parking is available.“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
Cappelli's Pizzeria Pizza • $
3643 N Buffalo St #1933, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings and Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“We have ordered from there last three to four Sundays antipastos are great this time got wrap tuna sub and calzone yummy and only takes 20 minutes for your order it was my birthday we had great meals and we spent about 45 dollars with large portionsParking: Ample parking“

3.7 Good35 Reviews
Spot Coffee Cafe • $
6519 E Quaker St, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwich

“Spot Coffee is one of my favorite places to go! I can't get enough of a drink so simple, their house, coffee! They also have delicious breakfast options. My favorite is the breakfast wrap. The atmosphere is quaint, I like being able to go upstairs and get work done while enjoying a cup of coffee. And when it's nice out, sitting outside on the patio is beautiful! I highly recommend trying to buy coffee“

3.7 Good39 Reviews
Leo's Pizzeria Pizza • $
2220 Southwestern Blvd, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Large Cheese & Pepperoni 17''
Hot and Sexy Wings
Cheese Pizza Slice
Chicken Finger Sub
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
French Fries
Caesar Salad
Antipasto
Steak Sub

“I only started to go to Leo's a couple years back. Normally I'm very pleased with their products. Good pizza, salads, cheesey bread sticks, tacos. All great. Dined in last night for subs and wings. Mildly disappointed. The wings were much smaller than usual and overcooked. The sub roll was over toasted. It was 50¢ wing night so maybe they substituted an inferior product compared to the rest of the week?“

3.7 Good66 Reviews
The Byrd House Bar & Grill • $$
4190 N Buffalo St, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Three Cheese Stuffed Banana Peppers
Chicken Souvlaki Wrap
Turkey Club Sandwich
Flaming Byrd Burger
Fried Bologna Deluxe
Sweet Potato Fries
Pot Roast Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Cuban Sandwich
Fried Bologna

“The Byrd house is my second home. For starters, the staff takes pride and joy in providing great service for each and every customer. The bosses, managers, and employees strive to make each customer’s experience great and memorable. The menu is crafted from quality ingredients and the cooks work very hard to make consistent, quality, and delicious food. The atmosphere is very cozy and comfortable and casual. I recommend the Byrd house to everyone on this planet.Dietary restrictions: We offer many dietary options for anyone with allergies or dietary restrictions.Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly! There’s even a duck machine in the front to play!Wheelchair accessibility: Back ramp behind the building!“

3.6 Good87 Reviews
Pie O Mine Greens Pizza • $
3229 Southwestern Blvd, Orchard Park

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Pizza
Caesar Salad Large
Margherita Pizza

“I love coming here! I am hooked on the Concord grape salad dressing (so unique) and the build your own options. The menu of salad bar and pizza makes me feel like I'm getting a well balanced meal of something healthy and something tasty all with super fresh ingredients made right in front of my eyes. My fave menu item here is the bbq chicken pizza (wood oven) and build your own salad with lots of goodies topped with Concord grape dressing. The portion to pricing ratio is very fair imo as you can choose diff sizes for each. The menu is full yet not overwhelming making it easy to choose. Find myself always wishing for more types of these fast casual places to pop up!“

3.5 Good45 Reviews
Loading...
map Map