15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Orchard Park

“my favorite lunch spot!! The pizza is absolutley AMAZING!! All the workers are extremely polite and the service is really fast.“

“The best Pizzeria in Orchard Park. Been buying pizza, wings and subs for many years and have never had an issue. Top quality food at a fair price with a large variety to choose from.“

“We are obsessed with their indian cuisine, it's so good with huge portions and always arrives hot when we order delivery! We try to order at least once a week now ? The lamb mahkani is my absolute favorite but everything is sooo good, their desserts and lassi are to die for too! I never cared about Rix much before to be honest, not that it was bad it just didn't stand out much to us, but now it's our go-to for takeout nights! Love!“

“Food is delicious! Very Reasonable Priced!“

“Had our Dad’s 70th party here. The staff were super accommodating and the food was brought out with no issues! We got a couple sheet pizzas, wings, and chicken fingers and they were all great. Had an open tab going for about 30 people and the final bill was significantly lower than we expected! I would recommend having your event at Leo’s.“

“Took a cruise out from So. Buffalo to get a couple of subs. It was worth the ride. It's the only place we know of that melts the cheese, and that's makes the sub. Also, the price doesn't break the bank. We will definitely be back.

Parking: You can eat in, or they have tables outside when the weather is nice out. Handicap parking is available.“

“Gerard and the staff at Cappelli’s Pizzeria helped us throw together a luncheon for my grieving family, after the loss of my sister. They made their clean dining area available, the food was delicious and their service was awesome! I will always recommend this restaurant! I can’t thank them enough!“

“Ellicott Rd location never disappoints. meatball sub is delicious. pizza if the month (spinach) was really good. lots of toppings, really good crust. it's like a white pizza on steroids!“

“Ryleigh was our bartender a few nights ago and was such a sweetheart! I couldn’t recommend more! The drinks were phenomenal!“

“Also very good service and wide menu“

“Got a cup of house blend today and all day kept thinking about what a great cup of coffee it was. Highly recommend.“

“Pizza is great, antipasto is very friendly sized and lots of stuff they put in it good chicken wings to boot. Never got to the entrees doubt they were bad. Found out today they’re closing absolutely breaks my heart must have ordered from them 5-10 times absolutely sucks since I’m now 5 mins around the corner from them. Good job on running a great business my heart breaks for you guys good luck on your next adventure!“

“I love little Caesars pizza. I am a disabled senior citizen and I order from them quite frequently. I ordered last night and I never received my order. The DoorDash gentleman never called me to say he was having problems finding my apartment. So I called Little Caesars and it seems there’s nothing they can do about it although they have my $20 Because it would screw up their computer system if they gave me my order that I already paid for. They said I have to take it up with DoorDash I don’t see why since I paid a little Caesars the money I cannot afford to be out $20 and that he had the food that I ordered. I have tried to contact DoorDash but that is like mission impossible so it looks like I am going to be out $20 I never received my order and Little Caesars will not replace my order so it looks like I will not be getting food from Little Caesars again if this is the way they treat disabled senior citizens.“

“The Byrd House is a reflection of how I remembered the establishment from when I fist moved to OP. Very Friendly, can come alone or with group. Always welcome, hometown feel. Long bar area on one side and dining on the other. Good cooks with delicious menu! My first choice of where to go to relax. Thank You.“

“Buffalo's Best Grill in Orchard Park, NY, offers a casual dining atmosphere praised for its friendly staff, quality food, and a wide selection of craft beers and cocktails. The establishment is celebrated for its home-cooking style comfort food, with a menu that boasts favorites like The Prime Rib Sandwich, House Smoked Beef Brisket, and a unique take on Pizza Logs​​​​. The venue features 7 flat-screen TVs and hosts special events, making it a perfect spot for relaxing meals or gathering for drinks​​.However, based on your personal experience, while the service was adequate, the overall dining experience didn't stand out as exceptional. The prime rib, a highlight for many visitors, was found to be overly fatty by your family, contributing to an overall perception of the food being average for bar fare but not compelling enough to warrant a special trip. Despite the large space being seen as an advantage for pre-game gatherings for Bills games and concerts at the stadium, the combination of the drive and the overall dining experience doesn't encourage a return visit on your part.This reflects a broader spectrum of experiences at Buffalo's Best Grill, where, alongside many positive reviews, there are instances of customers having expectations that weren't fully met. As with any restaurant, experiences can vary, and what might be a draw for one visitor—such as the ambiance and suitability for large events—may not compensate for perceived shortcomings in food quality and overall value for another.“