50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elma

“Best Pizza in the area. Tastes like the way I remember pizza to tast.“

“I was driving by and stopped in for the assorted sub, I was not disappointed. I highly recommend you stop in .“

“Great friendly staff.. Excellent food. Have eaten at this restaurant multiple times. The food has always been fantastic! Cannot say enough good things about the restaurant, and the staff!“

“Ordered 3 times- first time, wings which were great. 2nd time, ordered 2 subs, got home and one was a completely different sub than what was ordered. Today ordered the works pizza. Told them peppers only on half. Asks me if I want sweet or hot peppers. I said, it says on the menu, you get both, but I only want them on half. I pick up and it has hot peppers on half, green peppers on the whole thing. When I said something I was told I said sweet on half. Uh, no I said peppers on half which means all peppers should only be on half and why is it my orders keep getting screwed up. Get home and the toppings were barely cooked. Peppers and onions were just about raw and the pepperoni was barely cooked.“

“I have been craving a great, NY style pizza for a long time. This place knocked it out of the park! The pizza was crispy and delicious! The perfect foldable slice. Let’s talk about these amazing garlic knots too! Amazing! My husband said the staff is extremely polite and welcoming! I can’t wait to try another pizza!“

“I can't say enough about this place. There are several pizzerias near us, but on a whim looking for something different (not super crazy about the ones we usually order from) we ordered a regular pizza from them and it didn't disappoint! Just perfect. Our daughter is getting sick of pizza, but loved it. The next time we ordered their white pizza which again delicious and lots of cheese! Last night we tried their subs. WOW! I have not had a chicken finger sub that good in forever. Perfect amt of everything and didnt skimp on toppings. Our daughter was in heaven. The owners are so friendly too. Now our go to place. Try them if you haven't yet!“

“Very delicious, clean and friendly atmosphere.“

“This place has excellent food and Carl is a true gem of the food service industry.“

“I hesitate to give a great review because it will start to get really crowded, but its GREAT. The best sauce ever and really great thin crust pizza. The people who work there are friendly, personable, and eager to make sure you have a wonderful experience. In short, AMAZING“

“We have been getting food from Grasso's on Transit Rd. In Depew, NY for quite some time now...they have delicious choices and generous portions. All of their workers and delivery people are so glad to assist us...I would give Grasso's a 10 out of 5 for their food and service!!! Highly recommend this restaurant to people in this area and will continue to use and refer others to try them out. Thanks for the great food & service!“

“The staff there is extremely nice. Always a pleasure ordering from them.“

“We had fish fry. It was by far the best fish fry we have ever had. Couldn’t even eat 1/2 of it.“

“incredible food! ordered for the first time tonight. so impressed. new pizza joint for us.“

“The BEST Italian food ever. I've been many, many time in the restaurant as well as caterer food for the Christmas Holidays for years and years. I wouldn't choose anywhere else. Thanks for such great service and being so friendly. Lorenzo gets an A+++“

“The Britesmith has the best burger I have ever had! Will definitely go back!“

“I absolutely would recommend Johnny’s. Our party of 9 walked in and was instantly greeted with the warmest Buffalo welcome during half time. We were out celebrating my son’s 12th birthday, it also happened to be an employees birthday. They brought out a piece of cake(his favorite too!) right before serving us with 4 huge pizza pies and appetizers. We live over an hour away and cannot wait to come back. Thank you guys, fantastic dining experience we appreciate it!!! ❤️💙“

“Ordered a pizza sub and fries this evening. They were both fantastic!!! Joey’s always hits the spot!“

“Great food and beautiful atmosphere! Been here many times and it's been a great experience every time!! Enjoyed Mothers day with my large family today and we had a wonderful brunch buffet! Great service all around!!!“

“Thank You Sugo's for an early dinner. After making food for 8 hours, it's great to have it done for you. Always courteous and efficient (Sarah ?) Now that I know your hours, you'll probably see me a lot more.“

“Definitely recommend!! Just had the best hot wings I’ve had in YEARS! Whatever you guys are doing, keep it up! Seriously, your cooks absolutely rocked our socks off tonight. The wings were spicy with a nice after burn and they expertly walked the line between well-sauced but not slimy. The pizza was great too, as well a couple subs we ordered. Pizza works also has great chicken fingers, fries and onion rings. They have been very reliably great the past year or so with fast service“

“Amazing perfect yummy I will be back.“

“I've originally grown up on NYC/Jersey pizza but living in Bflo.in upstate NY I had never known how gr8 Mattina's pizza was until I had it 2-yrs ago and couldn't stop ordering it baked light quick well done on top and their sauce is Amazing if only they would put Xtra sauce when you pay Xtra for it is rlly the only thing I've noticed that they don't do anymore. I have to drive 3-hrs to get their pizza now since I moved to Hilton.Pls.dont bogart on the sauce bring back your proud pizza so my guest can be your #1fans of the best pizza this side of New York!“

“Order well done / thin crust. Best pie I had in Buffalo, compared to the thick“

“Ordered a pizza sub and fries this evening. They were both fantastic!!! Joey’s always hits the spot!“

“Moons is awesome! Great prices.. great food...family friendly place! We think highly of the owner!“

“Excellent food, great pizza, great sandwiches, and most of all great people. If you haven’t been by, I highly suggested give them a try.“

“Just had the slice and salad lunch combo from the Union Rd. location. Very good.“

“Everything I've ever tried at Mayback's has been delicious. From the breakfast pizza to the regular pizza. This is one of the only places in the 716 that makes good chicken fingers (the honey mustard ones are divine) and a good cheese steak. The fish fry is the best I've had in years. If you want a real treat try the turkey sub with pickles and extra meat. The freshest salads I've ever had. Food is amazing, prices are great, and everyone who works there is friendly. They've got something for everyone. Easily my favorite place to get food in Buffalo.“

“Amazing perfect yummy I will be back.“

“I've ordered here before for a regular Cheese and Pepperoni pizza a long while back. It was pretty good. Haven't ordered for a bit, and gave it a go again, but this time with your Meat Lovers Pizza.
All I got to say is this was the best pizza ive ever had anywhere in the area.
You for sure earned another customer. Thank you so much!“

“A small, hang out vibe pizza place. We aren't from the area and wanted something local, and this was one of the options that came up.

We ordered a few slices of pizza and some garlic bread with drinks. That was enough garlic bread for four people so for just the two of us, I was a happy girl.

The pizza was good, nothing special that I will remember for life but it definitely tasted authentic and not chain restaurant.

It reminded me of a pizza joint that my cousin in Arizona used to own back in the 90s and it was nostalgic for me.“

“Great pizza, kind staff. I'll never get pizza from anywhere else, this place is #1! 👏🏻👏🏻“

“love your pizza wish I could have gotten a whole slice“

“LTS is by far the best pizza ! All the food on their menu are awesome ! Can’t say enough about this place , food is great the employees are soooo friendly , delivery comes very fast and food is hot when delivered , also delivery ppl are very friendly too ! They all seem to go out of their way to please ! If you haven’t tried LTS your missing out big time !!! Sooo good“

“I am from florida and my friend told me about this place. It was fantastic. the homemade soups to the homemade pies. wings were perfect and the bruchetta was to die for.“

“The Garlic/cheese broiled/ baked fish ,coleslaw finely cut, fresh cut fries, pasta salad and garlic toast. Total perfection. Can I also mention boho drinks from 3-6 ….pizza n wings on Wednesday muaah😊love!!!“

“my favorite lunch spot!! The pizza is absolutley AMAZING!! All the workers are extremely polite and the service is really fast.“

“Leo's serves fantastic food. If you are looking for greasy or fried food done right, Leo's is the place to go. They offer salads as well. My husband loves the wings there. I attached my personal pan white pizza order to this review. It's always tough to decide on what to order here, because everything on the menu is sooo good.
There's a large horse-shoe bar, with huge TVs displaying movies or sports games.
The restaurant has a separate take-out counter attached. For those looking to dine in, booth, table, high top, bar, and patio seating are offered. The gated patio has an awning, string lights, and a firepit. It's very vibe-y.
They have a huge beer menu. The cocktails are okay, not my favorite. I wish they sold White Claws or Trulys. I'm not sure why they offer vodka seltzers but not those 2 major brands.
The servers are quite attentive, but not super friendly.
Leo's is open late, and often a go-to after sports games, homecomings, or simply long days.“

“Been going here for years. Great pizza and good prices. The staff are top notch too 😀“

“Pizza, chicken wings, subs and even the fries are always delicious. Best customer service as well“

“I used Uber eats to order a general tsao's Pizza, its something I never heard of before so I gave it a shot since it's my go-to Chinese meal! It was absolutely delicious, you guys nailed it with this one but then again over the years I've never gotten food that wasn't delicious here!“

“The Legacy Papas to me is the best of all Papas.The taste is what I've been looking for.Price is reasonable.“

“We got the thick large rectangular pizza. I gave 4 stars because they use CANNED mushrooms not fresh. ALSO, how do you not give blue cheese dressing with wings!?!? Also, NO carrots and NO celery!?! No place to sit, except small table for condiments. This place is for takeout.“

“Wish I could give this place 5 stars BUT…
While the food comes out fresh and hot (or cold, however you ordered) the price is a bit outrageous. $60 for 4 subs and a side of fries!? Not to mention that sometimes my sub comes with something I didn’t ask for, mainly lettuce. Wish the employee would repeat the order back to double check. The food is delicious, I recommend the fish fry! Mainly gets subs here, but occasionally get the fish or a salad - very rarely get pizza here, but it is delicious when I do!“

“Excellent foods, awesome prices, great staff“

“First time dining at Bobby J’s and loved it!!! We will be going back!!“

“Giancarlo’s was absolutely incredible. We had our ceremony there and I truly cannot say enough amazing things about the entire experience. From the very beginning, Hannah, the event coordinator, was beyond phenomenal. She made everything feel easy, organized, and completely stress free. Every detail was handled so seamlessly and it honestly felt like she cared just as much about our day as we did. Everything went off without a hitch and that is not something you can say often when it comes to events like this. Tori, our server, was just as amazing. Attentive, kind, on top of everything without ever making us feel rushed or overwhelmed. She made sure we were taken care of every step of the way and brought such a great energy to the day. The food, the atmosphere, the service, all of it was top tier. You can tell this team takes so much pride in what they do and it shows in every single detail. They truly went above and beyond anything we expected and made our ceremony feel so special. We are so grateful we chose Giancarlo’s. If you are thinking about hosting anything here, do it. You will not regret it.“

“was there for my birthday on 3/11 with my kids .we had a very nice time .“

“picked up the 20" and 30 wings for the sabres game. absolutely fantastic big wings cooked just right saucy!! pizza was just as good. nice crispy? chewy crust. and a good deal on top of it.“