50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elma

“Best Pizza in the area. Tastes like the way I remember pizza to tast.“

“I was driving by and stopped in for the assorted sub, I was not disappointed. I highly recommend you stop in .“

“Ordered 3 times- first time, wings which were great. 2nd time, ordered 2 subs, got home and one was a completely different sub than what was ordered. Today ordered the works pizza. Told them peppers only on half. Asks me if I want sweet or hot peppers. I said, it says on the menu, you get both, but I only want them on half. I pick up and it has hot peppers on half, green peppers on the whole thing. When I said something I was told I said sweet on half. Uh, no I said peppers on half which means all peppers should only be on half and why is it my orders keep getting screwed up. Get home and the toppings were barely cooked. Peppers and onions were just about raw and the pepperoni was barely cooked.“

“Great friendly staff.. Excellent food. Have eaten at this restaurant multiple times. The food has always been fantastic! Cannot say enough good things about the restaurant, and the staff!“

“These guys are doing it right. It's a neighborhood shop with big NYC pizza taste and quality. The pizza is delicious, there are many varieties to suit all tastes, and the owners are super friendly. It's worth going out of your way for a slice or whole pie. Try the Grandma pizza!“

“This is the BEST pizza Ive had in the 716! Buffalo Chicken wing is perfection....and classic Cheese and Pepperoni is sooo good! Pickle pizza is next up! You must try it!!!! The Family is pretty cool too! 😉🍕“

“Very delicious, clean and friendly atmosphere.“

“I hesitate to give a great review because it will start to get really crowded, but its GREAT. The best sauce ever and really great thin crust pizza. The people who work there are friendly, personable, and eager to make sure you have a wonderful experience. In short, AMAZING“

“This place has excellent food and Carl is a true gem of the food service industry.“

“We had fish fry. It was by far the best fish fry we have ever had. Couldn’t even eat 1/2 of it.“

“The BEST Italian food ever. I've been many, many time in the restaurant as well as caterer food for the Christmas Holidays for years and years. I wouldn't choose anywhere else. Thanks for such great service and being so friendly. Lorenzo gets an A+++“

“We have ordered several different items on many occasions. Every time the staff, quality and prices are unmatched. highly recommended.“

“The Britesmith has the best burger I have ever had! Will definitely go back!“

“The staff there is extremely nice. Always a pleasure ordering from them.“

“Thank You Sugo's for an early dinner. After making food for 8 hours, it's great to have it done for you. Always courteous and efficient (Sarah ?) Now that I know your hours, you'll probably see me a lot more.“

“BEST PIE IN AND AROUND BUFFALO!!! THE TOPPINGS ARE TOOOOO GENEROUS AND THE FLAVOR IS ONE TO SAVOR!!! THE ONLY COMPLAINT I HAD WAS TOOO MANY SELECTIONS I WANTED TO TRY AND NOT ENOUGH ROOM IN MY BELLY!!! GREAT BILLS/SABRES ATMOSPHERE AND IF YOU'RE LUCKY THE OWNER SITS DOWN TO EAT WITH YA AND YOU HAVE ONE OF THE BEST CONVERSATIONS IN YOUR LIFE!! ILL BE STOPPING HERE EVERYTIME I COME CLOSE TO THIS CITY!! BUFFALO HAS A GEM IN JOHNNY'S PIZZERIA & RESTAURANT!! THANKS MARK FOR A MEMORABLE AND DELICIOUS TIME!! TILL WE MEET/EAT AGAIN MY FRIEMD!“

“Amazing perfect yummy I will be back.“

“The owner has made an effort to provide plant based options at Grasso's. Please see the photo I provided as an update to the old photos here: Follow Your Heart Moz and Field Roast Pep. Will not come cut to prevent cross contamination. It's tough to find vegan friendly cheese AND pep to go. Crust is super tasty as well. Please try Grasso's you won't be disappointed.“

“Order well done / thin crust. Best pie I had in Buffalo, compared to the thick“

“The pizza here is phenomenal! It’s a classic 'Buffalo' style with a generous amount of toppings and a perfect, slightly charred crust on the bottom. Truly delicious.
​The wings, however, were a bit of a mixed bag. While they were a great size and perfectly crispy, they had almost no sauce on them. We ordered Medium and Mild, but both tasted as if they hadn't been sauced at all. I’m hoping it was just a one-off mistake, as the quality of the chicken was great. I’ll definitely give them another shot!“

“Great pizza, kind staff. I'll never get pizza from anywhere else, this place is #1! 👏🏻👏🏻“

“Great food and beautiful atmosphere! Been here many times and it's been a great experience every time!! Enjoyed Mothers day with my large family today and we had a wonderful brunch buffet! Great service all around!!!“

“Definitely recommend!! Just had the best hot wings I’ve had in YEARS! Whatever you guys are doing, keep it up! Seriously, your cooks absolutely rocked our socks off tonight. The wings were spicy with a nice after burn and they expertly walked the line between well-sauced but not slimy. The pizza was great too, as well a couple subs we ordered. Pizza works also has great chicken fingers, fries and onion rings. They have been very reliably great the past year or so with fast service“

“Ordered a pizza sub and fries this evening. They were both fantastic!!! Joey’s always hits the spot!“

“Excellent food, great pizza, great sandwiches, and most of all great people. If you haven’t been by, I highly suggested give them a try.“

“Just had the slice and salad lunch combo from the Union Rd. location. Very good.“

“Amazing perfect yummy I will be back.“

“Ordered a pizza sub and fries this evening. They were both fantastic!!! Joey’s always hits the spot!“

“Moons is awesome! Great prices.. great food...family friendly place! We think highly of the owner!“

“Anyone who wrote a review less than 5 stars is delusional. This is such a great business and pizzeria. My go to order is large cheese and pepperoni, with 20 wings (medium & crispy). I think the value for the price is incredible, and the staff is incredibly kind. I wish this business all the best.“

“I've ordered here before for a regular Cheese and Pepperoni pizza a long while back. It was pretty good. Haven't ordered for a bit, and gave it a go again, but this time with your Meat Lovers Pizza.
All I got to say is this was the best pizza ive ever had anywhere in the area.
You for sure earned another customer. Thank you so much!“

“The Garlic/cheese broiled/ baked fish ,coleslaw finely cut, fresh cut fries, pasta salad and garlic toast. Total perfection. Can I also mention boho drinks from 3-6 ….pizza n wings on Wednesday muaah😊love!!!“

“LTS is by far the best pizza ! All the food on their menu are awesome ! Can’t say enough about this place , food is great the employees are soooo friendly , delivery comes very fast and food is hot when delivered , also delivery ppl are very friendly too ! They all seem to go out of their way to please ! If you haven’t tried LTS your missing out big time !!! Sooo good“

“my favorite lunch spot!! The pizza is absolutley AMAZING!! All the workers are extremely polite and the service is really fast.“

“Everything I've ever tried at Mayback's has been delicious. From the breakfast pizza to the regular pizza. This is one of the only places in the 716 that makes good chicken fingers (the honey mustard ones are divine) and a good cheese steak. The fish fry is the best I've had in years. If you want a real treat try the turkey sub with pickles and extra meat. The freshest salads I've ever had. Food is amazing, prices are great, and everyone who works there is friendly. They've got something for everyone. Easily my favorite place to get food in Buffalo.“

“I am from florida and my friend told me about this place. It was fantastic. the homemade soups to the homemade pies. wings were perfect and the bruchetta was to die for.“

“Had my first Pan Pizza ! Delicious. The crust was so good, the sauce was not too sweet and the cost! $9.00 plus tax. Will definitely be ordering again .“

“love your pizza wish I could have gotten a whole slice“

“I slept on this place for years after I actually tried them last year realized what I was missing if you haven't had ferris what you waiting for?!?!“

“Been going here for years. Great pizza and good prices. The staff are top notch too 😀“

“Pizza, chicken wings, subs and even the fries are always delicious. Best customer service as well“

“The Legacy Papas to me is the best of all Papas.The taste is what I've been looking for.Price is reasonable.“

“We had never heard of this place before, but we decided to order a large pepperoni pizza from here and it was quite good. The pepperoni was tasty but came as a bit of a shock, considering the usual Buffalo cup and char style of pepperoni common to the area. The pizza was good, but not particularly noteworthy. The pizza was somewhat soft and was like a more expensive Dominos. But most of us liked it! It was pretty good.“

“Excellent foods, awesome prices, great staff“

“Wish I could give this place 5 stars BUT…
While the food comes out fresh and hot (or cold, however you ordered) the price is a bit outrageous. $60 for 4 subs and a side of fries!? Not to mention that sometimes my sub comes with something I didn’t ask for, mainly lettuce. Wish the employee would repeat the order back to double check. The food is delicious, I recommend the fish fry! Mainly gets subs here, but occasionally get the fish or a salad - very rarely get pizza here, but it is delicious when I do!“

“Very polite staff and informative. Just got a slice of their white pizza... DELICIOUS!!! And to top it off It had a garlic crust to it which was superb!!! I am a pizza connoisseur and I would definitely recommend the white pizza. Unfortunately I haven't tried any other slices so I can't vouch for anything else“

“Outstanding from beginning to end. Best food I've ever had. Service was wonderful too. Highly recommend the short rib and calamari.“

“was there for my birthday on 3/11 with my kids .we had a very nice time .“

“Large double cheese double pep wings were fantastic friendly staff thank you Taylor for great hospitality!!! 10-10 new favorite!!!“