50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elma

“Best Pizza in the area. Tastes like the way I remember pizza to tast.“

“Just Pizza- Niagara Produce Elma catered our End of Season Basketball Banquet at West Seneca West Middle School on 2/16/24. The food (pizzas/salads) were delicious and the delivery was fast and food was oven hot. All our guests raved about the pizzas and the amazing Caesar salad. Great owners, local West Seneca family, 5 out of 5 stars! Thanks again, Bob Simmons WSW Modified Basketball Coach“

“My wife and I have enjoyed a few meals here. Food was top notch, service was good as well. Strongly recommend!!“

“Fish fry five star Friday ! But I also learned they serve the fish fry everyday during lent . Fish was fantastic and the sides are great and plentiful . Had a pizza a few weeks ago and that was incredible as well . New ownership is great ! You won’t be disappointed“

“First off, I just want to say I do love your pizza and it’s refreshing to see a local restaurant that doesn’t sling the same style of Buffalo pizza that so many others do. I really think you guys need a full-service bar with taps and interesting cocktails. I feel your business would skyrocket if you had a larger building that could accommodate a big boy bar. I’ve lived and traveled all over and one place that would be worth a visit for you is Savoy in West Hartford, CT. They nail the business model of artisan pizzeria and cocktail bar. Either way, decent attempt at an operation and happy to have you in EA.“

“Very delicious, clean and friendly atmosphere.“

“Being from Chicago, we are tough pizza customers. We LOVED this pizza. It’s thick without being dense, and the sauce is perfect-not too sweet. I would have included pictures, but my family ate it too fast! We enjoyed meeting the couple who owns this place as we passed through town. We will definitely be back!“

“good food, always amazing“

“I grew up eating here..28 years says ALOT!! The food is AMAZING like your auntie from Italy is in the back making dough..I swear. Favorite Italian place EVER!!!????“

“The Britesmith has the best burger I have ever had! Will definitely go back!“

“BEST PIE IN AND AROUND BUFFALO!!! THE TOPPINGS ARE TOOOOO GENEROUS AND THE FLAVOR IS ONE TO SAVOR!!! THE ONLY COMPLAINT I HAD WAS TOOO MANY SELECTIONS I WANTED TO TRY AND NOT ENOUGH ROOM IN MY BELLY!!! GREAT BILLS/SABRES ATMOSPHERE AND IF YOU'RE LUCKY THE OWNER SITS DOWN TO EAT WITH YA AND YOU HAVE ONE OF THE BEST CONVERSATIONS IN YOUR LIFE!! ILL BE STOPPING HERE EVERYTIME I COME CLOSE TO THIS CITY!! BUFFALO HAS A GEM IN JOHNNY'S PIZZERIA & RESTAURANT!! THANKS MARK FOR A MEMORABLE AND DELICIOUS TIME!! TILL WE MEET/EAT AGAIN MY FRIEMD!“

“The staff there is extremely nice. Always a pleasure ordering from them.“

“If you’re looking for a great pizzeria look no further. From the service placing our order, the short wait time and the absolutely delicious food Geoffano’s has become our favorite pizza place! The pizza is cooked perfectly and the wings were absolutely amazing too- perfect cook and amount of sauce. Our only regret is that we hadn’t tried this place sooner! We’ll definitely be ordering again… and soon! Thank you!“

“Order well done / thin crust. Best pie I had in Buffalo, compared to the thick“

“Amazing perfect yummy I will be back.“

“Consistently great pizza, my favorite cheese and pepperoni in WNY. Generous subs, but not too much to ruin the balance of the sandwich. Service has always been great, they have messed up about 2 of our orders in the past 8 years, and have made it right no questions. I gave them a 5 for atmosphere just because - this is not a dine in restaurant, but it's always clean. Mad props to the guys and gals that work in a hot pizzeria for us!“

“Met some girlfriends tonight at Neat for dinner and drinks. The hostess was friendly and seated us quickly. We had loganberry Moscow mules that were delicious and started with the Brussel sprouts appetizer! Our server Olivia was very friendly and sweet....attentive and gave good suggestions. Look forward to next time!“

“Tried Mattinas pizza for the first time ever and it was very good. We ordered a Chicken Finger Sub and also a Pizza. The chicken fingers were very thick and meaty and seemed as if they may have been made in house but definitely good quality chicken fingers and at the usual price. Their pizza was very good and almost was reminiscent of Boccis club pizza, which in my opinion is a great thing. Their sauce was flavorful, and they had generous portions of topping.(I wouldn't have minded extra sauce and cheese, but it was good how it was). You cannot dine in which I was not expecting but was fine. The staff were friendly and constantly cleaning/ scraping the ovens between each pizza. I definitely recommend trying them out if you have never. They are worth it.

Parking: Big parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly, but no seating so expect to have the kids standing“

“Really enjoy the Philly Steak and White pizzas. Great taste at a great price!“

“Amazing perfect yummy I will be back.“

“Never had your pizza until yesterday at work someone ordered I work at elderwood Williamsville nursing home I really enjoyed it the lil spice in the pepperoni usually get Mattinas because I’m in the Kenmore area and they also season their pizza but def when in a area your located will order very good pizza!“

“We were traveling from Missouri and stopped here our first night in town. We thought we were just going to run in for a quick pizza, but it ended up being so much more than that.As soon as we walked in, we were greeted like we were regulars the amazing staff and great atmosphere was just the beginning of our experience then the food came out and we were in food heaven! We traveled the whole east coast on the rest of our trip and will always have a place in our hearts (and belly)for the amazing Zahz's pizza.It's definitely unforgettable, especially when you get a t-shirt for memories. So, from someone who travels just for food, this place is a must even if you're not in the area ❤️“

“Best pizza in the Depew/Lancaster area! Highly recommend.“

“my favorite lunch spot!! The pizza is absolutley AMAZING!! All the workers are extremely polite and the service is really fast.“

“Everything I've ever tried at Mayback's has been delicious. From the breakfast pizza to the regular pizza. This is one of the only places in the 716 that makes good chicken fingers (the honey mustard ones are divine) and a good cheese steak. The fish fry is the best I've had in years. If you want a real treat try the turkey sub with pickles and extra meat. The freshest salads I've ever had. Food is amazing, prices are great, and everyone who works there is friendly. They've got something for everyone. Easily my favorite place to get food in Buffalo.“

“First time having dinner here tonight for our anniversary! Everything was perfect and top notch, we really enjoyed our experience. Hats off to Gabriel for making us feel truly special tonight, he was wonderful! Looking forward to coming back again soon. Thanks again for a memorable anniversary dinner!“

“The TKs dudes are good dudes,i personally like there pizza with double cheese.the Topper pizza was loaded and delicious,chicken fingers are large and also very good. Thank you for the great service dudes. Your movie making,dirtwheeling,loosenut,HB Baird“

“Had my first Pan Pizza ! Delicious. The crust was so good, the sauce was not too sweet and the cost! $9.00 plus tax. Will definitely be ordering again .“

“Sugo's Pizza deserves all the praise in Cheektowaga. I don’t think I’ve had a Negative experience yet; good pizza and wings, solid fish fry and sides, and decent subs; I say decent because sometimes I’ve wished they were a little more loaded but I also recognize sh*t costs more and sometimes we don’t get the FATTEST of Sammies. Anywhoo, they made up a couple FAT Sammie’s tonight, turkey club sub and a stinger, and once again they’ve satisfied. The owner/manager/nice lady that seems to run the joint has done it again with her crew and were so very grateful for having a great pizza joint nearly across the street from us. Keep on keepin on and thank your for another great meal❤️“

“Some of the best pizza around Buffalo, regardless if it is chain pizza. I highly recommend the wings, the Detroit deep dish pizza, and the NY style pizza. Get your pizza with Turbo crust, at no extra charge! Mmmm…

For those who follow me, you may notice that I don’t give out many 5-star reviews. The business in question REALLY needs to earn a 5-star ranking from me.

Apart from some unenthusiastic employees, I’ve never had a problem at Jet’s Pizza.

The owner of this location recently needed to shut down his second location on Delaware Avenue. Uh-oh. That doesnt look good for this location.

I really dont want to lose Jets Pizza in Buffalo, so support this location while you still can. The owner needs your support.

Look for deals when you order online, or call up to see the daily deals. It’ll help to save you quite a bit of money on your order. (Admittedly, the prices here without the help of coupons are quite expensive.)“

“The pizza is always done to perfection. And they will leave a few bubbles in the crust if you ask nicely.“

“Went to the new location on union road in West Seneca. Pizza and wings were Delicious. Wings were nice and crispy on the outside and sauced well. The pizza is different, with the sweet sauce, and we really enjoyed it! We will definitely be back.“

“Moons is awesome! Great prices.. great food...family friendly place! We think highly of the owner!“

“Never had your pizza until yesterday at work someone ordered I work at elderwood Williamsville nursing home I really enjoyed it the lil spice in the pepperoni usually get Mattinas because I’m in the Kenmore area and they also season their pizza but def when in a area your located will order very good pizza!“

“love your pizza wish I could have gotten a whole slice“

“I slept on this place for years after I actually tried them last year realized what I was missing if you haven't had ferris what you waiting for?!?!“

“Had a random burger and fries here for takeout. It was delicious, fresh bun, not greasy, and either were the delicious fries. Lady behind the bar was very cordial too.“

“Best pizza in the Depew/Lancaster area! Highly recommend.“

“My new favorite pizza place in West Seneca! Try a mix of the sweet and regular sauce, you won't be disappointed.

The wings are delicious, and so was the homemade blue cheese.

I'll definitely be getting my pizza here from now on.“

“Definitely recommend!! Just had the best hot wings I’ve had in YEARS! Whatever you guys are doing, keep it up! Seriously, your cooks absolutely rocked our socks off tonight. The wings were spicy with a nice after burn and they expertly walked the line between well-sauced but not slimy. The pizza was great too, as well a couple subs we ordered. Pizza works also has great chicken fingers, fries and onion rings. They have been very reliably great the past year or so with fast service“

“My first but not last small pizza from there. Great pizza“

“Took a few minutes longer but soo worth it. Awesome good. Present staff!!“

“Had my first Pan Pizza ! Delicious. The crust was so good, the sauce was not too sweet and the cost! $9.00 plus tax. Will definitely be ordering again .“

“This place is a hidden gem. The prices can’t be beat, period. $6 pizza on Wednesdays and it’s GOOD! $6 subs on Thursday?! Where else can you find that? Drinks are MORE than reasonable all day everyday and the weekend specials are unheard of. Large and 20 for under $30. Only gripe is the manager, but he’s rarely around. The bar staff is wonderful!“

“I have ordered from this location multiple times and every time I am greeted immediately, I have yet to meet an employee there who isn’t very pleasant to interact with. My food is always hot and ready when they say it will be and it is always delicious.“

“Okay I’m not exaggerating when I say this is the tastiest pizza I’ve had in a while. The wings are great too. I was a little apprehensive because I saw some bad reviews but now I have my own opinion. I think the staff are friendly and the food was ready fast. The sauce is really good it’s not too acidic and not sweet either. This is also the only place to provide a decent portion of carrots and celery with the order and not a dry dehydrated crusty bag of baby carrots. Nothing but good things tbh.“

“LTS is by far the best pizza ! All the food on their menu are awesome ! Can’t say enough about this place , food is great the employees are soooo friendly , delivery comes very fast and food is hot when delivered , also delivery ppl are very friendly too ! They all seem to go out of their way to please ! If you haven’t tried LTS your missing out big time !!! Sooo good“

“This is THE MOST underrated spot in Buffalo. Everything is good. Cheese pizza? Fantastic. Chicken fingers? Bussin'. Wings? On point. Prices are as low as you'll see in the area. And their menu has so many deals and ways to save. 10/10 pizzeria. I wish I lived closer it would be my go-to for every single event“

“OMG! It was DELICIOUS❤️ We tried both traditional and original sauces and LOVED original. The tiny pepperonis made and cheese was perfectly portioned. So good, can’t wait to get again!“

“Their food is good but customer service is lacking. In 7 months they have screwed up my order 3 different times. I order about once a month. I feel like I should have been compensated a little better for my inconvenience if they want return business. Not looking for a freebie. Carbone's in Alden does a much better job overall. Good food too.“