25 Best Italian Restaurants near Elma

“I needed to find a place for a reception after my daughter’s wedding. We are from Pa.not sure where to go? I found Bravo called spoke with Carmela and from first conversation I was sure we would be happy…and they did not disappoint!! Food, service was excellent!Thank you for making our special day so memorable ❤️“

“I ordered delivery yesterday. I paid over the phone as I want going to be home.... my babysitter was watching my kids and I didn't want her to be bothered with paying. We are slightly out of the way, but the manager Jay personally delivered my order and made sure my babysitter got it abs was set. I really appreciated him making sure my order was delivered!! And the kids love the food!!“

“Thank you Giancarlo's and our server, Gracie for making my wife's Birthday celebration so very memorable! From the minute we walked in to the end of the evening was outstanding! The nicest touch was the personalized menu with Han's name and the birthday wishes! The dessert was great as well!!! Once again, thank you very much and also Gracie is a great asset and representative for what Giancarlo's is! Graci Mille!“

“I was pleasantly surprised when I went in to order breakfast,Everything I’ve gotten from there has been delicious, fresh , made to orderThe woman that works the register has the most amazing accent and attitude I’ve ever been around . She kind and welcoming and I love her voice so much I want to mimic her ;) instant smiles Will absolutely return ..“

“We are in Buffalo for a kids hockey tournament and wanted to order dinner to our hotel. The staff at Airport Pizza were so friendly and accommodating over the phone. When the delivery service (door dash) they use wouldn’t authorize our Canadian credit card they had a staff member who was there to cook and be in the restaurant-deliver all of our pizzas. The order was made quickly and every single pizza (we ordered 7) was absolutely delicious!!! The pizza sizes were very generous and they were LOADED with toppings. We had a few parents say it was the best pizza they’ve ever had. I would 100% recommend anyone to eat here and will most definitely be a repeat customer the next time we are in Buffalo.“

“All of our food was delicious. my seafood fra di avlo was super good & I had the eggplant stack appetizer it came on a salad with capers & olives with fresh mozzarella & the dressing was excellent. My Wife's food was also delicious. we can't wait to go back to try the rest of the menu!!“

“Amazing dishes, we had about 8 different plates to share , my favourite was either the sea bass or venison, as well as the lobster ravioli. This was hands down best Italian I've had in some time. Also I can not compliment the wait staff enough, they were very present and made sure we had a great dining experience. Amazing staff here. 10/10 for me“

“My husband and I do Wednesday night date night here once a month. Tonight we had our family holiday dinner and everything was perfection (as usual!). Excellent food generous servings attentive service and all at a reasonable price in a comfortable atmosphere. Thanks Tony and your Chef for a great meal. Special thanks to our server Sandy!“

“I will say food is good but not worth the price for most of the food items I do understand it's more of a classy place but not when you can go somewhere to get the same thing for cheaper and I say this because I have been cooking my whole life and I have worked in the food industry my whole life“

“I grew up eating here..28 years says ALOT!! The food is AMAZING like your auntie from Italy is in the back making dough..I swear. Favorite Italian place EVER!!!????“

“the good we had for dinner which was delicious.“

“After reading all the great reviews, I decided to try this place. They did not disappoint. They were friendly, the place was clean, and my food was delicious! I ordered the chicken fingers and fries, and a steak hoagie.. I'll be back to try more..“

“Everything we had was fantastic, decent size portions. Food was made correctly. We tried the "maria goumade" panini, and the "foot of ferry" gourmet "sandwiches" both were really good. Highly recommend coming. We also got some salads.Kid-friendliness: YesWheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“I used to live near there and ate there regularly. Moved away 10 years ago, but was back in the area and had to stop in. The food is as good as it always was. Hubby had to have the fried chicken, his favorite! The food was good, the service friendly and attentive...we'll have to go back again!“

“I had a bad experience my 1st visit. I contacted the owner who responded immediately. He replaced our whole order. I found it to be DELICIOUS. Not many owners would do that, he stands behind his product 100%. I will definitely be returning and recommend his restaurant“

“This place is the best!!! I used to come here all the time before my celiac (gluten allery) diagnoses and have continued to come here since as they offer gluten free pizza! Best pizza in town imo and have never been sick from cross contamination. Staff is very friendly and knowledgeable!!“

“Nice deals on Tuesdays - $15 Filet Mignon or $25 Surf and Turf are just a few of the many specials. $12 Bloody Mary and $6.00 bottled Blue light are the everyday price, making this night a great find!Wheelchair accessibility: There is wheelchair access throughout.“

“They are great here!!!! The food is soo good and dinner because dinner and lunch and a small lunch the 3rd day. Lol. They have very good gluten free pasta and the staff is willing to work with u if u have food issues.Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free pasta and made me a gluten free chicken parm“

“Absolutely wonderful staff. My family dines out a lot and I haven’t seen such incredible service in a while, from the hosts to the server. Our server, Wilanny (sorry if that’s not the correct spelling) was amazing. Truly made the whole experience incredible from start to finish. Also, my sea bass was perfectly prepared and absolutely delicious. Our server recommended the tiramisu and we were not disappointed. She was so enthusiastic about her recommendations and was spot on. Thank you!“

“Another awesome experience, our server was Lexi and she was amazing, knew how to joke around and took our antics in stride. Extremely courteous, attentive, friendly and made our dining experience a great one. We we’re at the Transit location a month prior for a club dinner and had a great time then too. If you go and have either Lexi or Lydia as your server - just know you’re going to have a great time! They both went above and beyond. Food was good, service was incredible. Our visit was only disappointing in the fact that we had to leave. I don’t eat out often but the last 2 times I’ve chosen Olive Garden on Transit and do not regret it at all. Hopefully those servers are there the next time we go!“

“This is a pick-up place. They make phenomenal pizza, and they are extremely reasonably priced. Their staff is always friendly and smiling, which I believe is a testimony to the good character of the owner. Rivas is an absolute pillar of the community.“

“They generally have good food; however, in the past 2 years, the quality of their pizza has dropped significantly. The crust is almost nonexistent, the toppings are scant. Last night we ordered a large pizza: cheese, pepperoni, and banana peppers. The cheese and pepperoni were a good amount (i.e. not great), the banana peppers were almost nonexistent. The quality has suffered and not up to the standards they had when they were located on Center Road. It appears that profit has outweighed quality: Less dough per pizza equals more money in the pocket. The price has increased to almost $60 for a large pizza and a double order of wings. It used to be $40. Less product for more money. I do understand that the cost of doing business has increased, but the quality should not suffer related to that. I would think that, with the current influx of travelers for the eclipse, they would want to put their best foot forward. And, for the current loyal customers, i.e. us, they would want to maintain them. We have been loyal to Pasquale's for well over 20 years. You need to rethink your attitude toward product.“

“I love the decoration here - exquisite!Their lime and cucumber with mint water was refreshing but nothing special, I believe you can easily make it at home.Their in house salad was amazing, I wonder how they can make the dressing so addicting, and the combination of cucumber and cherry tomatoes are just so refreshing!Their in house bread was just okay - but I did like the flavor from the crust.But I have to say, the olive oil and the vinegar they choose, wow! UNBELIEVABLE! And the spices they put into it, delicious!The New York Strip Steak - I liked the flavor, but I didn’t understand the potato pancake under it, why? Just unnecessary. And the grilled Brussels sprouts were very tasty and not too soft. But the steak was over cooked, I asked for medium but it came out even more burnt than medium well. I recommend you order a level down - which my server did.The cheese snack thing, that is way too normal. I don’t understand why it is a popular thing. But I did like the caramelized onions that came with it, yum!Lastly, dessert. The dessert I got was a polish chocolate cake called Wuzetka. It is a chocolate cake with whipped cream inside. I like the whipped cream inside, it is some good whipped cream.Overall, I very much love the atmosphere here, the decorations. It seems like a family restaurant, foods taste like with emotions, not something from package and taste no human.But I didn’t like it took them very long time to check each table. Some servers are just standing there and doing nothing, while some servers busy as hell. Even the owner had to came out to help. But I love the owner, she had a sincere smile.“

“This place is ALWAYS my go to when I'm come home for a visit! Everything about it is EXCELLENT! Service, cleanliness, and the food is stupid good no matter what you get! Family owned and operated is what I love most!!! Wanted to take a pic of my food but I ate it!“

“5 of us had dinner Friday night. To start, our server was spectacular. I told her my son and I drink a ton of water, she was slammed busy, and we never had an empty glass. Hostess and everyone else we encountered were pleasant. Our food was very good. I had chicken Parm, 5 out of 5. Their red sauce is delicious. We all enjoyed our dinner and will be back.“