13 Best American Restaurants in East Aurora

“Charlie The Butcher continues to be the premier Beef on Weck of Western New York! Thank you for all you do for the community as well! Merry Christmas!“

“Old Orchard Inn is a bit hard to find even for GPS. Be prepared to not find it on the first try if you have never been here before. The entrance road is hidden, barely paved and rough. Parking is free though. Be prepared to drive slowly when you do enter the driveway. There is a steep upward climb when you walk to the front door. If you are elderly, infirmed or handicapped, a boy with a golf cart will come get you and transport you to and from if you encounter difficulty or simply require mobility assistance. I only know this because I saw it with my own eyes. The wait was a bit long (about 30 minutes). Judy was the waitress; I see reviews with her name from 2012. She must be a lifer. Nothing wrong with that, just an observation. She is in command and can handle any customer no matter what happens. She is a good photographer if you need that service as well. Later she brought more menus and took our orders. Although she is not bashful about giving orders as well. I had the grilled lamb salad. A "hard to get" at most places for sure. It was a grilled half rack of New Zealand lamb. Crisp spring greens, goat cheese, roasted red pepper, red onion and lemon chive dressing. Highly recommend this! The sides are served family style to everyone at your table. We had summer squash and carrots, and herb roasted red potatoes. Judy will not do substitutes! The blood orange creme Brule is splendid for dessert. The restroom was a bit silly. The towel dispenser was hung from the ceiling, also just enough room to turn around in there. So, no need to be concerned about sharing it with anyone, you will have plenty of privacy. There is outdoor seating and a duck pond when the weather is nice. There is also a fireplace if the weather is cool. Certainly, memorable and will never be forgotten. In the event you are looking for something very unique with a flair for charm, the Old Orchard Inn may be just your ticket for elegance, relaxation and fun. Caveat Emptor.“

“Taste Bistro & Coffee Bar is one of our favorite spots in East Aurora. The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and well presented, and there are so many unique options on the menu that it’s hard to choose just one. The coffee is excellent, and the desserts are always worth getting. The staff is friendly, helpful, and welcoming, even when the place is busy. The atmosphere is also great and makes it a perfect spot for breakfast, lunch, coffee, or just meeting up with friends. Definitely one of the best local spots in East Aurora and somewhere we’ll keep coming back to!“

“I have been looking for a place to eat breakfast in East Aurora. Being from Pittsburgh and visiting I did not know where to go. I found the Iron Kettle on Google and saw their menu included steak & eggs, plus country potatoes. The steak was seasoned perfect, and people make you feel welcomed. Highly recommend this place, you can’t go wrong. 👍👍👍👍👍👍“

“Four of us ate here. The service was very good. Food was good for 2 of us. The other 2 both ordered reubens. They were not at all satisfied with their sandwiches. The meat had a good flavor, but was full of fat & grizzle. Not at all lean & tender. Whether this is normal or a one-time occurrence, we don't know!“

“We’re from Texas and were told to come to Bar Bill for wings and drinks. We went for lunch on a Sunday that the bills played. Great food, service and the festive atmosphere was great. Ended up getting wings and pizza. Absolutely delish.“

“Delicious food, great service and pleasant atmosphere! Perfection!“

“We stopped in while visiting East Aurora and was made to feel at home. The bartender was great and friendly, the covered deck was relaxing and the food was awesome. Definitely recommend.“

“We love the cocktails and whiskey, and the salads and burgers are delicious, but our favorite part of 189 is our server, Mary. Thank you, Mary, for always making us feel special and for adding joy and laughter to every visit. You’re the best! ❤“

“I just had my dad‘s 90th surprise birthday party at Kodiak Jack’s. Lisa was amazing and made the experience flawless. She was so easy to work with and had everything set up as we had planned. Food was amazing. Would highly recommend to anyone!“

“My wife and I go here any chance we get. The atmosphere is comfortable. Either in the warmer months out back or inside when it is snowing looking out. Nicer than home with the ambiance. Food is always great. Drinks are to die for and desserts are sinfully good... A++++“

“First time - not the last . New to the area - everyone told me to go For their fish fry . It’s a slammed Friday and they were pumping meals out and got my food 1/2 the time they told me . The owner and staff are awesome and friendly! So I Got a fish fry and took it home - still crispy and hot . Honestly a 10/10 - and I’m picky with fish fries. Best anywhere around Elma / EA !“

“My boyfriend & I came here for dinner while on an overnight in East Aurora. Outstanding food and service! Our waitress was very friendly and attentive and even changed the channel for us on the TV closest to us. The Kobe beef burger was phenomenal! Highly recommend. The service was more welcoming than other restaurants we went to in the area.“