Mitchell's Tavern

Name: Mitchell's Tavern
Address: 734 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, New York, 14150, US
Telephone: (716) 874-8907
Price range: $
Rating: 4.5

$ • Bars, Burgers, American

Hours:
734 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda
(716) 874-8907

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

take-out

delivery

Customers' Favorites

Beef on Weck Outstanding

Chicken Fingers

Chicken Wings

Roast Beef

Fish Fry

Hot Dog

Mitchell's Tavern Reviews

4.5 (76)

Write a review

March 2024

Always awesome food and service. We always end up staying way longer than we intended so our bill is always high but it's actually super reasonable with drink specials all the time. Roast beef is, legit, the best anywhere in Buffalo.

June 2023

The place has lots of cool Buffalo sports memorabilia. Lots of pic and jerseys lining the walls. Our server was so friendly and sweet. We split a few things since it was out 1st time here. Everything was served piping hot. The pickle chips were crispy and crunchy, with a nice dipping sauce, a little spicy but all tasty. The fries were cooked the way fries should be. Crispy outside, mashed potato like inside. The gravy served on the side was not very good. It was clumpy and not...read full review

March 2023

Been here a bunch of times and the roast beef is where it's at! I've had the meatloaf, roast beef, chicken wings, chicken fingers, cheese burger and the Mitchell fries. Service is always bueno with plenty of brews on tap. There's always something sport's related on the TVs and the sports memorabilia covering the walls screams Buffalo! Check them out, you will not be disappointed.

More Reviews(219)