Niagara Cafe

Name: Niagara Cafe
Address: 525 Niagara St, Buffalo, New York, 14201, US
Telephone: (716) 885-2233
Price range: $
Rating: 4.3

$ • Puerto Rican, Vegetarian

Hours:
525 Niagara St, Buffalo
(716) 885-2233

Menu Order Online

About Niagara Cafe

Niagara Café is a popular spot for Caribbean food and appetizers, with dishes that remind many of home. The menu features flavorful items like the Chicken, rice and beans, and other Puerto Rican specialties. Customers often praise the food, especially noting the well-cooked rice that is firm and chewy, similar to sushi rice, and the pastelillos (empanadas), which are crispy and slightly spicy without tasting fried. The Pernil (Roast Pork) is highly recommended for its tender, flavorful meat. The Mofongo, made with mashed plantains mixed with garlic and pork rinds, is a hearty and satisfying dish that many enjoy. The Arroz con Gandules (Rice with Pigeon Peas) is also a highlight, cooked perfectly and aromatic with sofrito. Tostones, crispy twice-fried plantains, arrive hot and golden, perfect for dipping. The staff greets guests with warmth and friendliness, making everyone feel at home. Due to high traffic, the restaurant has shifted from sit-down dining to a busy grab-and-go spot, often with long lines and a noisy atmosphere. Payment is cash-only, and the environment can be lively and bustling. Despite these drawbacks, many find the food worth the wait and the inconvenience, making Niagara Café a vibrant and flavorful escape into Puerto Rican culture in Buffalo.