Pretty sure they are out of business. Ordered delivery through slice (both pointed the finger at one another). Owner wouldn’t comp me new order, said “not my problem”. He had the photos of the food we received. Clearly did not care in making things right. Slice also did nothing to assist us.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
taylor nigro
Great slices and I hear the shawarma is awesome too, going to have to try it next timeUPDATE: I think they permanently closed, phone out of service, paper over windows and no sign letting anyone know if they are closed or not. A shame.
Devon Eagles
Best pizza on Hertel hands down.. Hot wings not the traditional buffalo hot wing but more like a tangy bbq hot but definitely recommend. All pizzas come with a Bleu cheese cup too.**update** I've been trying to order from here and phone is out of service. Went there and the windows have paper over them so not sure if they closed or just getting remodeling done but it's been like that for a couple of weeks.
Dan Starner
Pizza looked and tasted like it sat outside for hours. Id be willing to try it again, but this first attempt was not a good showing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Shakilur Rahman
Pizza tasted like NYC pizza which I’ve been missing, great place and I believe it’s halal too :)
Juanita Mathis
If I could rate lower- I would! I ordered the chicken shawarma platter online to get a phone 2mins later from the restaurant telling me that they don't have ANY chicken at the moment!!! Who doesn't have chicken?!!? He told me to call Slice delivery to request a refund, which I did to only have the rep from Slice delivery tell me that the store already processed the refund which will take 24-48hrs to return for food I never even got. I understand the reviews are good, but I'll pass!
Yasmene Dergham
Good prices, great food, super nice service! We walked in and our order was ready fast. Best shawarma we've found in Buffalo and fun pizza options (plus beef pepperoni!). We tried the chicken tandoori and it was spiced nicely. We will definitely be back. Extra points for being one of the few quick bite local places open later on Hertel.
Nicola
This is more of a note to the owners.I never actually got to eat the pizza because I placed an order through slice(which is their phone ordering system). As I arrived I was informed my order was cancelled because they were closed....as I walked into the pizzaria....The app allows you to order no matter what time and their Google hours are completely wrong going based on their website page hours. Please update all your information correctly
Jackie Slattery
This place is DELICIOUS.Any time a place says it’s NYC style pizza I get skeptical. When they put a Statue of Liberty on their box and claim to be a “bite out of the big apple” I get SUPER skeptical.This just felt like NY pizza in your mouth and hand in a way few Buffalo places pull off. And the fact that they managed to make me think of home while eating a slice as unconventional as tandoori chicken pizza is pretty much a miracle. It also tasted like real tandoori, like they pulled the meat off the bones of some roasted chicken, dark meat and all.All that, and they do mozz sticks right, too. Will absolutely be ordering again.Only note is they need a larger soda selection.
Vee S
First time here. Grabbed a few pepperoni slices. I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza was so flavorful and fresh. Crispy like NY style pizza should be. Extremely clean inside and the guy inside was very nice. I will deff be back.
So I am giving them 5 stars because the food I had was freaking great. I had a gyro, and also tried some pizza slices (don't judge me, I only at about half). The pizza slices were heated up to the perfect point, so that the cheese was a wonderful golden brown, in contrast to a different pizza place I tried close by, where it wasn't heated up enough, and it was honestly super gross. The gyro was one of the best I've had anywhere (even though I prefer the more spongey naan-type bread, it was still one of the best gyros I've had). The service was fine, haha, but could have been better, don't get me wrong, it wasn't bad...but honestly, if the food is freaking amazing, then I pretty much forget the service, as long as it's not bad, and it wasn't. I plan on coming back.
Bagel Blarney
We thought we'd order from this place based on reviews and so glad we did! Ordered Pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms and 10 wings. The pizza was absolutely delicious, from the soft chewy a little crunchy thin dough to the sweet sauce, cheese and toppings it was so good! The wings were excellent too with just enough sauce and they were big and plump, will definitely order from here again! Wish we didn't have to order from Uber Eats because they stink, order didn't arrive for an hour and a half, and the delivery driver was miserable. Had to heat everything up in the oven but it was worth it!
Danny Gassaway
Exceptional pizza! I tried many while living in Buffalo. These guys are a toss up between my other favorite. Needless to say, I may have gained a few pounds on this pizza. Super tasty, cooked well, affordable.
Hiba Albayaty
Amazing food best middle eastern food in new york great for tourists ill 100% go again
Noemi Tabibian
Read Google reviews and tried the cheese and pepperoni slices. Asked for them to be well done to fold crisply. Wow! Baked to perfection and the taste was phenomenal! Finished with a baklava that was fresh and flaky. Will definitely be back!
Pretty sure they are out of business. Ordered delivery through slice (both pointed the finger at one another). Owner wouldn’t comp me new order, said “not my problem”. He had the photos of the food we received. Clearly did not care in making things right. Slice also did nothing to assist us.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great slices and I hear the shawarma is awesome too, going to have to try it next timeUPDATE: I think they permanently closed, phone out of service, paper over windows and no sign letting anyone know if they are closed or not. A shame.
Best pizza on Hertel hands down.. Hot wings not the traditional buffalo hot wing but more like a tangy bbq hot but definitely recommend. All pizzas come with a Bleu cheese cup too.**update** I've been trying to order from here and phone is out of service. Went there and the windows have paper over them so not sure if they closed or just getting remodeling done but it's been like that for a couple of weeks.
Pizza looked and tasted like it sat outside for hours. Id be willing to try it again, but this first attempt was not a good showing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Pizza tasted like NYC pizza which I’ve been missing, great place and I believe it’s halal too :)
If I could rate lower- I would! I ordered the chicken shawarma platter online to get a phone 2mins later from the restaurant telling me that they don't have ANY chicken at the moment!!! Who doesn't have chicken?!!? He told me to call Slice delivery to request a refund, which I did to only have the rep from Slice delivery tell me that the store already processed the refund which will take 24-48hrs to return for food I never even got. I understand the reviews are good, but I'll pass!
Good prices, great food, super nice service! We walked in and our order was ready fast. Best shawarma we've found in Buffalo and fun pizza options (plus beef pepperoni!). We tried the chicken tandoori and it was spiced nicely. We will definitely be back. Extra points for being one of the few quick bite local places open later on Hertel.
This is more of a note to the owners.I never actually got to eat the pizza because I placed an order through slice(which is their phone ordering system). As I arrived I was informed my order was cancelled because they were closed....as I walked into the pizzaria....The app allows you to order no matter what time and their Google hours are completely wrong going based on their website page hours. Please update all your information correctly
This place is DELICIOUS.Any time a place says it’s NYC style pizza I get skeptical. When they put a Statue of Liberty on their box and claim to be a “bite out of the big apple” I get SUPER skeptical.This just felt like NY pizza in your mouth and hand in a way few Buffalo places pull off. And the fact that they managed to make me think of home while eating a slice as unconventional as tandoori chicken pizza is pretty much a miracle. It also tasted like real tandoori, like they pulled the meat off the bones of some roasted chicken, dark meat and all.All that, and they do mozz sticks right, too. Will absolutely be ordering again.Only note is they need a larger soda selection.
First time here. Grabbed a few pepperoni slices. I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza was so flavorful and fresh. Crispy like NY style pizza should be. Extremely clean inside and the guy inside was very nice. I will deff be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
So I am giving them 5 stars because the food I had was freaking great. I had a gyro, and also tried some pizza slices (don't judge me, I only at about half). The pizza slices were heated up to the perfect point, so that the cheese was a wonderful golden brown, in contrast to a different pizza place I tried close by, where it wasn't heated up enough, and it was honestly super gross. The gyro was one of the best I've had anywhere (even though I prefer the more spongey naan-type bread, it was still one of the best gyros I've had). The service was fine, haha, but could have been better, don't get me wrong, it wasn't bad...but honestly, if the food is freaking amazing, then I pretty much forget the service, as long as it's not bad, and it wasn't. I plan on coming back.
We thought we'd order from this place based on reviews and so glad we did! Ordered Pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms and 10 wings. The pizza was absolutely delicious, from the soft chewy a little crunchy thin dough to the sweet sauce, cheese and toppings it was so good! The wings were excellent too with just enough sauce and they were big and plump, will definitely order from here again! Wish we didn't have to order from Uber Eats because they stink, order didn't arrive for an hour and a half, and the delivery driver was miserable. Had to heat everything up in the oven but it was worth it!
Exceptional pizza! I tried many while living in Buffalo. These guys are a toss up between my other favorite. Needless to say, I may have gained a few pounds on this pizza. Super tasty, cooked well, affordable.
Amazing food best middle eastern food in new york great for tourists ill 100% go again
Read Google reviews and tried the cheese and pepperoni slices. Asked for them to be well done to fold crisply. Wow! Baked to perfection and the taste was phenomenal! Finished with a baklava that was fresh and flaky. Will definitely be back!
Loading...