Matthew's On Main

19 Lower Main St, Callicoon
(845) 887-5636

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Steve Porti

6/26 Wed night ...made trip in for dinner. Got there 7:45 and it was closed (Supposed to be opened until 9:00).I suggest you call ahead to be sure they are keeping to posted hours before making the trek in.

James Singer

This is the type of bar that gives you a lemon with your whiskey and has no peanuts. What kind of bar has no peanuts? A bar run by someone who doesn't know bars.

Trey Talley

We ate a quiet dinner here on the back porch overlooking the Delaware River. The food was great and the portions were very generous.

Thong Keokham

Bloody mary was great and the quiche was fresh and delicious. Service was good too though there was only 2 tables there when were seated.

Jeff Kirschenbaum

Good food. Very busy on a Sunday.

Bob Grossman

Food and service are good, thought there prices were a little high for the area.

joan hoffenberg

Matthew is the chef and his wide Dominique works the floor. Food is creative and tasty. Ambience is warm and friendly. The bar is separate from the tables. Always enjoy our meals there.

Dan C

Ordered a chicken caesar, crab cakes and burger. Beer selection was good too. Service is slow, wait staff tries and the food is just o.k. Went on a Saturday evening and the place was packed. Normal to expect service to be a little slow, the kitchen looks tiny. The food warmer where plates are set before wait staff takes to customers is also tiny. At one point the wait staff asked to remove our water glasses due to running low. No problem, but the staff conversation in front of us was uncomfortable and hurried.

steve greenberg

Decent meal in the woods a little pricey but served with a smile

Francisco Esperon

Awesome location, delicious food, and staff is truly attentive and entertaining. Love this place and will continue to make it my spot.

William Polyn

The Food is the best in CALLICOON NY. The ambiance and service is excellent. The bar area offers a rural down home country touch

Judy Brennan

Fabulous Sunday Brunch! Excellent food and terrific service.

Edward Herrmann

We had a great time . Really good food and atmosphere

Christine Meyers

Always amazing menu, fantastic meals, great service.

Connie Roxas Ballen

Totally enjoyed the food, longer wait but it was all worth it.

Loading...