4 Best Steakhouses near Caroga Lake

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Steakhouses near Caroga Lake.

Showing 4 of 4 restaurants

  • Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse/Special event Venue 1810 NY-10, Caroga Lake Seafood · $$$$

    1 Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse/Special event Venue

    4.0 Good 178 Reviews

    1810 NY-10, Caroga Lake

    Customers’ favorites

    • NY Strip WL Rack of Lamb over Steamed Clans
    • Oniondings over Steak FF Mashionion Gravy
    • Filet with Lobster Scallops and Shrimp
    • Chicken Parmigiana over Pasta

    “9/6/2016 Came here to today on the advice of a friend, to celebrate my daughter’s birthdate! We were absolutely very happy with our meals. First off,The presentation of our meals was stunning! Everything was perfectly prepared and brought out in a timely manner. and we three walked out there with full , satisfied bellies! Delicious food, attractively served! Our server, Kenzie, was polite, pleasant and prompt! Thank you Kenzie for making my daughters big day a hit!!❤ The only real “downfall” is the entranceway… My husband is disabled and unable to walk well.. and you have to walk down a pretty lengthy, steep gravel/dirt incline (not paved) with no steps or railing to get to the dining room/bar. Not an easy task for anyone with a disability. With that being said, I would still highly recommend Nick Stoner’s to any and everyone…just be forewarned of that walk to the entranceway! ❤🥇”

    Menu
  • Sam's Seafood Steakhouse 281 North Comrie Avenue, Johnstown Steak House · $$

    2 Sam's Seafood Steakhouse

    4.5 Superb 130 Reviews

    281 North Comrie Avenue, Johnstown · 10.17 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Haddock and Shrimp Dish with Coleslaw
    • Stuffed Salmon with Side of Broccoli
    • Side of Sweet Potato Fries
    • 1 2 lb Boneless Wings

    “Excellent food, friendly staff”

    Menu
  • Spirit's Restaurant 308 North Comrie Avenue, Johnstown American · $$

    3 Spirit's Restaurant

    3.2 Average 4 Reviews

    308 North Comrie Avenue, Johnstown · 10.02 miles

    • Take-Out

    “I’m staying at the hotel and I have to say that the restaurant has excellent food and the atmosphere is decent. Most dinner meals come with a soup or salad (French onion is wonderful) and fresh made rolls. It is a pretty quiet place with a fireplace and lots of tables. Good for large groups or work dinners.”

    Menu
  • 308 Prime 308 North Comrie Avenue, Johnstown Steak House · $$

    4 308 Prime

    3.6 Good 56 Reviews

    308 North Comrie Avenue, Johnstown · 10.01 miles

    Customers’ favorites

    • Western Omelette
    • Western Skillet
    • Quesadilla
    • Waffles

    “I was there recently for work and staying at the hotel. I stopped in to try out the restaurant I will admit I had my doubts. I'm glad two waitress nullified my doubts. The first night I had Gianna it has been more then 15 years since someone has been able to get my order correct without there being a issue. Gianna did it without even breaking a sweet. The last night I was there I was with a friend and we got Samantha ( who trained Gianna ) and again the without breaking a sweat got my order prefect and even convinced me to have dessert that night. I am extremely hard to impress they both did it. I will definitely be coming there just to have awesome food and to see those 2 young ladies. Thank You both for a awesome time it very appreciated.”

    Menu

Steakhouses Nearby