New York Pizzeria
11376 Main St, Cato
(315) 626-6662
Customers' Favorites
Southwest Steak Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Medium Hot Wings
Specialty Pizza
New York Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Grilled Wings
Veggie Pizza
Subs
Menu
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Always been the absolute best place to get pizza and wings. I dont know if theres new owners making changes or what. Tonight the wings were way over cooked, the bbq sauce is different now or it was just old, the cheese was rubbery and pulled right off the slice.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Outstanding Pizza & Service!
Cato New York Pizzaria is hands down the best spot in town! The pizza is baked to perfection — the crust is golden and crispy on the outside while soft and chewy inside. Their sauce has that perfect balance of tangy and savory, and the cheese melts beautifully with just the right stretch. Every topping tastes fresh and generously portioned.
The staff are incredibly friendly and make...
Outstanding Pizza & Service!
Cato New York Pizzaria is hands down the best spot in town! The pizza is baked to perfection — the crust is golden and crispy on the outside while soft and chewy inside. Their sauce has that perfect balance of tangy and savory, and the cheese melts beautifully with just the right stretch. Every topping tastes fresh and generously portioned.
The staff are incredibly friendly and make...
Wow!! Came here for lunch on a work trip as it was one of the few places around. Some of the best pizza i have ever had - incredible prices - friendly staff. cannot recommend enough!!!
You May Also Like
The Busted Yolk - 11384 North St
![]()
Burgers, Wraps, Vegetarian
Dunkin' - In Sunoco Gas Station, 3475 NY-370
![]()
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee