17 Best Greek Restaurants near Centereach

“I have been here over six times. And have never been disappointed. Only once was there a wait time. He was extremely apologetic. But it’s always well worth it. Once you place your order, he brings it out to your car. The french fries are the greatest. Also, the best Gyro I’ve ever had. It is a must go to place.“

“I recently ordered a Gyro from Voulapitta Greek Restaurant for takeout, and it was an absolute delight. From the moment I opened the packaging, the aroma of authentic Greek flavors filled the air, setting the stage for an exceptional dining experience.The Gyro was a masterpiece of flavors and textures. The tender slices of seasoned lamb and beef were perfectly grilled, offering a harmonious balance of savory and succulent. Tucked inside warm, fluffy pita bread, it was complemented by crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and a generous drizzle of creamy tzatziki sauce, which added a refreshing tang.What truly set this Gyro apart was the attention to detail. Each ingredient was fresh and high-quality, making every bite a taste of Greece itself. The portion size was ample, ensuring I had enough for a satisfying meal, with some leftovers for later.Voulapitta's commitment to delivering authentic Greek cuisine was evident in this Gyro. It transported me to the streets of Athens with its delicious flavors. Whether you're a Gyro enthusiast or new to Greek cuisine, I highly recommend Voulapitta for a memorable culinary journey. It was the perfect choice for takeout, and I can't wait to order from them again.“

“Got takeout from here. Best Greek food!. We got the Gyro with french fries added inside and lamb platter served over rice with side salad. The chicken and lamb were great quality and overall great flavor! Iced Feddo Cappuccino and baklava was delicious- great ending to an amazing meal!!“

“We have been here many times - the food is delicious, authentic, and Andreas + Pascalia are so warm and welcoming. Being half Cypriot myself, I can say it feels like home with food and family included. I will continue to return and I will also add that our Yiayia absolutely loved it here - for those with a Yiayia, you know that speaks volumes!!“

“We have been coming here for as long as I can remember. The staff has always been incredibly friendly and nice. It's always such a pleasure if we're with 2 people or 10. The food has never once been bad and they always give you more than you can handle! Once time we even caterered from them and us and our guests were so happy with the quality of the food. The owner was also a pleasure to deal with for that event and gave us a background on his Cyprus upbringing. Can't get enough of Akropolis!!!“

“This deli is so underrated! I can’t believe I’ve been so close the whole time and never heard of it! I decided to try after craving a gyro and was so impressed. I also ordered the bean and cheese pupusas which were fantastic. The spanish food is as authentic as it gets around here. Highly recommend this place!! Will most definitely be coming back.“

“So friendly! So nice! Open late and delicious food!!! Something for everyone. Tonight we had everything delivered and I'm so glad!!! We had pizza, knots, the BEST mozzarella sticks, a yummy Greek salad, delicious spanakopita, and baked clams. Everything came nice and hot. Perfect Sunday night dinner for a late night with the family.“

“Mykonos is a family restaurant. It's like eating with your loved ones. The food is always excellent and homemade. Freshly made Spinach Pie, fresh beet salad, delicious Gyros, great Burgers, fresh Salmon, Roasted Potatoes, OMG I could go on for hours! One of Smithtowns hidden treasures for sure. Love Mykonos ❤️“

“We like to get the rice bowls with either the grilled chicken or the chicken gyro meat, both are great options. We've eaten in the restaurant once and it is a nice, clean space. We've never had a bad experience and will continue to visit.“

“The Gyro is the best we’ve ever had even in Greece! (Just as a sidebar, in Greece, they serve their gyros with french fries ) The Greek salad is superb. I would love to have their salad dressing recipe!. The owners are dedicated to serving their customers with great “

“Came to write my review so fast. Chicken tacos were delicious. I got them doordashed and they were still so hot, double wrapped with a soft corn shell so they didn’t get soggy, and then individually wrapped in tin foil. I appreciate this level of care because tacos can get messy. The chicken was tender and juicy and the flavors were on point, and the tacos were filled well for the price! Highly recommend“

“I turned the car around because the sign said "dollar oysters." Worth every second doing so and every penny. Apparently this is a Tuesday special and if you're not into oysters, they also do clams. I grabbed a seat at the bar. Cassie, the bartender was friendly, super efficient and convinced me into 10 more oysters after my initial order of 15. They were cold and fresh, and came with all the fixings. Their mingonette was all I really needed. I saw a few other dishes coming out of the kitchen and they all looked great. A few folks at the bar got some healthy looking pours and the mussels smelled divine. Totally worth stopping in.“

“Pete, the Greek, small in appearance, but big on food, quality and taste. Limited seating most of the business is takeout, but don't let that stop you from coming and sitting down and enjoying a good meal. The restaurant has their contemporary look steel seats, wooden tables with black subway tile walls. Fast friendly service with average prices. Ample parking, so no need to worry. Ciao for Now.“

“We went here for the first time for a birthday celebration, and all we can say is....EXCELLENT! A great selection of appetizers led to wonderful entrees. My Chicken Souvlaki was delicious and the Stuffed Flounder my wife couldn't finish (LARGE portions) and which I had for lunch the next day was unbelievable! They were both paired with a great Rice Pilaf and a home made Greek vegetable combo. With a bottle of nicely priced Chardonay, we didn't have enough room for dessert (of which there were plenty of choices). The wait staff was happy, friendly and knowledgeable. There was lots of room for your privacy, but that may change when more tables need to be added once this gem in Sayville becomes more well know. It was our first time there and we can't wait to go back.“

“Such nice, fresh food again this afternoon. Our waitress was friendly and professional (Ciarra) and the guys were flexible about keeping tomatoes and peppers out of our salads--THANK YOU. They used shredded lettuce as a base, which meant an extra step for them. We really enjoy the salads, their dressing really makes it. And the yogurt sauce never disappoints. Chicken souvlaki is such a favorite that we almost can't bring ourselves to try new dishes? Whole wheat pita is really appreciated by our family. Cinnamon and almond cookies are special! Thanks ZORBA.“

“I live very close to a pizza place that held high accolades for a long time, but sadly has gone downhill lately. I am happy to say I've found Selden restaurant! Every single thing we have ordered from them has been fresh and delicious. Their bolognese sauce even had peas in it, which most places, it's just meat sauce.The hot heroes have been perfect. And not to forget the Gyros!!! Delish!!!They even deliver!Thank you Selden restaurant!!“

“Honestly the food is so good with plentiful portions..This is set up for grab and go not a sit down Atmosphere .The food is cooked to order Here.. I got a chicken soup and there was so much chicken In it.. pita bread is fluffy and fresh .The large chunks of nicely seasoned and moist chicken thats not overcooked was great to see..Im looking forward to calling in my next order...The people just keep coming in one after another..“