19 Best Greek Restaurants near Centereach

“We picked up Lunch today for the first time. Everything was delicious and had so much flavor. Staff were super friendly and sweet. Definitely will be back“

“This restaurant was a 10/10! We came in as a big family and ordered a lot of meals and it came out so quick!! The falafel and gyro were our favorites and were delicious. The portions were very large, reasonably priced and the staff was very nice. We will DEFINITELY be back. Thank you!!“

“Work day Dinner for 2
Fast Quick service *****
Gyro - D lish *****
Spanakopita best ever **********
Quick easy Pick up and go
Cost $$$$$$ No complaint$
We lost Greeks Island of Holbrook (sad )
As one chapter closed and New one opens“

“We happened upon this place because we were in the mood for Greek and were close by. Everything was absolutely delicious, some of the best Greek food I've ever had. Service with a smile, and so clean and welcoming inside. We will be back!!“

“Love this place! Such a homely feel and the food reminds you of a delicious home cooked meal. I suggest it to anyone and everyone who wants to eat great Cypriot cuisine and support a local restaurant!!“

“Couldn't find a decent souvlaki outside of Long Island City until I found Yeros!“

“I cannot say enough about the incredible food and how unbelievably fresh their fish is. From the moment you get there with their chickpea salad, which is phenomenal and then there’s tzatziki, which is also the best I’ve ever had you off perfectly. There’s never a time I don’t come home with leftovers. The staff is friendly And consistent. Unbelievably nice and I just love it here we eat here quite regularly because it is absolutely the best Greek food I’ve ever had. Tell Nick I want you. Love everyone that works there.“

“First time there last night. Delicious food, huge servings, prices great! Best chick pea salad appetizer and Greek salad . Lamb chops big portion and delicious with green beans with peppers and onion vegetable and lemon potato wedges. Highly recommend glad our friends brought us there. Wish I lived closer“

“As someone who worked in the food industry and owned my own restaurants, I can’t say enough about this particular establishment. The food is not just good, it's truly excellent, showcasing a commitment to quality that is hard to find. The service matches the quality of the food—it's consistently great, reflecting the professionalism and courtesy of the staff. They possess excellent manners and are clearly dedicated to ensuring that all customers’ needs are met. While it’s understandable that some patrons may occasionally feel overlooked, especially during busy times, it's important to recognize that the staff can only attend to one table at a time. However, rest assured that eventually everyone is attended to, ensuring that each guest's experience is pleasant and satisfying.“

“Finally tried Kalamaki and wow — so good. The chicken souvlaki was super juicy and packed with flavor. The pita was warm and fluffy and the tzatziki was perfectly garlicky. Portions are generous and prices are fair. Definitely becoming one of my go-to Greek spots.“

“Had lunch here today with a friend. Food was delicious. What a hidden gem. The owners were lovely. Very accommodating for my allergies. And again, the food was some of the best Greek I’ve ever had. Definitely will go back!“

“Been coming here for years. The food is consistently good and the waitresses are all warm and welcoming.“

“Stopped here for a quick lunch and got the falafel pita and fresh squeezed lemonade. The falafel had great flavor and a little kick, maybe a bit over crispy but still really good. The fresh squeezed lemonade was so refreshing and tart - not too sweet. The staff was friendly and greeted several customers by name. All in all very nice lunch spot.“

“Best Greek restaurant ever - falafel sandwich is to die for!“

“Awesome variety of food and service always with a smile. Would definitely recommend ❤️“

“Great place with great staff. I recommend!“

“I was craving mezze bad literally all day but didn't want to go to the place near work during my lunch break so I was CRANKY when I got home. Googled when I got home and saw this close by, forced my husband out of the house to drive me before I got so hangry I murdered him. Husband got a quinoa bowl (why anyone eats quinoa is beyond me but he really enjoyed it) piled high, I got falafel, and I got an order of each of the spreads. Absolutely hit the spot--also I make the feta dip (tyrokafteri) at home which I've been making for years and people rave about it (literally, like I'm pretty famous for it in my circles) but somehow this tastes better than mine?!? How dare they make it better than me?!? One day I'll figure out their recipe but until the I guess I'll have to keep buying it to divine their secrets. Falafel was crispy on the outside, tender and not dry on the inside, great portions. I only remembered to review with a picture after I mostly demolished it so sorry if you were hoping for a picture of the whole thing.“

“Came to write my review so fast. Chicken tacos were delicious. I got them doordashed and they were still so hot, double wrapped with a soft corn shell so they didn’t get soggy, and then individually wrapped in tin foil. I appreciate this level of care because tacos can get messy. The chicken was tender and juicy and the flavors were on point, and the tacos were filled well for the price! Highly recommend“

“You can not beat this food. Cost value best Mexican / post gym meal around. Thank you so much for the great food and service“