Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant
CLOSED$ •
2425 Middle Country Rd, Centereach
About Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Recent Reviews
We ordered from Michael Anthony’s today. Pizza, garlic knots and shrimp & scallops Newburg. Everything was absolutely delicious.
I ordered for the first time yesterday on a recommendation and Michael Anthony’s lived up to it. Delivery was right on time. Pizza was a huge hit with the kids and delicious. I will be definitely ordering from them on a regular basis and cannot wait to try other items on their menu.
Placed delivery order hours in advance for a kids party and then a no show on delivery…30 mins and 2 phone calls later they said they are on way after going to a wrong location in a completely different town…and no apology!
Menu
People in Centereach Also Viewed
Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a top-notch establishment with excellent food and service. The employees, atmosphere, and quality of food are all outstanding. They excel in event planning and catering, making every experience memorable. The Veal Marsala, penne a la vodka, and other dishes are all highly recommended. The staff, including Mike and Gina, are friendly and attentive, ensuring a wonderful dining experience. The restaurant offers delicious gluten-free options, such as mussels and pizza, catering to all customers' needs. With a beautiful dining room and exceptional service, Michael Anthony's is a must-visit for delicious meals like the Veal Chop pizzaola. Recent reviews highlight that the food is spectacular and that customers feel welcomed, even when visiting late. The pizza is popular, especially among kids, though some find it cheesier than necessary. The chicken Parmigiana is praised for its generous portion, though the pasta may be slightly overcooked for some tastes. Overall, the friendly staff and tasty dishes make it a great choice for a satisfying meal.