This person/business is a complete scam. I was scammed about 2 years ago and it’s sad to see it seems to still be happening. There are so many other, better businesses with integrity in WNY to get your cookies from!
Renée Fitzsimmons
Buyer beware this is a very untrustworthy business.
Lindsay Shafer McGuire
I neglected to read the reviews before ordering cutouts for my son’s birthday party and was scammed as well! Took the deposit and never got back to me. So frustrating! She is a scam artist - DO NOT order from her.
Brooke Sutch
Ordered a dozen cookies for June 30th for a birthday. Text her when/where I should pick up and she only responded they would be ready in the afternoon and never heard back after that.
Alyssa Chawgo
Do your research people!!! DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PERSON! I ordered 5 dozen custom cookies that we never received. Excuse after excuse and finally an offer to drop them off at the last possible minute and she was a no show and completely stopped communicating after daily communications with no issues. DO NOT ORDER FROM HER! The pickup address that was given was a deer processing company with a bloody parking lot and no knowledge of her. Phone numbers don’t work. She gets the money and runs.
Kristy Salay
We had sooo much fun decorating these cookies today. This is the perfect way to keep the kids and actually even the adults occupied doing a fun creative activity.... especially in this social distancing time. If you haven’t placed your order, I recommend not waiting any longer. Call or message Katie and she will have a ready to go box made up with everything from the cookies to the homemade frosting in piping bags and even some fun sprinkles. As an extra added bonus... they taste DELICIOUS !!!!!!!
Katie Graham
This business is not trustworthy. My mom put a deposit down for cookies for my sister’s bridal shower and Katie never sent her an invoice after she required my mom to Venmo her half of the deposit. She has promised my mom her money back and now will not read her inbox messages and keeps deleting her posts. This is our only hope of getting our money back.
Brandon Clark
DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH!. My fiances mom put a deposit down for cookies for her bridal shower and Katie never sent her an invoice after she required her to Venmo her half of the deposit. She has promised her money back and now will not read her inbox messages and keeps deleting her posts. Give us our money back PLEASE! Turns out shes stolen from several people before, and steals images from interest to pass as her own.
Cindi Marble
The cookies I ordered turned out absolutely beautiful! On top of being beautiful they tasted delicious as well. They were individually wrapped and tied with a ribbon. I couldn’t have asked for a nicer presentation. Katie was easy to work with and responded back to my messages promptly. I will definitely order again for my next event!
Kimberly Ostrowski
Super cute and delicious cookies! We will definitely order from Katie again!
These cookies were for my dil baby shower! Done to perfection is short notice and very good! Thank you Katie's cookies!
Alexa Suanne
Katie's cookies used and admitted to using photos of cookies from Pinterest that were not her cookies. Her profile is very misleading. She plagiarized with stealing photos of cookies from Pinterest. Then she has the nerve to take this man's money and didn't even produce the cookies. The only reason he is getting his money back is going on Judge Judy. Then she is giving stupid answers and excuses to Judge Judy. You will see what I mean. Turn on WLNY at 10 to watch Judge Judy and see the case.
Michelle Mack
Katie has done cookies for our children's parties for 3 years now. All of our guests RAVE about how delicious and skillfully dine her cookies are. Katie is wonderful to work with, and she is so talented. She has our business for as long as we need cookies!
Eli Joseph
Katie can do it all, best cookies I've ever had. Look and taste great. Great service and price.
Anita Mariani Joyce
Contacted her less than a week before my event, and she was able to not only make them look great, but they were delicious as well! Good communication! I would definitely recommend her cookies!
This person/business is a complete scam. I was scammed about 2 years ago and it’s sad to see it seems to still be happening. There are so many other, better businesses with integrity in WNY to get your cookies from!
Buyer beware this is a very untrustworthy business.
I neglected to read the reviews before ordering cutouts for my son’s birthday party and was scammed as well! Took the deposit and never got back to me. So frustrating! She is a scam artist - DO NOT order from her.
Ordered a dozen cookies for June 30th for a birthday. Text her when/where I should pick up and she only responded they would be ready in the afternoon and never heard back after that.
Do your research people!!! DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PERSON! I ordered 5 dozen custom cookies that we never received. Excuse after excuse and finally an offer to drop them off at the last possible minute and she was a no show and completely stopped communicating after daily communications with no issues. DO NOT ORDER FROM HER! The pickup address that was given was a deer processing company with a bloody parking lot and no knowledge of her. Phone numbers don’t work. She gets the money and runs.
We had sooo much fun decorating these cookies today. This is the perfect way to keep the kids and actually even the adults occupied doing a fun creative activity.... especially in this social distancing time. If you haven’t placed your order, I recommend not waiting any longer. Call or message Katie and she will have a ready to go box made up with everything from the cookies to the homemade frosting in piping bags and even some fun sprinkles. As an extra added bonus... they taste DELICIOUS !!!!!!!
This business is not trustworthy. My mom put a deposit down for cookies for my sister’s bridal shower and Katie never sent her an invoice after she required my mom to Venmo her half of the deposit. She has promised my mom her money back and now will not read her inbox messages and keeps deleting her posts. This is our only hope of getting our money back.
DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH!. My fiances mom put a deposit down for cookies for her bridal shower and Katie never sent her an invoice after she required her to Venmo her half of the deposit. She has promised her money back and now will not read her inbox messages and keeps deleting her posts. Give us our money back PLEASE! Turns out shes stolen from several people before, and steals images from interest to pass as her own.
The cookies I ordered turned out absolutely beautiful! On top of being beautiful they tasted delicious as well. They were individually wrapped and tied with a ribbon. I couldn’t have asked for a nicer presentation. Katie was easy to work with and responded back to my messages promptly. I will definitely order again for my next event!
Super cute and delicious cookies! We will definitely order from Katie again!
Restaurantji Recommends
These cookies were for my dil baby shower! Done to perfection is short notice and very good! Thank you Katie's cookies!
Katie's cookies used and admitted to using photos of cookies from Pinterest that were not her cookies. Her profile is very misleading. She plagiarized with stealing photos of cookies from Pinterest. Then she has the nerve to take this man's money and didn't even produce the cookies. The only reason he is getting his money back is going on Judge Judy. Then she is giving stupid answers and excuses to Judge Judy. You will see what I mean. Turn on WLNY at 10 to watch Judge Judy and see the case.
Katie has done cookies for our children's parties for 3 years now. All of our guests RAVE about how delicious and skillfully dine her cookies are. Katie is wonderful to work with, and she is so talented. She has our business for as long as we need cookies!
Katie can do it all, best cookies I've ever had. Look and taste great. Great service and price.
Contacted her less than a week before my event, and she was able to not only make them look great, but they were delicious as well! Good communication! I would definitely recommend her cookies!