MAYFAIR BAGEL CAFE
$ • Bagels, Coffee ShopsAbout MAYFAIR BAGEL CAFE
Customers' Favorites
Sausage Egg and Cheese
Signature Sandwiches
Tuna Fish Sandwich
Chocolate Muffin
Chicken Cutlet
Avocado Toast
French Toast
Egg Sandwich
Bacon Egg
Cakebites
MAYFAIR BAGEL CAFE Reviews
111 ratings
Share your opinion about MAYFAIR BAGEL CAFE
Best staff and best bagels in Suffolk! The specialty cream cheeses are awesome.
I don’t do reviews often but, I have to do this one for sure. I’m from Commack, and I’ve been to many bagel shops around Commack and surrounding areas and I’ve got to say that this one totally hits every check mark for me. Starting with quality SPOT ON , Hospitality Amazing, considering the actual economy now, you can’t beat the price for the goodness and quality consistently delivered every time. I can totally see the value on every bite of my food....read full review
The staff is so friendly and efficient! Every employee was welcoming and nice.
Hours
| Monday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Tuesday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Wednesday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Thursday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Saturday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Sunday | 6AM - 4PM |
Mayfair Bagel Café is a bright, clean, and welcoming spot, perfect for breakfast and casual dining. The café offers a wide selection of fresh, high-quality bagels that are served warm every hour, ensuring they are always delicious. Customers praise the food for being fresh and flavorful, with highlights like bagels, omelets with fresh greens, fluffy pancakes, and homemade muffins that add a special touch. The Bagel Toastery is especially popular, described as bagel heaven—fresh, toasty, and loaded with good ingredients.
The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, with an emphasis on cleanliness and organization. The owner and staff are noted for their exceptional service—friendly, hardworking, and attentive to detail. Staff members like Ken and John are appreciated for making customers feel welcomed and ensuring orders are perfect. The service quality and environment have made many customers feel like the café is a second home.
Overall, Mayfair Bagel Café is highly recommended for a cozy family breakfast, quick bites, or catering. Its combination of great food, friendly service, and a clean environment makes it a favorite among regulars, promising a satisfying experience every visit.