Island Empanada

314 Commack Rd, Commack
(631) 486-7470

Recent Reviews

Joseph Sorrentino

Not that good. Messed up our order. Called to let them know, lady that answered was a real b+#&$. For 5$ per empanada, should have gotten it right. Will be cancelling our Amex charge and not going back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ashley B.

Here's the thing I love this place. Food is delicious. But last night I ordered, was delicious but I nearly shat myself the next morning. However, it was fucking delicious and apparently I never learn so I ordered again the next day. BIG MISTAKE. Bug was cooked into my sofrito potato ball..... got the shits again. Man I love the taste of the food but idt I can get again from here which sucks If I was rating just the taste of food, it would be 5 stars. If I was rating the quality, ummmm it depends cuz sometimes it's great sometimes there's a bug. And if I was rating if it makes me shit myself...... um.......

Sam G.

Great empanada place, really. The thing is, I feel that for the price of each empanada (about $3-$4), the filling isn't completely filled up and I do believe they are a bit small. The flavors are wonderful, but I wish there was just more of it. Otherwise, I like Island Empanada. :) Oh, and I recommend the spinach and feta, broccoli and cheese, or loaded potato empanada! Those are what I usually get :)

Sayeeda A.

The staff was kind and friendly. The restaurant was clean and cozy. The reason for the low rating is because their empanadas are super salty. This was my second time picking up food from them. The first time I ordered the empanadas last year, they were very salty. I thought I would give them another try since we like supporting local small businesses. But the empanadas were super salty again. And the chicken empanadas had a weird smell to it :( the spinach and feta ones were the only ones that were decent and not salty. The rice and beans were good too. The side sauces are good too. A little less salt in the empanada fillings would make a big difference!

Michelle B.

Stop in to try the empanadas. So many choices to choose from. They are so delicious. The staff is super sweet. Definitely have to go back before I return to FL.....

Fernando Aceituno

They sell air in the empanadas, the best empanadas will be from a bakery, not a corporation…..

Eric R.

I have been here a few times and have nothing but good things to say. I live in Levittown and go out of my way for their food

Elisabeth R.

Terrible 1st and last experience. I ordered online. Chicken and Beef empanadas were meh...especially for the price. Also ordered 2 side salads...only got 1! Plenty of other places in the are that are much better food for your money.

Evelna

Really good guava and cream cheese empanada, bitter apple caramel empanada, churro is good too but was the incorrect one from the one I ordered. Guava cheese empanada was overfried resulting in over burnt shell of half of the empanada

Theresa F

Awesome empanadas, wide selection

Samuel Mejia

Great customer service and the food top notch

Ian Rolla

Shrimp and mango was outstanding

Heloise Kayser, MHC-LP

Consistently authentic!

Angela Quiles

Great food . We love their pork empandas and the beans. Tastes like real Puerto Rican food.

Demishia O.

We purchased the empanadas for take out online. It was ready within 20 mins. We got several different empanadas. My favorite is the shrimp, and mango with the shrimp. They are reasonably priced only a few dollars each.

Load More