Custom Cakes near Depew, NY

“Just picked up a birthday ice cream cake for my husband and it's perfect! The staff there was super nice and even let me come back with my gift certificate that I forgot and refunded me the money. Will be using them again for custom ice cream cakes!“

“We can’t thank Not Just Cales enough for the amazing cookie kit for our little ones pre-k graduation celebration! Everyone at the party both kids and adults had a blast making their own custom cookies! And everything tasted absolutely delicious!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 stars would absolutely recommend!“

“I love this place so much! The owner Dawn is so friendly and will take time out of her busy baking day to chat with you. The atmosphere is so cute and cozy and her cupcakes are delicious! I come here every chance I can and even buy her goodies as gifts for my friends and family.“

“Everything was perfect and delicious! ? Absolutely delicious cookies and the cats were so beautifully decorated to look like my 2 ❤️ And the Blue Monster cookie has been a huge favorite (they're all already gone!) along with the smores and snickerdoodles. Each kind of cookie is so delightfully unique and simply fantastic.I won't hesitate to order from A.L.L. Sweet Shop & Bakery again and again, and thank you so much for helping to save the rescues!“

“We had a division meeting in March and I was tasked with bringing breakfast for the team, all of which were from out of town. I picked up an assortment of 2 dozen pastries and muffins the day before. Everybody loved them, thank you so much!“

“Highly recommend Chrusciki bakery. We used them for our wedding reception in December and the quality, flavor and presentation was everything I could have hoped for.Our tasting experience at the Lancaster location was great, Leah was very informative and helpful and able to accommodate our group.The communication throughout the entire process was very easy and everyone was very kind and helpful!We ordered the white almond raspberry cake as our tiered cake and it is my personal favorite. The red velvet sheet cake, macarons and cookies were all GONE at the end of the night. Everything was a big hit with our guests!“

“Cakes by Katya catered our wedding this year and we were utterly blown away by the precise presentation of our cake and cupcakes, the professionalism, and absolute ease of the entire process from ordering to delivery. The cupcake flavors were absolutely out of this world. And they even found a way to customize our cake toppers to our specific outdoor interests, which we can keep forever as a token of our special day. We cannot recommend this bakery enough for all of your needs for baked goods!“

“Cold Stone Creamery has the most delicious creations. I really enjoyed my sweet spring, it was so creamy like a burst of spring and amazingly delicious. You can create your own or pick and choose from a variety of choices, either way you can't go wrong.“