A reliable favorite! Consistently excellent across all levels ~ food, service, experience.
Opentable Diner
Il Toscano has become my favorite restaurant! Not only is the food absolutely delicious, but the staff is incredibly nice and makes you feel like family!
Bob
The food is always superbly prepared and delicious. Specials are delightfully unusual and flavorful. Service is always friendly and the owner goes the extra mile to ensure a pleasurable dining experience.
Nancy
Celebrating a birthday there. Staff was quietly attentive. We were not rushed. Cocktails were perfect, food yummy. Courses served at comfortable pace. Fine Italian dining at its best.
Holly
Consistently excellent food and a "no problem" response to requests for modifications to menu items. The staff is on roller skates and manages to be attentive throughout the meal.
Beverly
One of my favorite Restaurants - food is exquisite - as well as drink options - A go to for me for sure - Highly recommend this outstanding Restaurant!
Lisa
The food is consistently amazing at il toscano! We used to live in the area, and drove 2 hours to have dinner there, and it didn't disappoint! We really wish we lived closer! :)
Melynda
Such a pleasant evening. Good food good service Will be back and we live in Suffolk county
Jerry
The best Italian food in NY , Always welcomed and treated like family . A must go to place for dinner
Geraldine
Delicious food, great drinks and excellent service Salmon special was a stand out Black linguini and shrimp special also amazing Zucchini flowers beautifully presented and very good! Everyone was happy!
Il Toscano has been one of my favorite places to dine for years. Last night was no exception. Where they could have done better was at the greeting. I'd categorize it as cranky and not exactly welcoming. But okay we got past that, sat at the bar until we were seated. The presentation of our salads and entrees was lovely. Every bite delicious. Our server did his job. The food arrived hot and timely.
robert
Amazing as always Server was great we celebrated my wife's birthday Upstairs was quieter than downstairs
Kyle Style
This is not your typical Italian restaurant from Italy. There's no primi or secondi separation in the menu. The menu has some typical Italian dishes, but 1/2 it is a mixture of fowls & fish. The music they played is mostly Gypsy Kings & perhaps 1 Italian song, whilst we were there. The inside of the place looks like a typical Tudor interior, nicely decorated. Nevertheless, the food is very good. My wife & I were there to celebrate our anniversary. We shared everything from salad (has manchego [too white to be more than 3 months aged], avocado, baby spinach, red onion), lobster bisque (not as creamy as other places, however, what they have works well too), quails (deboned) stuffed with spinach, striper with asparagus (the tomato chutney was a great addition), peach cobbler topped with chocolate chip ice cream (we had better in Chattanooga, the streusel has granola, which is a pleasant surprise). I wished we've chosen the coconut panna cotta. Both the mains were cooked just right, not overdone. My wife had a cappuccino, which was not too fancy. It just has foam & a dust of cinnamon. Just like the pan gratis, the 3 or 4 varieties weren't even heated. We like our breads heated. We've also shared a raspberry limoncello martini. I'm not sure what to make of it, but it's not bad either.
Hanna
We celebrated our anniversary with friends. Dinner delicious. Service great. Always love dining here!
anne
Food is good but service was okay. Bus people were okay, wine was very unevenly served, biscotti ordered never came out, coffee was ordered and served to everyone but the first pets who ordered coffee.
A reliable favorite! Consistently excellent across all levels ~ food, service, experience.
Il Toscano has become my favorite restaurant! Not only is the food absolutely delicious, but the staff is incredibly nice and makes you feel like family!
The food is always superbly prepared and delicious. Specials are delightfully unusual and flavorful. Service is always friendly and the owner goes the extra mile to ensure a pleasurable dining experience.
Celebrating a birthday there. Staff was quietly attentive. We were not rushed. Cocktails were perfect, food yummy. Courses served at comfortable pace. Fine Italian dining at its best.
Consistently excellent food and a "no problem" response to requests for modifications to menu items. The staff is on roller skates and manages to be attentive throughout the meal.
One of my favorite Restaurants - food is exquisite - as well as drink options - A go to for me for sure - Highly recommend this outstanding Restaurant!
The food is consistently amazing at il toscano! We used to live in the area, and drove 2 hours to have dinner there, and it didn't disappoint! We really wish we lived closer! :)
Such a pleasant evening. Good food good service
Will be back and we live in Suffolk county
The best Italian food in NY , Always welcomed and treated like family . A must go to place for dinner
Delicious food, great drinks and excellent service Salmon special was a stand out Black linguini and shrimp special also amazing Zucchini flowers beautifully presented and very good! Everyone was happy!
Restaurantji Recommends
Il Toscano has been one of my favorite places to dine for years. Last night was no exception. Where they could have done better was at the greeting. I'd categorize it as cranky and not exactly welcoming. But okay we got past that, sat at the bar until we were seated. The presentation of our salads and entrees was lovely. Every bite delicious. Our server did his job. The food arrived hot and timely.
Amazing as always Server was great we celebrated my wife's birthday Upstairs was quieter than downstairs
This is not your typical Italian restaurant from Italy. There's no primi or secondi separation in the menu. The menu has some typical Italian dishes, but 1/2 it is a mixture of fowls & fish. The music they played is mostly Gypsy Kings & perhaps 1 Italian song, whilst we were there. The inside of the place looks like a typical Tudor interior, nicely decorated. Nevertheless, the food is very good. My wife & I were there to celebrate our anniversary. We shared everything from salad (has manchego [too white to be more than 3 months aged], avocado, baby spinach, red onion), lobster bisque (not as creamy as other places, however, what they have works well too), quails (deboned) stuffed with spinach, striper with asparagus (the tomato chutney was a great addition), peach cobbler topped with chocolate chip ice cream (we had better in Chattanooga, the streusel has granola, which is a pleasant surprise). I wished we've chosen the coconut panna cotta. Both the mains were cooked just right, not overdone. My wife had a cappuccino, which was not too fancy. It just has foam & a dust of cinnamon. Just like the pan gratis, the 3 or 4 varieties weren't even heated. We like our breads heated. We've also shared a raspberry limoncello martini. I'm not sure what to make of it, but it's not bad either.
We celebrated our anniversary with friends. Dinner delicious. Service great. Always love dining here!
Food is good but service was okay. Bus people were okay, wine was very unevenly served, biscotti ordered never came out, coffee was ordered and served to everyone but the first pets who ordered coffee.
Loading...