Jonathan's Pizza & Italian Cuisine

Stopped here during a family road trip for dinner and was very pleased. Got a table immediately, food came out quickly and everything was cooked well and delicious. Wait staff was kind, attentive and patient with our large family. Would give them 10 stars if that was an option.

Jonathan's Pizza is THE best! I have had pizza here twice and love it! The crust is perfect on their Sicilian and sauce is flavorful. Also tasted some of my wife's eggplant parmigiana and it was fabulous. Hey - if Harrison Ford flies in and eats here, good enough for me.

well i havent been there in a couple of years but my steak sandwhich was dry the waitress was rude she just throws down the pitchers of soda andwater and walks away. but i lived in texas and we had a saying that goes you think you are coming down chicken fat and all. your restaurant is below average. enjoy your retirement or whatever the reason you are selling we will never return jonathans has gotten to big for their britches and those waitressess well what comes around goes around. have a good life.by the way your waitress hands me a bill with a bunch of numbers scribbled on it with no description and i am supposed to believeit why dont you get with the program and computerize so i can get an itemized bill. i will be contacting the appropriate authorities on mondayabout your business practice and the condition of your restaurant. and within a week you will see the health dept at your front door

The calzones are excellent. Most of the other items are good. Located in a place with few good restaurants.

The Calzones are to die for! Very friendly staff and a very good dining experience. It's just what you works expect from a neighborhood Italian restaurant. Definitely worth the drive to Duanesburg even at $5 a gallon for gas.

Food is great and the proportions are filling.

Very friendly staff and food was great fish fry was batter dipped and delicious individual pizza was deep dish style will have to go back soon

The best spaghetti sauce I’ve ever had in my life! Great food, great atmosphere and our server was terrific!! Highly recommend. 2 thumbs up! A great find!

Vary vary saddened by how inappropriate the management was to their employees infront of customers. Really pulling a power play and very rude. It seems a new maybe not trend going around that management can talk down to its coworkers. I will not support this behavior.

Quick, attentive, entertaining service. The food is always magnificent.

My Friend and I went here for a Sunday Super Bowl dinner, and the food we had was excellent . The sizes were very decent as well, the waitress was very nice and did not rush us. We both loved this place and we will be going there again.

Delicious food. Great service. Have gone there many times and will go many more times.

Service Has gone away downhill.I used to give this place 5 stars loved the food while the atmosphere last 3 times I've gone there this place has really gone down hardHalf the time they don't answer the phone they scrub your order and then you get an attitude

So I usually love Jonathan’s! Me and my family get takeout usually every few months from there… food is great, service is also usually great. However, tonight I called to order a pizza for pick up at about 4:20 and they said about a half an hour so I asked if I could pick up at 5:20 instead and they said absolutely and that it will be on top of the oven at 5:20 for me… great! So I get there at 5:21 and the lady there looked confused like she didn’t know about my order and looked in the oven and it was still dough so she said give us another 5-6 minutes… ok then… I go to give her my card to pay and she looked pre occupied and kind of walked away so I go out and sit in my car and went back in at 5:28 when she checks the pizza and it’s done so she throws it in box cuts it and slides it over and while she’s ringing it up I’m holding my card out and she then takes my card and goes to cash me out then says sorry we can’t take cards our credit card machine is down… so I asked if there was an ATM in the building and she says no there’s one across the street at Stewart’s and I’m like well can you just take my information and charge it when the machine goes back up and she says no that the machine has been down for over a week. Sooo wait a minute… not on the phone nor when I went in the first time, ANYONE could tell me that they can’t take cards? At that point I wasted another 15 minutes on top of my hour drive home and I left… it’s unfortunate that nobody could tell me ahead of time because I absolutely would have stopped on the way and took out the money because I love their food but honestly, there was no need for that and they didn’t even remotely accommodate for their error. I get it we all make mistakes but like she didn’t even apologize or offer to help make it right by any means.

Everytime my husband and I get a burger from there we always get sick. This time we were hoping for the best bc we really wanted a burger and now it was my husband my sister in law and myself that got sick. I'm am no longer coming there to get food if it's going to make us sick!