Nellie’s
CLOSED$ •
About Nellie’s
Nellie’s Reviews
68 ratings
They hosted a private baby shower for my friend and it was perfect! The staff were attentive and the food was delicious!
My 9yo daughter and I were in town for the Catskills Mtn Feis and the owner of our hotel recommended Nellie's. I am so glad we took her suggestion. My daughter loved the kids pizza. I had the corned beef reuben and steak fries. So, delicious. We were also treated to some local karaoke. There was only one waitress on, but she did an excellent job checking on us. Will definitely eat here again when we are in town.
Food was great. Pricing was great waitress staff was great, but it was hard to get a drink at the bar unless you were one of the regulars, and after dinner we tried to move to the bar and none of the dirty glasses were cleaned up so you didn’t know where you could sit very unhappy with the bar service, but everything else was great.
Nellie's is a renowned restaurant located in a quaint corner of New York, offering a wonderful dining experience. The service is praised as awesome, and the food is described as phenomenal, with highlights like the perfectly cooked prime rib and rich, delightful mushroom soup. Customers have enjoyed a variety of meals, including the corned beef reuben and steak fries, as well as the kids pizza, which is a hit among younger diners. The drinks, particularly the whiskey sours, are also highly regarded. While the bar service can be inconsistent, the overall dining experience at Nellie's is exceptional. The dining room is beautifully arranged, making it a great venue for special occasions, such as baby showers and family gatherings. Despite having only one waitress at times, customers have noted that she does an excellent job attending to their needs. With a mix of great food, service, and unique experiences like local karaoke, Nellie's continues to receive high praise from satisfied customers.