So expensive and food mediocre. Steamed artichoke cooked well, but aioli was bland. Croque Monsieur burnt on the bottom, cheese burnt and very hard to cut. Salad tasted like it wasn’t dressed. Bloody Mary was tasty, but small and had ONE olive as a garnish! Good coffee. Waitress had to come back many times asking what we ordered - she should have written it down! Place almost empty for Sunday brunch at 12-2, no real brunch specials.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Jennifer Dickens
Came here for appetizers and took entrees to go. All the food was delicious, especially the fish and chips (I was especially fond of the tartar sauce!) While a little expensive, I'd go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup
George Morris
Great bartenders ! Everything was excellent, I am so glad we stopped at Rowdy Hall.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lou Piccolo
Drastically overpriced. Not the same Rowdy Hall I frequented over 20 years. Sayonara!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Michael Healy
Got the pretzel and the burger both were delicious.
A pleasant -but nothing special' spot on a rainy winter night when one doesn't feel like cooking. A pity there was no bread to sop up the sauce from the PEI mussels.Vegetarian options: Check menu on line
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Disco Fries
Jessica C.
We stayed in the Hamptons one weekend and we stopped here for dinner. I was blown away by their espresso martini, it was one if the best I have ever had! For dinner we shared a bunch of apps including the escargot, giant pretzel, and artichoke which were all amazing. My favorite however was the french onion soup, the veal broth was out of this world. It is a must order!
CP
Much more for the FUN FUN FUN than any of the food yet the food is GOOD.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Joseph D.
Service was excellent! Food came out quickly and was nice and hot with good presentation! The mussels were delicious!
Pros : Service here is on point. The atmosphere is clean and nice. Cons : The food is nothing special - for starters they changed their burger style, before they relocated from EH they had a legit sesame seed bun, now the bun is a basic generic one you find at a cheap rushed backyard BBQ. I ordered my burger medium, it was totally well done, I couldn't even finish it. Burnt vibes. The fries were overly salty and borderline not edible. I got a chili & cornbread special,l - the chili was fine, but it there was 3x more cornbread than chili, so it was a bad proportion. End of the day forty-five bucks before tip for a burger with fries and a chili with cornbread appetizer is pretty excessive for how unimpressive it all was. One and done for me personally.
Dawn B.
Superb cheese burger. Staff is super friendly. Rowdy Hall complements the Amagansett vibe. Amagansett Main Street is whole once again.
James C.
Lunch 2/3/24. Ordered three onion soups, two burgers and wings. Asked that all be delivered at same time. Soups arrive-very good, though $18. Wings came 15 minutes later. Burgers come another 15 minutes later-lukewarm, not hot. Were they sitting waiting to be delivered to the table? Seems that way. Fries were overcooked. Waitress was very pleasant but the timing and delivery of the food was poor. Very surprised and disappointed. Renovations were well done. Rowdy Hall needs to up its game on the actual food preparation and delivery.
Joyce E.
Great, casual atmosphere with delicious food and wonderful, professional and friendly service.
Nancy Atlas
The absolute best french onion soup i've ever had. Everything on the menu was completely on point. Love the staff. Love the owners. Love the vibe. Above and beyond a pub.
So expensive and food mediocre. Steamed artichoke cooked well, but aioli was bland. Croque Monsieur burnt on the bottom, cheese burnt and very hard to cut. Salad tasted like it wasn’t dressed. Bloody Mary was tasty, but small and had ONE olive as a garnish! Good coffee. Waitress had to come back many times asking what we ordered - she should have written it down! Place almost empty for Sunday brunch at 12-2, no real brunch specials.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Came here for appetizers and took entrees to go. All the food was delicious, especially the fish and chips (I was especially fond of the tartar sauce!) While a little expensive, I'd go again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup
Great bartenders ! Everything was excellent, I am so glad we stopped at Rowdy Hall.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drastically overpriced. Not the same Rowdy Hall I frequented over 20 years. Sayonara!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Got the pretzel and the burger both were delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Giant Bavarian Pretzel, Rowdy Burger
Nice place to have a drink and socialize. Light n
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
A pleasant -but nothing special' spot on a rainy winter night when one doesn't feel like cooking. A pity there was no bread to sop up the sauce from the PEI mussels.Vegetarian options: Check menu on line
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Disco Fries
We stayed in the Hamptons one weekend and we stopped here for dinner. I was blown away by their espresso martini, it was one if the best I have ever had! For dinner we shared a bunch of apps including the escargot, giant pretzel, and artichoke which were all amazing. My favorite however was the french onion soup, the veal broth was out of this world. It is a must order!
Much more for the FUN FUN FUN than any of the food yet the food is GOOD.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Service was excellent! Food came out quickly and was nice and hot with good presentation! The mussels were delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
Pros : Service here is on point. The atmosphere is clean and nice. Cons : The food is nothing special - for starters they changed their burger style, before they relocated from EH they had a legit sesame seed bun, now the bun is a basic generic one you find at a cheap rushed backyard BBQ. I ordered my burger medium, it was totally well done, I couldn't even finish it. Burnt vibes. The fries were overly salty and borderline not edible. I got a chili & cornbread special,l - the chili was fine, but it there was 3x more cornbread than chili, so it was a bad proportion. End of the day forty-five bucks before tip for a burger with fries and a chili with cornbread appetizer is pretty excessive for how unimpressive it all was. One and done for me personally.
Superb cheese burger. Staff is super friendly. Rowdy Hall complements the Amagansett vibe. Amagansett Main Street is whole once again.
Lunch 2/3/24. Ordered three onion soups, two burgers and wings. Asked that all be delivered at same time. Soups arrive-very good, though $18. Wings came 15 minutes later. Burgers come another 15 minutes later-lukewarm, not hot. Were they sitting waiting to be delivered to the table? Seems that way. Fries were overcooked. Waitress was very pleasant but the timing and delivery of the food was poor. Very surprised and disappointed. Renovations were well done. Rowdy Hall needs to up its game on the actual food preparation and delivery.
Great, casual atmosphere with delicious food and wonderful, professional and friendly service.
The absolute best french onion soup i've ever had. Everything on the menu was completely on point. Love the staff. Love the owners. Love the vibe. Above and beyond a pub.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5