Renzo's

CLOSED
$$ •

About Renzo's

Renzo's offers amazing food with a sweet and savory marinara sauce. This family-owned business provides polite and professional service, whether dining in or taking out. The aroma of garlic fills the shop, enhancing the delicious experience. Menu favorites include the pizza, sesame crust, wings, pinwheels, cheese steak, garlic knots, and Vanilla Coke. Renzo's is a neighborhood staple in East Islip, known for must-try slices like Buffalo, chicken bacon ranch, and classic pepperoni. Customers have praised the delicious food and friendly staff, especially highlighting the chicken parm slices. For those seeking gluten-free options, Renzo's GF pizza has received high marks, with many families enjoying both gluten-free and regular pies. While some longtime customers have noted changes in recipes, the overall quality of the food remains good.

Menu

Add a Menu
Renzo's Menu
Renzo's Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Renzo's
Renzo's
View All Photos

Renzo's Reviews

4
102 ratings
5
63%
4
3%
3
10%
2
10%
1
14%
Food
4.0
Atmosphere
4.5
Service
4.3
This was my spot growing up in East islip. Great food and people! Always grab a slice when I’m home
Sicilian pie or by the slice is the best you can get!😁
12/10/25 I give out good reviews and bad reviews third time going back to pizzeria establishment that been same location before 1970s the pizza ,the staff ,the lunch deal so much better than out east where I needed to move to after being a long term resident of East Islip keep up good work with affordable food great that I found a to go to spot they put up with me Medford farmingvile stay away from pasta cuccina horse block Rd and Waverly Ave get a bad taste pockets become...read full review

Read All Reviews(102)

Updated on: