Tony And Nick's Italian Kitchen

Really kind staff, and the vegan options are great. Even vegan pizzas! I had the vegan meatballs and broccoli. Great amount of food.

I typically take the time to write positive reviews, but this experience was not one of them. I frequently drive by this restaurant on my way to and from fishing at Rondout Reservoir in Grahamsville, NY. The good news is that the place is warm and inviting, with a good selection of non alcohol beers, tap & bottled beers and spirits. However, there were a few issues. My son and I sat at the bar, and there was a family of three at a table nearby, along with another couple. We ordered a pizza and ravioli for $45. While waiting, we noticed a lot of phone activity and several customers picking up take-out orders. Other patrons who arrived after us were getting their meals before we did. After 45 minutes, I asked the bartender about the delay, and she told me that take-out pizza orders were holding up our food. I asked for whatever was ready, because I now needed it to go. She brought our meal out around the 50-55 minute mark. I expressed my frustration, explaining that my goal was to eat my meal there, not having to drive 55 minutes home for a cold meal. In response, she offered us the two beers we drank while waiting, and a 25% discount on our bill. We appreciated the gesture but still left disappointed. On our way out, we overheard another customer asking, “Where’s our pizza? Are you making the cheese?” When I got home and opened the pizza, I grabbed a slice and noticed there was no dry carboard, and the oil soaked completely through the box — not the best experience, especially for a $45 basic order. In fairness, maybe I'll give them another try, but for now, I can’t help but feel like most restaurants do a better job of balancing take-out and dine-in orders. You’d think a place that’s been open for a while would have figured this out by now.

I love this place went here last week with the family and the food was amazing oscar and Sarah are great servers always a smile on there face . Definitely will be back !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lovely and friendly staff, made us feel welcomed. Food was really good and large portions. We had the eggplant Parm and the chicken Parm, recommend highly. Had the tiramisu for dessert and it was lovely. Will be back when we're in the area!

Dietary restrictions: IIRC there's a section of the menu that has options for dietary restrictions

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken and Eggplant Parm, Eggplant Parmesan

First time eating here. Nice atmosphere, good food. Recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spaghetti & Meatballs

I went here for the first time for my husband's birthday on a weeknight. I had a reservation, but didn't wind up needing one. It's absolutely criminal that this place isn't packed out every night. Service was so attentive. Their stuffed rigatoni was the stuff of DREAMS. We also had the wings for appetizer, which were also delicious. I'm excited to return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Took maybe 20 minutes in a half empty resteraunt to be seated. Starters were delicious, couldn't fault them the meatballs, wings and califlower was all delicious, was a good start, unfortunately when the main course came out the two pizzas were absolute garbage

The pizza was overloaded with cheese, It was waterlogged with way too much cheese and was soggy, the pizza on the other hand was also overloaded and the sauces were foul. Wouldn't recommend this place

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

I keep going to that place because my wife likes it.
But they take care of that as if not to leave
They take forever for everything, even if they don't have clients, they leave you waiting.
We arrive during the day and leave at night
I went for lunch and it was already food ?

Great food and staff!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spaghetti & Meatballs, Chicken Marsala

Pizza was good. Steak was like sponge . Waiter went back 3 times after bringing food looking for steak knife.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

The service is really bad, the people not friendly

We were camping near Ellenville over our anniversary and I selected Tony and Nick's for our anniversary dinner based on their ratings and their menu. That anniversary meal became a new cherished memory!

When I called to ask about/make our reservation I had mentioned it was our anniversary. Upon arrival there were plenty of open tables. We were asked if we had a reservation, I gave our name, at which point the gentleman walked us to a booth that had a reserved sign and was already set up with our menus and wine list, and he bid us a happy anniversary!

There were plenty of varied menu selections and a weekly specials page. We shared an Italian charcuterie plate, my Bride selected the braised beef ravioli, and I had the duo chicken and eggplant parm special. All were ample and delicious!

This restaurant is a gem. The food is outstanding, fairly priced, and I cannot say enough about the service. The clearly post their cash vs. credit prices and they didn't rush us out the door. The establishment is clean and has fun, nice decor.

You cannot go wrong!

EDIT: we took our desserts to go. Both the lemon and itItalian rainbow cake were two great choices! Tasty, moist, and not overly sweet - both delicious, even the next day!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pizza and shrimp pasta were both really tasty ? ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing loved the sicilian pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My partner and I got the fried tofu in the jalapeno glaze as an appetizer. It was not in the vegan appetizers section of the menu but we had it confirmed by staff. Very yummy. The glaze was sweet with a little spice. I'm not super keen on sweet foods so I didn't finish it. I had seen a comment that it was good and I really wanted to try it. I had gotten the beyond ragu pasta which was very yummy and filling. Not anything super special, but it was still very good. My partner got the Sausage pizza from the vegan menu. If you are a mushroom lover-get this. He said the mushroom was super good, and the pizza was loaded with it. He gave a super thumbs up to it haha. I was just super thrilled to see that we could get some yummy vegan Italian food. We had a whole section in the menu. We didn't try anything from the bar beverage wise, but it looked like they had quite the variety.