12 Best Caterers near Elma

716 Fresh Meal Delivery • $
6120 Seneca Street, Elma

“I have tried other companies that produce meals similar to what 716 fresh offers, but have been disappointed. So thankful I decided to give 716 fresh a shot! The food is delicious!“

4.9 Superb105 Reviews
Carmen's Catering Caterers • $$
1193 Center Road, West Seneca - 5.07 miles

“Carmens Catering is by far the BEST catering company in the area. The food is amazing. I’ve never been disappointed!!!“

5 Superb32 Reviews
Blue Fire BBQ Catering Bar • $$
6540 Main St, Williamsville - 8.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Chicken Sandwiches

“We hired Blue Fire BBQ to cater my daughter’s high school graduation party, and they absolutely knocked it out of the park! From the first phone call to the final empty tray, the entire experience was fantastic.

The food was phenomenal. We went with pulled pork, beef brisket, grilled vegetables with balsamic glaze, roasted potatoes, and their creamy mac and cheese. Every single item was superb, perfectly seasoned, cooked with care, and full of flavor. The beef brisket was the undisputed star of the day. It was so tender and delicious that guests were raving about it nonstop. The grilled vegetables had just the right char and that bright balsamic finish, and the mac and cheese was the ultimate crowd-pleaser.

Matt, the owner, was incredibly easy to work with. He was responsive, professional, and genuinely invested in making our event perfect. He personally delivered everything right on time. The setup was quick and seamless and the portions were generous. We had plenty of happy guests and very little left over.

If you’re looking for a caterer who delivers quality BBQ with personal service, look no further than Blue Fire BBQ. They helped make our graduation celebration truly memorable. We can’t recommend them highly enough. Thank you, Matt and team!“

5 Superb27 Reviews
An Enchanted Taste and More Caterers • $
5270 Transit Road, Depew - 4.36 miles

“I was delighted with An Enchanted Taste's brunch menu. The food looked appealing and tasted even better. Several of our guests commented on how delicious everything was. Having An Enchanted Taste cater our brunch was an excellent decision.“

5 Superb23 Reviews
Charlie the Butcher's Catering Center Caterers • $$
446 Cayuga Road, Cheektowaga - 8.26 miles

“Charlie The Butcher continues to be the premier Beef on Weck of Western New York! Thank you for all you do for the community as well! Merry Christmas!“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Cozy Catering and Takeout Caterers • $
10250 Main Street, Clarence - 8.99 miles

“Great food. Serving are huge. Unfortunately, we were there on a night people called off. So they were a little behind but we were not in a hurry.“

4.5 Superb24 Reviews
Daily's Caterers • $$
594 Main Street, East Aurora - 5.9 miles

“Karen is an East Aurora treasure, funny, smart, kind and always calm. Most of the town would find life a lot harder without Daily's Catering & Take Home. My favorite thing is walking in with an event or two or some dietary question, and leaving with great tasting solutions.“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Frontier Catering Caterers •
912 Union Rd, West Seneca - 6.11 miles

“A big thank you to Art, Nancy, and Frontier Catering for doing a fabulous job at our August 2021 reception!! We highly recommend Frontier Catering!!! Art has such PASSION for his food, service and attention to detail. I was a pandemic bride and he was nothing but helpful during all of the many reschedules until we landed on date that ended up working. The appetizers were beautiful! The food was HOT, scrumptious and plentiful. His team even came around with seconds (you can tell from the picture how delighted my brother was)! His speciality creamsicle cake was a fan favorite! I’ve had many people tell me it was the best food they ever had at a wedding. I wish Art had a restaurant because I would be there all the time!!!! On the day of the reception, a few guests couldn’t make it and Art packed up those dinners so my husband and I could enjoy them the next day!!! Great people to work with! He was quick to respond to any of my emails and calls, and so was Nancy! It was also convenient that he provided all of the linens for the table. He is more than a chef and a caterer, he is a wedding planner that coordinates with the other vendors so your day is flawless! Thanks again Art!!!!“

4.7 Superb11 Reviews
Joseph's Catering Service Caterers • $$
275 Columbia Avenue, Depew - 5.33 miles

“Professional staff and a great wedding venue. Food is good too!!! 😊“

4.3 Superb38 Reviews
Carmine's Restaurant & Catering Sicilian • $$
7170 Transit Road, Williamsville - 8.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Filet Mignon Mushroom Risotto
Stuffed Mushrooms
Eggplant Parmesan
Stuffed Shells
Chicken Piccata
Penne Palermo
Caesar Salad
Lasagna

“Carmine’s catered my daughter & son-in-law’s wedding this past weekend, and the food was delicious. Guests couldn’t stop talking about it. Professional, accommodating, and they met all our needs. Bonus: amazing leftovers for days. Highly recommend Carmine’s for any catered event!“

4 Good91 Reviews
Nowak Catering Bar & Grill •
143 Patricia Lane, Buffalo - 7.31 miles

“Very disappointed in the duck soup. I have been eating it for years and the last batch I purchased at the Polish Festival had carrots in it!! Too thick and gray.Must be someone new making it. When I asked about the carrots, they said they've been doing it like that for years. Huh?!“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Wegmans Catering Caterers • $$
4960 Transit Road, Depew - 3.7 miles

“Was quite disturbed entering the Losson Rd store with a sign about mandatory wearing a mask only to see several adults without a mask. Cmon Wegmans , you really should not post a sign if you’re not going to adhere by your own policy. This is not the time to let this happen.“

3.7 Good3 Reviews