Southside Sub Shop

374 S Main St, Elmira
(607) 734-7045

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Russ M

This sub shop has great subs, great service and great potential. Had they the means to toast their subs like the meatball and steak and cheese, they could take it to the next level.

As it stands, the people working here are courteous, helpful and dedicated, the food is good, the prices very reasonable, and the service is very good. I've become a patron. I wish they had an oven to bake or toast their hot subs to perfection.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emily Barrett

Great subs! Pleasant staff. Quick service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bill Batterson

I went there to get tuna subs for my wife and I and they spread the tuna so thin because they didn't want to open a new can. Very disappointed. Will not go there again!!!

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kevin M

Hometown, local favorite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jumbo Sub

Mike Mcguire

As a submarine sandwich connoisseur. I try as many different locations as I can in search of a great submarine sandwich. While not the greatest, South Side Sub shop is acceptable. The best sub on their menu is the jumbo sub. It has cooked ham, chopped ham and salami on it. I get it with mayo, lettuce,tomato, onions , banana peppers and Italian dressing.One major thing I don't like is they use chopped onions. A submarine sandwich to me should have thinly sliced onions. Not chopped onions. The rolls are always fresh . I've had four of the jumbo subs in the last four months. The first one was very good. The second and third ones were ok. The fourth one was disappointing. The first one was made by a very nice lady. The second and third ones were made by a different lady. The fourth one was made by a young man. The construction of subs by different employees should be consistent. All employees should make them the same way. Instead of different amounts of meat and quality of construction. Southside sub shop subs are ok. With a little attention to detail and consistent quantities of meats. They would be very good

Paul Martin

Best subs

Kenzie Palmer

The food always slaps. It’s been a community staple for years, way better than Subway any day.
I’m happy they are still here. They are affordable and delicious.

Dawn Seeley

Love this place 😄 always have

John

Always has great food

Charlotte McIntosh

Take out only. Cold Subs are great. Everything was very fresh. Very good rolls. Asked for oil & vinegar instead of mayo. They put both which made it soggy but it was still good.

Nicole DeRico

The Southside Sub Shop has been a family favorite since childhood. On our last trip I was rather disappointed. I felt as if I had ordered a bread and lettuce sub. Portions were NOT what they used to be. Prices have gone up (but what HASN'T). Well, I decided to give the Sub Shop another chance. This time we ordered doubled meat. It was the sub I remembered from long ago! Although you shouldn't have to pay extra just to receive what was once the norm, I definitely recommend giving them another try if you, like me have been disappointed in their subs in recent years. Just ask them to go heavy on the ingredients and you will be happy that you did!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Regular, Roast Beef

Ashanti Williams

Everytime i call nobody answer

Travis Foster

It's a sandwich

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Thomas Brooks

Excellent always...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nik Chase

Love it, mom and pop style shop. Excellent friendly service, very fast. Fresh rolls, home made mac salad, I highly recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...