The Bagel Shoppe
$ • Caterers
Hours:
986 Main St, Fishkill
(845) 896-3823
About The Bagel Shoppe
Customers' Favorites
Breakfast Sandwich w Ham Sausage or Bacon
Flavored Cream Cheese
Black & White Cookie
Tuna on Salt Bagel
Bagel All the Way
1dz Bagels 13
Strawberry
Muffins
Rolls
Lox
The Bagel Shoppe Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Tuesday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Wednesday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Thursday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Saturday | 6AM - 4PM |
| Sunday | 6AM - 3PM |
People in Fishkill Also Viewed
Empire Bagels
Cafe, Bagels
The Bagel Shoppe
Bagels, Coffee & Tea, American
Bagel World
Breakfast, Coffee & Tea, Bagels
The Bagel Shoppe is a popular spot for delicious bagels and a variety of cream cheese flavors. Customers can choose from options like herb and strawberry cream cheese, with the strawberry cream cheese being a favorite for its perfect sweetness and chunks of strawberries. The bagels have a wonderful flavor, with poppy seed rolls being a highlight in breakfast sandwiches.
The food is generally well-liked, and the staff is described as friendly. However, there have been instances where staff seemed more focused on call-in orders, leaving walk-in customers waiting. It is recommended that the shop designates staff for call-in orders to improve service for in-person customers.
Pricing is considered reasonable, and the selection of bagels and cream cheese flavors is impressive. The breakfast sandwiches, including the SEC (sausage, egg, and cheese) and BEC (bacon, egg, and cheese), receive positive feedback, with the sausage sandwich being the most filling. Some customers have experienced issues with DoorDash orders, so it might be best to call ahead for pickup or order in person.
The cozy café/deli has a welcoming atmosphere, with a group of regular customers typically present in the mornings, contributing to a friendly neighborhood corner bodega feel. A popular item is the large black and white cookie, often enjoyed at parties and special occasions.