Anthony’s Supper Club
$ • Italian
Hours:
174 Ivory St, Frewsburg
(716) 922-4054
About Anthony’s Supper Club
Customers' Favorites
Anthony’s Supper Club Reviews
Share your opinion about Anthony’s Supper Club
If you're looking for authentic Italian cuisine that feels straight out of Italy, Anthony’s supper club is an absolute gem. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm smiles, the comforting aroma of fresh herbs, and an atmosphere that perfectly balances rustic charm with modern elegance.
We started with the red, white and blue burger — creamy, rich, and perfectly paired with the truffle fries. The sauce was this beautiful balance of heat, richness, and...read full review
this may be a long review but please read it all!! I've eaten here a few times. but I decided to rent out the location for tonight. after tonight I decided I needed to write this. from the first interaction til the end of the event anthony was kind curteous, and very informative about prices and any food details. he helped pick out a custom menu for my event. come to the evening of my event everything was on time as discussed. I chose family style dining since that is what I usually...read full review
Eggplant Parmesan and a Mushroom Swiss Burger with fresh cut fries were awesome
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 - 10PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 10PM |
| Friday | 4 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 10PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in Frewsburg Also Viewed
Anthony's Supper Club offers great food and an enjoyable dining experience. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, featuring rustic charm combined with modern elegance. Customers mention the comforting aroma of fresh herbs as they enter, enhancing the overall ambiance. While the restaurant can be busy, leading to some wait times, the attentive service stands out. Reviewers frequently commend the staff for their knowledge of the menu and their ability to make special requests work.
The quality of the dishes is impressive, with many recommending the authentic Italian cuisine. Highlights include the red, white and blue burger, which is creamy and rich, paired beautifully with truffle fries. The pasta is made fresh daily, while the prime rib is noted for being tender and flavorful. The shrimp is cooked to perfection, enhanced by just the right amount of spice and garlic. The pizza is often praised as one of the best in the area, and customers are encouraged to try the Jamaican Jerk Pizza for a unique treat.
Desserts, particularly the pies, receive high praise for being light, airy, and not overly sweet. Portion sizes are generous, offering excellent value for the price. Although service can sometimes be slow, the overall experience is consistently excellent, with many customers planning to return for another meal at this exceptional spot. Whether celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a delicious meal, Anthony's Supper Club is a fantastic choice.