The Hidden Oak Café

Name: The Hidden Oak Café
Address: 440 Montauk Hwy, Great River, New York, 11739, US
Telephone: (631) 277-3895
Price range: $
Rating: 3.6

$ • Cafe, Salad

Hours:
440 Montauk Hwy, Great River
(631) 277-3895

About The Hidden Oak Café

The Hidden Oak Café, located in the Manor House at the Bayard Cutting Arboretum, offers a pleasant atmosphere for tea or a meal. The café provides friendly service and a relaxed environment, with options for indoor and outdoor seating. Visitors can enjoy a variety of food and tea choices, including reasonably-priced meals and delicious baked goods such as crumb and Kahlua cakes. They also serve a Victorian Tea, which includes a tea pot per person, scone, and pistachio cake, with decor that enhances the charming experience. The café is situated on the grand porch of the 1886 Manor House, offering beautiful views of the Great Lawn stretching down to the Connetquot River. The scenic setting and good food make it a popular spot for visitors.

Recent reviews highlight the incredible food, especially the delicate pastries, authentic clotted cream, and flavorful preserves. The caramel tea is highly recommended for its sweet and soothing qualities. However, some customers noted that the service did not always meet expectations, with instances of delayed attention and abrupt interactions. Despite this, the quality of the food and tea makes the café worth visiting.

Guests have enjoyed their time at the café, appreciating the outdoor seating even if the view wasn't perfect. The quiche and large scones received positive remarks. Additionally, the staff has been commended for their attentiveness, especially during events like baby showers. Overall, the Hidden Oak Café aims to maintain a welcoming atmosphere, though improvements in service could enhance the experience further.