Andy’s Restaurant Greenport New York

Don't waste your time and go somewhere else in the area. Went for mother’s day with my family of 4. Food is overpriced and gross. My husband got a Ruben sandwich which was mediocre. The spaghetti for my kids was watery and my burger meat tasted disgusting. Only plus was they didnt charge me for my glass of wine for mothers day. Needless to say half of our foods were left on the plates when we left and we wont be returning when we are in the area.

First time visiting Greenport. Must say, Andy’s is a place to visit. Food is delicious, atmosphere is fun, and Sterling is the best! They allowed a fundraiser event, near and dear to my heart, to promote awareness and raise funds for cancer in their establishment. Must try the HUGE pretzel..so good! This is a “must visit” in Greenport!!

1/26 Went to watch the Bills game & had the fried chicken special which was delicious!

Chicken sandwich was excellent.

I’ve been here a few times and always had a great experience. But this last time was really great and I felt I had to leave a review. Andy and team really made it a special evening for my friends birthday, going above and beyond. The drinks were great, the food was amazing as usual. As someone who has lived out here for 30 years, and seen the prices change drastically everywhere, Andy’s remains reasonable compared to everyone else. And the family vibe in the restaurant is appreciated. Thanks guys for everything! (PS there were about 20 of us and everyone enjoyed the food and it was all brought out quickly!)

Nice place. Enjoyed the food and atmosphere. Was a good spot to meet up with others. Will be back!

Went to Andy's to see a friend playing the guitar. The nicest people, the food was great very chill vibe

Nice place in the middle of town.. Greenport, NY. Good food. Pleasant, efficient service. Worth a visit. You won't be disappointed .

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, New England Clam Chowder, Reuben Sandwich

Fish and fries... excellent with a glass of vino!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice place. Good service. Only one issue, my wife fell over the step at the entrance. It is marked but the marking needs to be improved. Brighter lighting would help.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Best-Ever Creamy Tomato Soup, New England Clam Chowder

I thought the food quality and service were great until we got the bill and were charged $1 a piece for each condiment on our ‘Happy Hour’ burgers and my date didn’t even ask for mayo. Six dollars for beer does not seem like a ‘Happy Hour’ price. I know food prices are high but that was ridiculous. No wonder the place was empty.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Amazing! We had a party of 30+ they closed the restaurant for us, since other patrons would havta wait. Service was fast, friendly & delicious!! Very gracious & accommodating staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I thought the food quality and service were great until we got the bill and were charged $1 a piece for each condiment on our ‘Happy Hour’ burgers and my date didn’t even ask for mayo. Six dollars for beer does not seem like a ‘Happy Hour’ price. I know food prices are high but that was ridiculous. No wonder the place was empty.

Felt like I had to leave a review as this has been my worst dining experience in recent memory. Extremely overpriced and terrible tasting food. Order broiled scallops, which was listed on the menu as MP. Given that it's a sports bar and I'm used to city prices, I didnt ask and soon learned that was a mistake.

Out came 7 pieces of scallops with absolutely no flavor and had a texture as if they were tossed right onto the heat from being frozen. A few strands (5 maybe?) of asparagus and a bowl of white rice. Very poor qualify food so I figured it can't be that pricy again. We also got 8 chicken wings the size of at MOST 1.5 inches, again with absolutely no taste and barely edible, and some sweet potato fries that were admittedly alright.

$72 for this absolute garbage. $38 alone for the scallops... Absolutely shocked and felt like I was properly scammed. I can get a proper cooked meal for 2 in Queens for $38 at a host of places that have food worth eating.

There was only 1 waiter, and the poor guy was running around rushing to take care of all their patrons.

I am shocked this place has the rating it does and let this heed as a warning for visitors in Greenport.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

It was nice in there, there were lots ov tvs with sports, and the server was nice. I had the beef gyro, and it was good ig, but the beef was disgusting.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4