Andy’s Restaurant Greenport New York

For burgers and sandwiches, Andy's is a great choice. Our server, Jen, made great recommendations and engaged in a wonderful way with our group. Desert was a delightful brownie sundae.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food awesome service and live music too. Food was too good to take pics before we ate almost all of it. Buffalo cauliflower and fried pickles. Incredible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We were served food with dead bugs in it and rotten seared tuna. When we told the waiter they took $13 off of our $260 bill. Food was terrible

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Enjoyed a Sunday lunch here with my family. I forget the waiter’s name but I overheard him say he was 17. The kid works hard and was very attentive. Service and food were great. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was ok but not great, not worth the price. Won’t recommend unless you just want to grab a beer and watch the game.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

A good old, regular bar.

Unreal bar spot, Andy is an absolute legend and even gave me a Tide to go stick when I spilled on my pants. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The atmosphere was excellent and the service truly outstanding. While the food was somewhat underwhelming and didn’t quite meet expectations, the portion sizes were very generous. Pricing felt a bit high for the quality of the dishes. On a positive note, complimentary popcorn upon arrival was a nice touch and added to the overall experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Don't waste your time and go somewhere else in the area. Went for mother’s day with my family of 4. Food is overpriced and gross. My husband got a Ruben sandwich which was mediocre. The spaghetti for my kids was watery and my burger meat tasted disgusting. Only plus was they didnt charge me for my glass of wine for mothers day. Needless to say half of our foods were left on the plates when we left and we wont be returning when we are in the area.

First time visiting Greenport. Must say, Andy’s is a place to visit. Food is delicious, atmosphere is fun, and Sterling is the best! They allowed a fundraiser event, near and dear to my heart, to promote awareness and raise funds for cancer in their establishment. Must try the HUGE pretzel..so good! This is a “must visit” in Greenport!!

1/26 Went to watch the Bills game & had the fried chicken special which was delicious!

Chicken sandwich was excellent.

I’ve been here a few times and always had a great experience. But this last time was really great and I felt I had to leave a review. Andy and team really made it a special evening for my friends birthday, going above and beyond. The drinks were great, the food was amazing as usual. As someone who has lived out here for 30 years, and seen the prices change drastically everywhere, Andy’s remains reasonable compared to everyone else. And the family vibe in the restaurant is appreciated. Thanks guys for everything! (PS there were about 20 of us and everyone enjoyed the food and it was all brought out quickly!)

Nice place. Enjoyed the food and atmosphere. Was a good spot to meet up with others. Will be back!

Went to Andy's to see a friend playing the guitar. The nicest people, the food was great very chill vibe