very nice experience! we were a group of 8 who had a reservation for 4 pm but were early in Greenport so we decided to see if they could accomodate us earlier. And they did! thing that stood out was the great service! Our server Nicole was very upbeat, friendly and efficient. So were the others, the hostess, etc. who made it seem they were happy to work there. Food was OK and we were a bit disappointed because the band that was supposed to play canceled so there was no live music. But the service made it a very gratifying experience. looking forward to next time.
cara
The steamers were awful. Extremely fishy. The hamburger tasted like a mouth full of salt. The fried onion dings were delicious. My husband did enjoy his lobster roll. Ambiance felt like we were in a giant hall.
Kenneth
The only phone number available is to the other restaurant you have which is no longer open. We came expecting a normal dinner menu, which is what you have on the website, but all you had was mostly sandwiches.
Sharon
I booked 10 people for drinks and dinner-4:00 pm. Hostess very nice received confirmation texts. Waiter excellent. He seemed busy at different tables but gave us good attention. The food was horrible. Fish tacos cold and tasteless. No spice. No salt and pepper on table. Fried calamari was over fried and cold. Dipping sauce bland. Music plays so loud that one guest had to leave. We could not talk. Even loud voices could nearly be heard. When the loud music stopped, the acoustics were so bad we still couldn't hear. Unfortunately, I would not recommend. Maybe if you like loud bar experience it would appeal to you.
Daniella
generally a poor experience overall—food was cold and flavorless. unfortunately wouldn't recommend, the experience was overall disappointing for what we were expecting.
Rebecca
The clam chatter taste like you're eating the ocean almost like a clear broth chowder compared to a New England clam chowder. Overall, no one‘s food was very good and the bloody Mary's tasted like cocktail sauce. There were six of us and we arrived at opening and they were like shocked to see guests. It was a really strange vibe, and our waiter was fantastic, but some of the other wait staff was really peculiar walking by our table, so close and just staring at us bizarre. This ended up being our most expensive dining in Greenport in the surrounding towns and it was definitely not worth it. It was $55 a person and most of us didn't even order seafood, besides the clam chowder and there were only three cocktails ordered.
Jeff
Appetizer was good hummus..we had the salmon which was a bit overcooked and had no taste..a bit disappointed
Cheryl
Having been here many times, I was extremely disappointed in our dinner last night. Completely overpriced, lobster dishes, and my fish was cold and overdone. Thewait staff could not have been nicer, but it did not make funny up for the lack of quality of the food. I won't go back.
Angelica
It's been a few years since we have been here. Clam chowder, calamari and mahi mahi Caesar wrap were tasty...but pretty standard fare. We were there over Labor Day weekend...good crowd not too rowdy. Like the new decor.
Eileen
We live in North Babylon and do a daytrip out to Claudios once a year. Claudios is a nice place to visit, especially if the weather is cooperating. The food is pretty good, but I'm sorry to say that I think they are a bit pricey - because they are so popular and people go no matter what, so they know they can get their prices. That's why we only go there once a year and opt for other places as well.
They purposely overbook, so even if on time, everyone always waits at least 45 minutes to sit down for dinner. Food was blah. Uninspired menu. Lots of "fried" options. But bar scene was fun. Better off eating somewhere else and just go there for drinks.
Joi
Our calamari tasted like it was flash fried a couple times, super chewy. Fish and chips were very basic, fish tasted previously frozen, fries were great. Chicken Caesar wrap was okay, chicken was dry but dressing made up for it. Overall I think the actual restaurant is much better than the waterfront restaurant, which I think is purposeful
Stephanie
Our waiter was super friendly and the live music was an extra perk and so much fun for our girls weekend
Tiffany
Great drinks and good vibes for a weekend lunch! The food was well portioned but the wraps only had a few pieces of chicken in them. However, the service was NOT it. The hostess gave me a nasty attitude for showing up an hour early to my reservation, when I had already explained we just came to sit at the bar first (Even though there were plenty of open seats to be sat early if we really wanted to). The server was friendly enough but hard to catch and we had to ask a couple of times to get other drinks/food/other needs. Overall does the job for a waterfront restaurant, but not much else
Maura
Slow service. Messed up order. Took them three attempts to sort out the bill for the messed up order. Nice location but loud.
very nice experience! we were a group of 8 who had a reservation for 4 pm but were early in Greenport so we decided to see if they could accomodate us earlier. And they did! thing that stood out was the great service! Our server Nicole was very upbeat, friendly and efficient. So were the others, the hostess, etc. who made it seem they were happy to work there. Food was OK and we were a bit disappointed because the band that was supposed to play canceled so there was no live music. But the service made it a very gratifying experience. looking forward to next time.
The steamers were awful. Extremely fishy. The hamburger tasted like a mouth full of salt. The fried onion dings were delicious. My husband did enjoy his lobster roll. Ambiance felt like we were in a giant hall.
The only phone number available is to the other restaurant you have which is no longer open. We came expecting a normal dinner menu, which is what you have on the website, but all you had was mostly sandwiches.
I booked 10 people for drinks and dinner-4:00 pm. Hostess very nice received confirmation texts. Waiter excellent. He seemed busy at different tables but gave us good attention. The food was horrible. Fish tacos cold and tasteless. No spice. No salt and pepper on table. Fried calamari was over fried and cold. Dipping sauce bland. Music plays so loud that one guest had to leave. We could not talk. Even loud voices could nearly be heard. When the loud music stopped, the acoustics were so bad we still couldn't hear. Unfortunately, I would not recommend. Maybe if you like loud bar experience it would appeal to you.
generally a poor experience overall—food was cold and flavorless. unfortunately wouldn't recommend, the experience was overall disappointing for what we were expecting.
The clam chatter taste like you're eating the ocean almost like a clear broth chowder compared to a New England clam chowder. Overall, no one‘s food was very good and the bloody Mary's tasted like cocktail sauce. There were six of us and we arrived at opening and they were like shocked to see guests. It was a really strange vibe, and our waiter was fantastic, but some of the other wait staff was really peculiar walking by our table, so close and just staring at us bizarre. This ended up being our most expensive dining in Greenport in the surrounding towns and it was definitely not worth it. It was $55 a person and most of us didn't even order seafood, besides the clam chowder and there were only three cocktails ordered.
Appetizer was good hummus..we had the salmon which was a bit overcooked and had no taste..a bit disappointed
Having been here many times, I was extremely disappointed in our dinner last night. Completely overpriced, lobster dishes, and my fish was cold and overdone. Thewait staff could not have been nicer, but it did not make funny up for the lack of quality of the food. I won't go back.
It's been a few years since we have been here. Clam chowder, calamari and mahi mahi Caesar wrap were tasty...but pretty standard fare. We were there over Labor Day weekend...good crowd not too rowdy. Like the new decor.
We live in North Babylon and do a daytrip out to Claudios once a year. Claudios is a nice place to visit, especially if the weather is cooperating. The food is pretty good, but I'm sorry to say that I think they are a bit pricey - because they are so popular and people go no matter what, so they know they can get their prices. That's why we only go there once a year and opt for other places as well.
Restaurantji Recommends
They purposely overbook, so even if on time, everyone always waits at least 45 minutes to sit down for dinner. Food was blah. Uninspired menu. Lots of "fried" options. But bar scene was fun. Better off eating somewhere else and just go there for drinks.
Our calamari tasted like it was flash fried a couple times, super chewy. Fish and chips were very basic, fish tasted previously frozen, fries were great. Chicken Caesar wrap was okay, chicken was dry but dressing made up for it. Overall I think the actual restaurant is much better than the waterfront restaurant, which I think is purposeful
Our waiter was super friendly and the live music was an extra perk and so much fun for our girls weekend
Great drinks and good vibes for a weekend lunch! The food was well portioned but the wraps only had a few pieces of chicken in them. However, the service was NOT it. The hostess gave me a nasty attitude for showing up an hour early to my reservation, when I had already explained we just came to sit at the bar first (Even though there were plenty of open seats to be sat early if we really wanted to). The server was friendly enough but hard to catch and we had to ask a couple of times to get other drinks/food/other needs. Overall does the job for a waterfront restaurant, but not much else
Slow service. Messed up order. Took them three attempts to sort out the bill for the messed up order. Nice location but loud.
Loading...