Custom Cakes near Hampton Bays, NY

1 Familia Bakery

4.8 Superb 53 Reviews

252-9 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays

• Delivery

“I'm a regular at Familia Bakery's Farmingville location, so I was excited to stop into the Hampton Bays shop, and it lived up to everything I love about this bakery. It had the same quality, the same care, and the same friendly service I've come to expect. Familia is who I trust with every custom birthday cake for my students, and they always go above and beyond on the design and the details. Their chocolate cake is a favorite in my house, especially with my girlfriend. It's great to know there's another location out east with the same standards. If you're in the Hampton Bays area and need a cake for a celebration, or you just want something fresh and sweet, stop in. You won't be disappointed.”

2 Rustik Cake Studio

4.5 Superb 21 Reviews

53 Hill Street Ste 72, Southampton · 6.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I took the Lambeth boot camp and everything was great. Thank you Rocío. Tomé el boot camp de Lambeth y todo estuvo super bien. Gracias por todo Rocío!”

3 Ben & Jerry’s

4.3 Superb 59 Reviews

121 Main Street, Westhampton Beach · 7.72 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Nothing but FANTASTIC things to say about my experience with Antoinette and the catering aspect of Ben & Jerry's of Westhampton. We used them to cater a sundae bar party for our wedding on June 30th at Bellport Country Club and from start to finish Antoinette was a PLEASURE to deal with, so incredibly helpful, not pushy at all, and attentive to my requests. I would literally get excited every time I had to talk to her! On the day of our wedding, the sundae bar was everything I could have dreamed of and more. From the photo props, to the flavors sign, to the toppings, scoopers, and of course the ice cream---worth every penny! If you are even remotely considering getting this store to cater an event of yours DO IT! You will not regret it :) Thank you Antoinette!!!!!!!!!!!”