Gemelli Gelato of Hampton Bays

Fantastic gelato.

A little expensive and cash only, but damn is it good!

Delicious gelato… Rum Raisin and Nutella are such favorites so yummy. Love the grounds to sit or even play corn hole while enjoying your gelato👍

We’ve been coming here every time we’re in the area. Always great! Well curated selection of high quality gelato and sorbetto.

This place is pretty cool. Had the blueberry basil.Tastes like summer in a cup. Also had the coffee chip and cannoli. So good. Definitely recommend and will be back for more.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Gemeli Gelato – Westhampton, NY
Visited June 1, 2025 with the LUCOA Corvette Club

Stopped in with the LUCOA Corvette Club on a beautiful Sunday drive, and Gemeli did not disappoint. I had the three-scoop bowl with pistachio, Nutella, and sacharetella—each one was absolutely spot-on.

The pistachio was rich and creamy with real nut flavor (none of that fake green stuff), the Nutella was smooth and decadent, and the sacharetella had those incredible chocolate shavings that melt just right. All three worked perfectly together without one overpowering the others.

You can tell everything’s made fresh and with care. Staff was friendly, the place was clean, and the vibe was relaxed—perfect stop on a Long Island summer day. Highly recommend if you’re anywhere near Westhampton. I’ll definitely be back.

Gemelli Gelato is a charming, family-owned gelato shop located at 139 W Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays, New York. Tucked away on a gentle slope off the main road, the shop shares an entrance with Buckley’s Inn Between and is situated across from Villa Paul restaurant .

While the interior of Gemelli Gelato is cozy, the true allure lies in its expansive outdoor area. Guests can relax on Adirondack chairs and picnic tables scattered across a well-maintained lawn, creating a perfect setting for families and friends to enjoy their treats. The outdoor space also features lawn games like cornhole, adding to the inviting and playful atmosphere .

Gemelli Gelato offers over 24 flavors of gelato and sorbetto, catering to a variety of tastes, including vegan options. In addition to their frozen delights, they serve a selection of chocolates, coffee, and cold drinks. The shop is known for its inventive cones, such as red velvet and birthday cake flavors, enhancing the overall dessert experience .

Please note that Gemelli Gelato operates on a seasonal basis and is cash-only; however, an ATM is available on-site for customer convenience .

Whether you’re stopping by after a day at the beach or during a scenic drive through Long Island, Gemelli Gelato provides a delightful and memorable experience for all ages.

The place looked nice Stopped here while in the area , the gelato was good , very small place on the inside so the line always forms outside and they let a few people in at a time so be prepared for a wait if you are standing outside , also when you order they make your order and put it in a bag or hand it to you and when you get to the register the owner asks you what you have and then after he asks you that he opens the bag to double check which I did not like because don’t ask someone what they have in there bag and then open then bag after it’s not right : either ask them and trust the customer or hush open the bag without saying anything. It was good gelato but I would not go out of my way to stop here.

Really mediocre, definitely didn’t taste like gelato, I think it was ice cream, and cash only, pricey, small cone $9.

Great vibe, tasty gelatos, friendly service. Loved our visit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious

Gemelli Gelato in Hampton Bay offers some of the best ice cream and gelato in the Hamptons. This charming spot features a cozy outdoor seating area. The gelato is exceptionally creamy and smooth, with a wide selection of delectable flavors like lavender, chocolate, and red velvet. Highly recommended for visitors to the Hamptons, Gemelli Gelato has ample parking available, though they only accept cash payments, not credit cards.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very cute place with a nice outdoor area. Ice cream was very tasty and smooth. Vast range of flavors. Also you can choose the flavors of your cone. I had salted caramel in toasted coconut flavored cone. Highly recommend this place when in Hamptons.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is the best and offers so many flavors to choose from! I got the rainbow cookie which was so yummy! Its also a great location with a ton of seats outside to enjoy your gelato. There is even a cute chair that is shaped like an ice cream cone!
I cannot wait to go back and the owners are the best they are always looking to support other businesses. If you are looking to enjoy a sweet treat i promise this is the place to go!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

As other reviews stated it's a ripoff place. Guy at the counter said that I can put 4 scoops in 2 separate cups, but he charged for those plastic cups around $4.Not friendly staff. It wasn't busy but it felt like they can't wait to get rid of the customers.. Hamptons deserves better..
P. S. Owner replied shortly after.. Very unhappy guy and not honest as you can see in his reply. I wish him to be happy and value what he has..

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Was really nice place to relax and enjoy some gelatos with my brothers!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Strawberry