Consistently the best BTL’s anywhere!!! The bacon is always cooked perfectly! We love it on the Kaiser roll. The owners are always gracious and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angelina
Basic bagel shop with a young female employee that never smiled. The first thing she asks me - scoop? The boss explains that people want their bagels hollowed out for sandwiches… oh ok, well how about——good morning, would you like me to… Does anybody do proper customer service anymore? Behind the counter is kind of disorganized and the place is sort of clean. I sat down with my bagel. I realized they didn’t give me cream cheese on both sides of my bagel and it was just a smear on one side. We’re in the Hamptons people. Do you really need to save every penny by giving me less cream cheese on my bagel.? They put more cream cheese on my bagel, but I can’t say that I would come back in here again . 07/17/2025 1045 am
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
Grey Price
Delicious breakfast food, served hot and fresh every morning! Service is great, even on a busy morning they'll have you in and out as fast as possible! Next time you come to visit, definitely try a 'bacon, egg, & cheese with hashbrown and breakfast sausage' it's the best!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
L Geezey
Stopped here while in the area for something else. I ordered a toasted bagel and a bagel with cream cheese. With only 2 people in front of me it took 15 minutes for me to get my bagels. I ordered a toasted bagel that was barely put on the grill. The place was very cluttered and the signs had multiple layers of paper and stickers where prices had been changed. Upon eating the bagels I ordered they were less than appealing. With a number of bagel places on the island , I’m surprised this place still sells bagels. The bagels made here are not a good representation of a Long Island Bagel. They offer many other things such as fresh juice and smoothies and other sandwiches, so maybe those items are better but trust the reviews and do not waste your time with ordering bagels from here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Larisa Schadt
My $17 chicken cutlet sandwhich with wilted lettuce, half a roll of chicken cutlet, and about a half a slice of cheese. Disgusting, biggest waste of money
Alex
Very long wait to get something that looked pretty gross ultimately.
Miguel Morales
It is one of my favorite places to have breakfast and lunch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
sean ryan
Garbage bagel shaped bread. Occasionally visitors will get us as a gesture before we can stop them and we graciously eat them while cruelly shooting glances to each other. Are we monsters? Probably. Do we know a good bagel? Definitely.
Matthew English
The bagels are over priced and not good quality. I told them I wanted three toasted bagels. I watched them put cream cheese on the un-toasted bagels. I asked if they would toast them and they said if it’s asked for which it was. They could have corrected the order and apologized but proceeded to just give me overpriced, low quality cold bagels without an apology. . .
Tanya Milanova
The bagels were the lowest quality more like supermarket shelf taste, Why sell those kind of bagels on LI bagel shop, taste like the cheap store plastic bag bagels. The place atmosphere is nice but they should change their bagel suppliers. It’s too bad, we were so exited to have found a bagel place in Hampton Bays but our family is not going back.
Best bagels in hampton bays! Staff is so friendly and easy going!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matteo
The owners Ron and Steve are the nicest guys in the whole world!And their food is grandma's recipe!Try the soups, wraps and smoothies.Everything is so Yummy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luz Devia
Good parking, delicious products
Parking: Easy access to parking
Wheelchair accessibility: Has good wheelchair access
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kevin Lucas
Great food will
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jon Calfa
Don't know how to make a BLT use to much bacon not enough lettuce. More lettuce and tomato 3 or 4 slices of bacon. I get a BLT to have a healthy
Consistently the best BTL’s anywhere!!! The bacon is always cooked perfectly! We love it on the Kaiser roll. The owners are always gracious and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Basic bagel shop with a young female employee that never smiled. The first thing she asks me - scoop? The boss explains that people want their bagels hollowed out for sandwiches… oh ok, well how about——good morning, would you like me to…
Does anybody do proper customer service anymore?
Behind the counter is kind of disorganized and the place is sort of clean.
I sat down with my bagel. I realized they didn’t give me cream cheese on both sides of my bagel and it was just a smear on one side. We’re in the Hamptons people. Do you really need to save every penny by giving me less cream cheese on my bagel.?
They put more cream cheese on my bagel, but I can’t say that I would come back in here again .
07/17/2025 1045 am
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
Delicious breakfast food, served hot and fresh every morning! Service is great, even on a busy morning they'll have you in and out as fast as possible! Next time you come to visit, definitely try a 'bacon, egg, & cheese with hashbrown and breakfast sausage' it's the best!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped here while in the area for something else. I ordered a toasted bagel and a bagel with cream cheese. With only 2 people in front of me it took 15 minutes for me to get my bagels. I ordered a toasted bagel that was barely put on the grill. The place was very cluttered and the signs had multiple layers of paper and stickers where prices had been changed. Upon eating the bagels I ordered they were less than appealing. With a number of bagel places on the island , I’m surprised this place still sells bagels. The bagels made here are not a good representation of a Long Island Bagel. They offer many other things such as fresh juice and smoothies and other sandwiches, so maybe those items are better but trust the reviews and do not waste your time with ordering bagels from here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
My $17 chicken cutlet sandwhich with wilted lettuce, half a roll of chicken cutlet, and about a half a slice of cheese. Disgusting, biggest waste of money
Very long wait to get something that looked pretty gross ultimately.
It is one of my favorite places to have breakfast and lunch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Garbage bagel shaped bread. Occasionally visitors will get us as a gesture before we can stop them and we graciously eat them while cruelly shooting glances to each other. Are we monsters? Probably. Do we know a good bagel? Definitely.
The bagels are over priced and not good quality. I told them I wanted three toasted bagels. I watched them put cream cheese on the un-toasted bagels. I asked if they would toast them and they said if it’s asked for which it was. They could have corrected the order and apologized but proceeded to just give me overpriced, low quality cold bagels without an apology. . .
The bagels were the lowest quality more like supermarket shelf taste, Why sell those kind of bagels on LI bagel shop, taste like the cheap store plastic bag bagels. The place atmosphere is nice but they should change their bagel suppliers. It’s too bad, we were so exited to have found a bagel place in Hampton Bays but our family is not going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Best bagels in hampton bays! Staff is so friendly and easy going!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The owners Ron and Steve are the nicest guys in the whole world!And their food is grandma's recipe!Try the soups, wraps and smoothies.Everything is so Yummy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good parking, delicious products
Parking: Easy access to parking
Wheelchair accessibility: Has good wheelchair access
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great food will
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Don't know how to make a BLT use to much bacon not enough lettuce. More lettuce and tomato 3 or 4 slices of bacon. I get a BLT to have a healthy
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Loading...