Tully's Seafood Market & Snack Shack

I've never seen a shrimp ? so smallAnd not de vein.Keep driving you will thank me

Save your time, your appetite, and your money by going somewhere else- anywhere else. There was only one other couple in the restaurant yet it still took 35 minutes to serve the worst lobster rolls I’ve ever had in my life. They were rubbery and tasted a week old. You’re forced to buy two at a time and can’t choose 1 hit or 1 cold. Bathrooms were disgusting and it was overall a bad experience- wish I could get my precious minutes of vacation back and money. I don’t post often but this experience drove me to post.

It's all about junk food. I rode my bike with some friends from the city and wanted a decent place to eat for lunch. We got the pression to be ripped off. Our food was only "junk food" at a very high price and we struggled to get tap water. I personally had the Mac and Cheese as I am vegetarian and i felt it was not "home made".

Stopped there after riding 32 miles on my road bike for a salad and a fried seafood combo. They weren't busy (which I should have picked up on). It took about 20 minutes to get my food. I substituted the fries for a side salad. The salad was very good. I can't say the same about the combo platter of fried shrimp, clam strips and flounder. The shrimp was fried batter with the tiniest about of actual shrimp. There were only a few clam straps and the flounder was ok. For $30, I was expecting it to be good, but, it was fair at it's best.

Decent food but lobster roll + conch fritters and a Bud light was $95. I was told it was two lobster rolls but more like 1 lobster roll spread out over two buns. Food was tasty but not tasty enough for a paper plate joint to warrant that pricing.

Stopped in the market to grab some fresh fish on the way home from the beach and spontaneously also got a Qt of Seafood Gumbo. Let me tell you my tastebuds were sent straight to New Orleans that gumbo was so good! 10/10 would recommend!

Really nice staff and you get double the amount of food compared to other places. Had the lobster rolls and they came with waffle fries so what’s not to love

Ordered grilled shrimp tacos and blackened cod tacos .The cod was not blackened and both orders of tacos had a scarce amount of fish on them for the price tag. The tacos themselves weren't bad but had so much Sriracha sauce on them that we could barely taste anything else. As for staff, they were friendly and accommodating .

Something has gone wrong with this place. Our soft shell crab sandwich was rancid. My friend took one bite and spit it out. Also, insanely overpriced. $36 for tacos. Not worth it. Come back when they get their act together.

French fries were fused together as a solid lump and fish tacos, “where’s the fish” cost &39 for a really bad meal. Now I know why I avoid these summer hot spots and go west for good food. Check out Varneys in Bellport.

THIS PLACE IS A TRUE NIGHTMARE… PLEASE DO NOT GO THERE AND AVOID AT ALL COST! THE FOOD IS HORRIBLE, OVERPRICED AND SCARCE. THERE IS NO WAITER SERVICE. THE ATMOSPHERE IS SIMPLY TOXIC. MENU PRICES HAVE BEEN SIGNIFICANTLY AND UNJUSTIFIABLY INCREASED, AND ARE NOT AS ADVERTISED ON THE WEBSITE.MY FAMILY WAITED ALL YEAR TO RETURN TO TULLY’S FOR A SOFT SHELL CRAB SANDWICH AND I NOW VERY MUCH REGRET WE DID! I CANNOT BELIEVE HOW THIS PLACE FELL OFF BIG TIME IN EVERY POSSIBLE WAY! THE BUSINESS IS MAJORLY UNDERSTAFFED AND UNORGANIZED. LAST YEAR THERE WERE COUNTER PERSONS, COOKS AND WAITERS. THIS YEAR ON A SATURDAY EVENING, THERE WAS ONE POOR KID COVERING THE FISH STORE, PHONE TAKE OUT ORDERS, AS WELL AS THE SHACK TAKE OUT AND SIT IN ORDERS. WE ORDERED 3 SOFT SHELL CRAB SANDWICHES AT $25 EACH AND WHEN THE FOOD FINALLY ARRIVED 40 MINUTES LATER, THE CRABS WERE COLD, SOGGY AND 3 TIMES SMALLER THAN THEY WERE LAST YEAR, EVEN THOUGH THE PRICE OF THE SANDWICH HAS INCREASED FROM $18 TO $25. INSTEAD OF A SOFT SHELL CRAB SANDWICH, WE FELT LIKE WE WERE EATING A VEGETABLE SANDWICH AS THERE WAS BARELY ANY CRAB ON IT. HOW DID YOU MANAGE TO FIND SUCH RUBBERY, TASTELESS TOMATOES IN LONG ISLAND? IF YOU ARE TOO CHEAP TO BUY QUALITY TOMATOES, THEN DONT CHARGE UPSCALE PRICES! THE FRIED CALAMARI WE ORDERED ARRIVED COLD, UNDERCOOKED, WITHOUT MARINARA SAUCE AND THERE WERE LITERALLY 9 PIECES. LOBSTER ROLL WAS DECENT, BUT IT BETTER BE FOR $37 AT A PLACE WITHOUT WAITER SERVICE, WHITE LINEN TABLE CLOTHS AND NO SOAP IN THE BATHROOM. OUR FOOD ARRIVED LATE AND COLD BECAUSE THE KID WHO TOOK MY ORDER IS THE ONE WHO HAD TO BRING IT FROM THE RESTAURANT LOCATED 5 MINUTES AWAY FROM THE SHACK, BUT ONLY AFTER HE COMPLETED TAKING ORDERS FROM THE 10 PEOPLE STANDING BEHIND ME, SO OBVIOUSLY OUR FOOD WAS NO LONGER A PRIORITY ONCE THE MONEY WAS PAID. I GAVE THE KID A NICE TIP AND STILL HAD TO CHASE HIM DOWN FOR OUR ICED TEAS AND MARINARA SAUCE AFTER HE FINALLY DELIVERED OUR FOOD AND WENT STRAIGHT TO TAKING THE NEXT ORDER INSTEAD OF FIRST COMPLETING OURS. I WITNESSED SEVERAL CUSTOMERS WHO GAVE UP ON WAITING FOR THEIR FOOD AND LEFT WITHOUT PAYING FOR THEIR DRINKS. WHILE I WAS TRYING TO OBTAIN MY DRINKS AND MARINARA, I WAS VERBALLY ASSAULTED BY SOMEONE FRUSTRATED IN THE LINE WAITING TO PLACE THEIR ORDER, WHO THOUGHT I WAS CUTTING THE LINE. ANOTHER CUSTOMER EMBARRASSED AND ACCUSED ME OF SPITTING ON HER OYSTERS, WHILE THE KID FINALLY HANDED ME MY DRINKS AND MARINARA SAUCE. NONE OF THIS WOULD HAVE OCCURRED IF THE PLACE WAS PROPERLY STAFFED AND ORGANIZED. I DON’T NEED MY FAMILY TO WITNESS THIS UNNECESSARY DRAMA AND ARGUMENTS, WHILE I AM OVERPAYING FOR BAD FOOD AND NO SERVICE! NEVER COMING BACK TO TULLY’S!

Omg the fried combo was horrible. You can smell the oil a mile away. It felt they had not changed the oil in ages.I had to throw out the whole thing cause I simply couldn’t eat it. Worse than even the worst fast food restaurants. How do they get away with this? The weirdest thing is that the sweet potatoes in one meal seemed freshly done but on the other meal they seemed they had been sitting there forever. Thorough disappointed. Paid $70 for two meals thrown away.

Amazing little stop on the way down to the beach! We went twice, first for soft shell crab sandwich - it was great. Second time we got the hot lobster roll and it was full of tons of lobster meat that was succulent and delicious with the perfect amount of butter! They also have canned alcoholic beverages and mixed drinks like margarita and sangria perfect to bring back with us to the hotel after.

Seafood gumbo was great. The lobster roll was $37 and it wasn't all lobster. It was filled with imitation crab (I'd say 70%)with little bits of lobster claw meat (30%). I don't recommend the lobster roll.

Worst food and waitress ever I waited almost two hours to get a salad and dressing. The food very very salty. The owner was so nasty. The waitressdidn't know anything when we asked her a question. She never brought bread to the table had to wait 45 minutes just to get bread. All the seating arrangement was so terrible. It like no-one knew what they where doing.