Black Forest Mill
716 NY-32, Highland Mills
(845) 928-9895
Order Online
Recent Reviews
By far the best, most Authentic German restaurant in the area. Sure, preparing food takes time so if you want fast food then go elsewhere but the food is excellent as well as the atmosphere. Authentic German Beer is sold in German liter glasses and my glass was never empty. Wunder bah!!!
Really quite good. Started with the MASSIVE pretzel, chicken liver pate, and their complimentary German potato salad and cole slaw. Meals were sauerbraten with braised cabbage and chicken schnitzel with sauerkraut, both with spätzle. Very good food all around (flavor, texture, moisture, temperature), but the sauerbraten stood out. Naturally, the beer was great, with the taps being all German...mostly Warsteiner with some Hofbräu-München thrown in (happily, no American...
Original owners are preparing to open up on February 21, 2018. Celebrating "44" years in business this German Restaurant is wunderbar. With a authentic warm , comfortable atmosphere you will feel like you're in Germany.
You May Also Like
Jay's Deli - 534 NY-32
![]()
Deli, Pizza
Tacos Express - 514 NY-32
![]()
Mexican, Coffee & Tea, Tacos