Jay's Deli

$ • Deli, Pizza

Hours:
534 NY-32, Highland Mills
(845) 928-2803

Customers' Favorites

Jay's Deli Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.2 (169)
Restaurantji Rating

Purchased foods while visiting family members. Nice store that also serves hot foods. Several of times buying hot subs and some snacks and drinks. Very friendly staff members. Foods I bought was excellent and delicious. Very happy with visits here!?

Restaurantji Rating

I had a last minute family get together with about 12 people. Jay's was able to accommodate my order for 3 half trays with 2 days notice. We had penne vodka, chicken francese and smashed red potatoes with bacon. Every dish was great, especially the potatoes. The food was ready at the agreed upon time and the aluminum trays came inside cardboard boxes for easy transport. My guests were impressed and looked forward to our next catered event. It's nice to know some businesses still...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

I really enjoy their chicken cutlet hero. Simple ingredients but they understood the assignment! I am a loyal customer from now on! I always grab breakfast or lunch depending when I’m on 32. They are always busy which is an excellent sign of goodness! Thank you Jays Deli for being so yummy! I must try everything!

More Reviews(169)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 7AM - 8PM
Tuesday 7AM - 8PM
Wednesday 7AM - 8PM
Thursday 7AM - 8PM
Friday 7AM - 8PM
Saturday 7AM - 8PM
Sunday 7AM - 5PM
Updated on: