Matteo's Trattoria

$$$ • Italian, Wine Bar

300 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station
(631) 421-6001


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Matteo's Trattoria

Nice looking restaurant but seriously lacking in several areas. Front desk/ hostess station staffed by less then friendly and inviting employees. Servers are over-worked with too many tables and not enough support per server. Service was slow and food was auctioned off at the table. Food was only okay. Basic menu items of Long Island Italian restaurant not that good. Better options around the area.

The service was very good. However, was mediocre at best. My friends food was terrible. she had Branzino. The Branzino was cut very thin and was very dry as a result. She complained to the waiter and he left. Much later on the manager stopped by and she told him it was very dry. Although by this time she had eaten half of this very small piece of fish. He shook his head and walked away. Before we left the waiter brought one small piece of cheesecake for the four of us to full review
Been there many times, food is always good. Service usually good. Went there for my wife's birthday, and they just dropped the ball. Bad table, cramped into a corner with a bunch of bags and corrugated boxes. service not up to par, which I understand due to the pandemic. It came down to the manager being a condescending little prick. There are enough choices for quality Italian in the area, no reason to be treated poorly, not at those prices. Gave the server a good tip, but full review

More Reviews(430)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 5 - 10PM
Wednesday 5 - 10PM
Thursday 5 - 10PM
Friday 5 - 11PM
Saturday 5 - 11PM
Sunday 3 - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.