My family ordered a few different personal pies and found that they were limpy, salty, and had no real flavor. It seemed that they cut corners on the toppings. It appeared that they use toppings from a can or jar. Certainly not worth the price that they charge. We will not be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 1653, White Pie, Prosciutto Arugula Pizza with Parmesan
charles grimm
Food is good. Portion is small.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Noah
This is my 2nd review ever. After tasting this pizza, I had to take it upon myself as a member of society to warn others about the quality of this establishment. All I wanted was a nice hot pie on a cold winter night and what I received was far from that. I ordered the sausage hot honey pizza. This pizza had zero flavor, no amount of red pepper flakes or parmesan could resurrect this pie. Crumbled up bits of sausage sparsely spread around the pie and a few peppers here and there haphazardly with a drizzle of hot honey(the only discernible flavor). The crust had a nice texture but again no flavor. I would’ve opted for bad tasting pizza rather than bland pizza, at least it would give me more to write about. Aside from the boring flavors the atmosphere left a lot to be desired. Walking in, there was a lone dj spinning some obnoxiously loud club beats in a thinly populated restaurant. All this to say I was very disappointed with 1653 pizza. At least the bathrooms were clean.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Hannah
I went here on 1/17 with my boyfriend. Absolute worst pizza of my entire life. I’ve gotten better pizza at bowling alleys. I ordered a buffalo pizza and there was 8 little dollops of shredded chicken that tasted like it came out of a can. I would bet money that it was tuna even because it was so indistinguishable. Had absolutely zero buffalo sauce. If i tasted it I would think it was just a cheese pizza. My boyfriend got the Hot honey sausage pizza and it was equally terrible. They use minimal hot honey and ground sausage is sprinkled on it. Soooo stingy with their ingredients. Everything is shredded or crumbled. We left so angry. This place should be ashamed of themselves. I know that food can be subjective but this is objectively bad food. I see them respond to comments saying they theyre trying to actively improve but people have been writing that it’s bland for years so whatever.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Linda
Pizza was delicious as well as the cocktails. The restaurant has a cozy vibe and our waitress was super nice and attentive. We will definitely be back.
Gemma
Music was great and upbeat bit very loud. No way to have any dinner conversation. Pizza was awesome.
Richard
We celebrated our son and fiancés engagement dinner here. What a fabulous time and the staff outdid themselves. I left a few times to set up as a surprise and it was all executed perfectly when we arrived! The restaurant was quiet and the food was delish!!!
Tom
Great atmosphere,,, Christmas festival in Huntington. Delicious apps and pizza. Service excellent
Ashley Perez
1653 Pizza isn’t your typical pizza spot — it offers a modern, creative take on pizza that makes it stand out in a great way. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the overall vibe feels fresh and inviting.
Parking can be tough, especially on busy days and weekends, so be prepared to circle around a bit, the top shelves could use some clean up But despite all that, the quality of the food and the experience make it worth the trip.
I’ll definitely be visiting again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isaiha Mendez (Imendez)
The wife and I found this spot by accident and it was the best accident ever made! We sat at the bar to try their wood fired pizza and drinks... Let me tell you, as a pizza finatic, this outclasses most on Long Island(and I've tried most). They've even refined it more, nice crust, no flop, savory flavors. Frank is the man and his team is awesome. This place hit home so much we had our after wedding celebration here! Can't recommend this place enough. If your in town, please stop by, you won't regret it.
Great and accommodating staff. Food and drinks are all very good. Vodka rigatoni is a must
Michaila
We went with our family and had delicious pizza and pasta! The drink options are delicious too - even mocktails!
Chris M
This place is consistently good. I would definitely recommend sticking to the pizza and apps though (the pasta dishes are a little on the smaller side). Cocktails and beer selection are above average, and it’s not so large that it turns into a complete zoo. There’s several good pizzerias in Huntington, but if you’re looking for a more elevated experience this is a great option.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna H
We went to the dead chefs society supper club event at this restaurant Wow. Mini preview of lasts night.
Dead Chef’s Tasting Menu at At 1654 Pizza Company – A Gold Coast Supper Club Experience
Last night on Long Island’s Gold Coast, I had the pleasure of experiencing something truly special: Dead Chef’s tasting menu at At 1654 Pizza Company in Huntington. What unfolded wasn’t just a dinner, but a full-on culinary performance that transformed the idea of a neighborhood pizza spot into a hidden gem supper club.
The evening unfolded course after course, each dish layered with creativity, bold flavors, and a touch of surprise. From refined takes on comfort food to plates that made you pause and savor every detail, it was clear that this wasn’t a typical night out—it was a carefully curated journey meant to linger in memory.
The atmosphere matched the menu: intimate, buzzing with energy, and elevated by a sense of discovery. Every dish felt like a conversation, and the storytelling behind the flavors was as captivating as the food itself.
Outstanding is the only word that fits—yet still feels like an understatement. This wasn’t just a meal; it was an experience that makes you excited for what’s next.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vincent Milazzo
The soda cups were very tiny with 4 huge ice cubes in it. The pizza was almost 30 bucks and was only 6 small slices. And the food wasn’t even all that good. Don’t recommend. Was a rip off.
My family ordered a few different personal pies and found that they were limpy, salty, and had no real flavor. It seemed that they cut corners on the toppings. It appeared that they use toppings from a can or jar. Certainly not worth the price that they charge. We will not be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 1653, White Pie, Prosciutto Arugula Pizza with Parmesan
Food is good. Portion is small.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
This is my 2nd review ever. After tasting this pizza, I had to take it upon myself as a member of society to warn others about the quality of this establishment. All I wanted was a nice hot pie on a cold winter night and what I received was far from that. I ordered the sausage hot honey pizza. This pizza had zero flavor, no amount of red pepper flakes or parmesan could resurrect this pie. Crumbled up bits of sausage sparsely spread around the pie and a few peppers here and there haphazardly with a drizzle of hot honey(the only discernible flavor). The crust had a nice texture but again no flavor. I would’ve opted for bad tasting pizza rather than bland pizza, at least it would give me more to write about. Aside from the boring flavors the atmosphere left a lot to be desired. Walking in, there was a lone dj spinning some obnoxiously loud club beats in a thinly populated restaurant. All this to say I was very disappointed with 1653 pizza. At least the bathrooms were clean.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
I went here on 1/17 with my boyfriend.
Absolute worst pizza of my entire life. I’ve gotten better pizza at bowling alleys. I ordered a buffalo pizza and there was 8 little dollops of shredded chicken that tasted like it came out of a can. I would bet money that it was tuna even because it was so indistinguishable. Had absolutely zero buffalo sauce. If i tasted it I would think it was just a cheese pizza. My boyfriend got the Hot honey sausage pizza and it was equally terrible. They use minimal hot honey and ground sausage is sprinkled on it. Soooo stingy with their ingredients. Everything is shredded or crumbled. We left so angry. This place should be ashamed of themselves. I know that food can be subjective but this is objectively bad food. I see them respond to comments saying they theyre trying to actively improve but people have been writing that it’s bland for years so whatever.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Pizza was delicious as well as the cocktails. The restaurant has a cozy vibe and our waitress was super nice and attentive. We will definitely be back.
Music was great and upbeat bit very loud. No way to have any dinner conversation. Pizza was awesome.
We celebrated our son and fiancés engagement dinner here. What a fabulous time and the staff outdid themselves. I left a few times to set up as a surprise and it was all executed perfectly when we arrived! The restaurant was quiet and the food was delish!!!
Great atmosphere,,, Christmas festival in Huntington. Delicious apps and pizza. Service excellent
1653 Pizza isn’t your typical pizza spot — it offers a modern, creative take on pizza that makes it stand out in a great way. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the overall vibe feels fresh and inviting.
Parking can be tough, especially on busy days and weekends, so be prepared to circle around a bit, the top shelves could use some clean up But despite all that, the quality of the food and the experience make it worth the trip.
I’ll definitely be visiting again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The wife and I found this spot by accident and it was the best accident ever made! We sat at the bar to try their wood fired pizza and drinks... Let me tell you, as a pizza finatic, this outclasses most on Long Island(and I've tried most). They've even refined it more, nice crust, no flop, savory flavors. Frank is the man and his team is awesome. This place hit home so much we had our after wedding celebration here! Can't recommend this place enough. If your in town, please stop by, you won't regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Great and accommodating staff. Food and drinks are all very good. Vodka rigatoni is a must
We went with our family and had delicious pizza and pasta! The drink options are delicious too - even mocktails!
This place is consistently good. I would definitely recommend sticking to the pizza and apps though (the pasta dishes are a little on the smaller side). Cocktails and beer selection are above average, and it’s not so large that it turns into a complete zoo. There’s several good pizzerias in Huntington, but if you’re looking for a more elevated experience this is a great option.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went to the dead chefs society supper club event at this restaurant
Wow.
Mini preview of lasts night.
Dead Chef’s Tasting Menu at At 1654 Pizza Company – A Gold Coast Supper Club Experience
Last night on Long Island’s Gold Coast, I had the pleasure of experiencing something truly special: Dead Chef’s tasting menu at At 1654 Pizza Company in Huntington. What unfolded wasn’t just a dinner, but a full-on culinary performance that transformed the idea of a neighborhood pizza spot into a hidden gem supper club.
The evening unfolded course after course, each dish layered with creativity, bold flavors, and a touch of surprise. From refined takes on comfort food to plates that made you pause and savor every detail, it was clear that this wasn’t a typical night out—it was a carefully curated journey meant to linger in memory.
The atmosphere matched the menu: intimate, buzzing with energy, and elevated by a sense of discovery. Every dish felt like a conversation, and the storytelling behind the flavors was as captivating as the food itself.
Outstanding is the only word that fits—yet still feels like an understatement. This wasn’t just a meal; it was an experience that makes you excited for what’s next.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The soda cups were very tiny with 4 huge ice cubes in it. The pizza was almost 30 bucks and was only 6 small slices. And the food wasn’t even all that good. Don’t recommend. Was a rip off.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Loading...