1653 Pizza Company

80 Gerard St, Huntington
(631) 824-6071

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Tagliatelle Bolognese
Mozzarella Prosciutto
Eggplant Parmigiana
Octopus Panzanella
Shishito Peppers
Margherita Pizza
Bacon Jam Pizza
White Clam Pie
Pesto Lasagne
Garlic Bread

Salads
Pizzeria Salad Small
radicchio trevisano, endive, baby greens, shaved red onion, heirloom tomato, lemon mustard vinaigrette
Tuscan Caesar Small
tuscan kale, radicchio trevisano, baby romaine, sourdough croutons, classic caesar dressing, aged parmigiano
Pear Salad Small
green leaf lettuce, pear, candied walnut, dried cranberries, feta, apple cider vinaigrette

Plates
Eggplant Parmigiana
lightly fried eggplant, tomato sauce, aged parmigiano, basil, evoo
Suppli
roman style rice balls made 2 ways: traditional pork sugo / cacio e pepe. comes with 2 of each
Oven Charred Mediterranean Octopus
Mediterranean Spice Glaze, pea puree, crispy guanciale, fried potato, bravas aioli
Fried Calamari & Shrimp
potato, lemon, parsley aioli
Foccacia
Coal fired focaccia, extra virgin olive oil
Potato Croquette
filled with mortadella, served with maple aioli
Crispy Artichoke Hearts
served with an aioli of anchovy, citrus and mint.
Lamb Arrosticini
lamb skewers served with cumin yogurt and house made bread.
Pork Arrostocini
skewered, served with hoisin glaze and pickled cucumber
Coal Fired Chicken
free range young poulet, seasonal vegetables, brown mustard-pickled cherry pepper jus
Shell Steak
marinated 8oz skirt steak, chimichurri, parsnip puree

Pastas
Rigatoni Vodka
bronze die cut rigatoni, filetti tomato, straciatella, bomba chili
Pesto Lasagne
pistachio pesto, bechamel sauce, pecorino
Tagliatele Bolognese
classic sugo of milk braised beef, pork and veal, parmigiano, thyme
Tonarelli alla Vongole
tonarelli pasta, cockles, garlic, white wine, calabrian chili, gremolata
Kids Pasta Red Sauce
Kids Pasta Vodka
Tortelli
stuffed pasta with burrata and black truffle, tartufata, parmigiano, cream
Parsley Cavatelli

Pizzas
Margherita
tomato sauce, fresh fior di latte mozzarella, basil, italian evoo
Potato and Bacon
oven dried heirloom tomato, mozzarella, garlic, fresh basil, italian evoo
Roni
Sausage
tomato sauce, fresh fior di latte mozarella, crumbled local sausage, shaved red onion
Parma
tomato sauce, mozzarella, aged prosciutto, wild arugula, parmigiano
1653
tomato sauce, mozzarella, rosa grande pepperoni, jalapeno
The Gerard
White Pie
fresh mozzarella, pecorino, scamorza, garlic, finished with straciatella and cracked black pepper
Bacon Jam
White Clam Pie
pecorino, peconic little neck clams, parsley, lemon zest, pickled banana peppers, calabrian chili
Mortadella
mozzarella, pistachio pesto, mortadella, straciatella cheese, pistachio dust
Wild Mushroom
mozzarella, scamorza, brown shimeji mushrooms, tartufata, porcini dust
Bronx Bacon
Hot Honey Sausage
crumbled sausage, Calabrian chili, caramelized onion, Mike's Hot Honey

Dessert
Pisctacho Nutella Custard
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Nutella Pizza

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+63 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+62 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This establishment has to be one of the BEST pizza places I've ever been to! The quality of the food is top notch, the atmosphere is adorable, the service is AMAZING! I have a million food allergies, the waiters demonstrated such patience in dealing with me. They went back to the kitchen to ask about ingredients, they didn't indicate any frustration in dealing with all of my allergies. I've eaten there twice and both times were a wonderful experience! The food...
July 2025
cocktails where great, the pizza flavors where great as was the service the only disappointing thing was they had no Cabernet or Merlot wine which is odd for a friday night. they gave me some red wine that tasted terrible for $12 undrinkable
June 2025
Ordered to go today, got the octopus and a pizza. I dont know if they dont put the same effort for dine ins but the food was bottom of the barrel mediocre. Octopus was undercooked and at 6 dollars each small slice you could get the same quality off dominos. Pepperoni on the pizza was mid and nothing special. The octopus had barely any flavor and the sauce they included was so basic. Never going again
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

The Rust & Gold - 70 Gerard St
Bar, Sports Bar, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly
Panera Bread - 345 Main St
Cafe, Salad, Soup, Vegan
Ravagh Persian Grill - 335 Main St

1653 Pizza Company

80 Gerard St, Huntington, NY 11743
(631) 824-6071