Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar

Amazing food, drinks, and service. The hostess was so friendly and welcoming, which I feel is rather rare these days, so it was refreshing to see. Our server, the bartender, and bus staff went above and beyond to make sure we always had everything we needed and the tables were always clean. Also, this was by farrr the BEST affogato we ever had (we've had many). We will definitely return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great time great food!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great Food ..we really enjoyed ourselves .. a bit pricey 2 people no drinks had one Steak ,Fish and sushi.. veggies with tip $280.00

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fantastic and consistent quality of food and preparation they never disappoint. Interestingly this was the first time I had an issue with the server. He wasn't the most pleasant even when we joked around with him which eventually was fine maybe he was having a rough day but then he walked away after dropping off the dessert for my friend as we were celebrating her birthday. He could've at least stayed if he didn't want to sing with us.

👍👍👍👍👍

As always - Prime is an amazing place to enjoy a meal with friends in a picturesque and elegant venue. Thank you!

Prime usually never dissappoints,the steak came out funky in a buttery sauce looking like oil,we were never checked on,never got soda till before the meal.The place wasnt packed but was constantly waiting even for check and the take home food.

Great location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Safe haven for quality food and service on Long Island. Views are amazing if you can get a table outside overlooking the inlet with boats on a fine sunny day. Menu is not very expansive, it’s mainly seafood with few steak staples. Service was very good, our server Sean was knowledgeable and friendly. Ambiance- Interior decor is lovely, stylish and modern.
Food- popovers, sushi and steaks are great. We tried their Veal chop & seasonal specials both were delicious.
My two feedbacks for improvement are :
-they made some changes to their Wellington & it’s lately it tastes a bit under seasoned, doesn’t have the same strong umami flavors that it used to
-Outdoor chairs are plasticy and uncomfortable, would be nice if they had cute outside seating

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Sean was amazing server who helped us navigate the specials as well as their regular menu. He was attentive with our orders and worked diligently to ensure we had a fantastic celebratory dinner. The food was phenomenal as always. These are the reasons we continue coming back to Prime and will definitely return

Staff was very accommodating and polite. Food came out just how we ordered.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time at prime for my anniversary. We ordered the shrimp cocktail, sesame potato roll, beef Wellington and fillet mignon frites. I’ll rate the best to worst dish. sesame potato roll was actually delicious, beef Wellington was also pretty good. Shrimp cocktail was okay, overpriced for what you get. Filet mignon frites was virtually inedible, its pepper crusted mignon tails, but all you could taste is overwhelming ammount of pepper. Overall left a bit dissapointed for what I paid.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

The food is incredible! This is probably the best sushi I've ever had and the wagyu steak tartare melted in my mouth. They were also extremely accommodating in altering dishes since I'm gluten free; from leaving sauces off the sushi to replacing the toast that comes with the tartare with potato chips, it was so easy to meet my dietary requirements. Also, if the tater tots with caviar is still on the menu, DO NOT MISS!

The food, ambience, and service was perfect! Although pricey in my opinion worth the cost as everyone went above and beyond to make it a special experience.

Clean, cozy, and quick service. The food hit the spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5