Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall
215 N Cayuga St, Ithaca
(607) 227-3987
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
Salted Caramel Ice Cream
Strawberry Cheesecake
Coconut Almond Fudge
Cookies & Cream
Cherry Jubilee
Gelato
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This place is a branch of the creamery a little bit further up the road on the west side of the lake. It's open much later, which is great! It's a little awkward walking through the mall after the mall itself is closed to get there, but the ice cream was worth it. The shop itself and seating is also really cute.
Unassuming location unreal ice cream.
The GPS really surprised me as it said we had arrived and I just saw what looked like a rundown apartment complex. But inside shines. Our first time here, pistachio & lavender. It was pricy $18 for 2 cones but really tasty!
And everyone else thinks so too! Full house.
The GPS really surprised me as it said we had arrived and I just saw what looked like a rundown apartment complex. But inside shines. Our first time here, pistachio & lavender. It was pricy $18 for 2 cones but really tasty!
And everyone else thinks so too! Full house.
They rarely have the brownie one which is what I like. The other flavors are good, but if you need chocolatey icecream you may be uninterested in the flavors they put out most of the time. Theres options for toppings including chocolate syrup and they do sell a literal brownie I think, but the brownie icecream just hits different. I always get the chocolate and nut cone with one scoop and the one scoop is more than you think cause they add a little more on top to smooth it out....
You May Also Like
Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop - 200 W Seneca St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Shortstop Deli - 200 W Seneca St
![]()
Deli, American, Fast Food, Vegan
Kimchi - 124 E State St
![]()
Korean, Pet Friendly