Black Sheep Bagels

$ • Coffee Shops, Pretzels

Hours:
1451 Main Rd, Jamesport
(631) 779-2914

Customers' Favorites

Black Sheep Bagels Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.2 (53)
Restaurantji Rating

I love this place! Everything I’ve tried has been delicious and fresh. Staff are super-cool! Can’t go wrong. I order a dozen bagels every week! Try the onion bagel! Toasted with cream cheese, tomatoes, red onion. Yummy! I’m picking up my dozen today!

Restaurantji Rating

Ok friendly staff, and the food is not top notch. You're going to find a better deli... but i got a voucher from motel next door and visited, you're just ok with taste and texture. Get everything and good cream on it.... you won't regret it!

Restaurantji Rating

This place is hands down the best on the North Fork! As someone who lived here my whole life -I have never had such a good breakfast sandwich. Everything is done right! Service was top tier- my order had adjustments and they were done to perfect ! Eggs cooked perfect. Crispy hash brown. Cheesy! And it was huge!! (The hungry man on egg everything)Also the price for 2 was justified for the amount of food coming in around 25 after tax for both. No sides or drinks. Good price for...read full review

More Reviews(104)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 6:30AM - 3PM
Tuesday 6:30AM - 3PM
Wednesday 6:30AM - 3PM
Thursday 6:30AM - 3PM
Friday 6:30AM - 3PM
Saturday 6:30AM - 3PM
Sunday 6:30AM - 3PM
Updated on: