This past weekend I had my daughters wedding and had Black Sheep cater the “getting ready” food for the guys and the girls Airbnb. There was not only an abundance of food but it was delicious! (Especially the stuffed cream cheese bagels). Chris was so easy to deal with and they were highly recommended by Natalie from RGNY! (So you know it is good) I truly highly recommend them. I don’t live out east but when I come out this way I am stopping in. Worth the drive!!!
B M
Expensive but good
Tatiana Sokolova
I am so happy my host recommended Chris. I was filming a movie in Mattituck and Chris provided lunch for my cast and crew every day (8 days). The food is healthy and delicious. He also accommodated my vegetarians. Thank you!
Evan Thorne
Delicious bagels especially the specialty ones! Favorite is cheddar jalapeño bacon with cream cheese. So good.
Rafael Nn
Bagels are good, cream is nasty, smells bad.....
Richard “Richpaddler” Stevens
Dynamic staff and owner. Great selection of bagels , wraps and so much more. They always make you feel welcome. I always leave with a smile on my face.
Natalie Mamrol
I love this place more. I’ll never eat another bagel outside of Long Island again. We got crumb cake, Cinnabons, jalapeño bagel, and coffee!!!!!
Gabrielle G-C
I love this place
Jillian Staebler
THE BEST always always always - consistently delicious - amazing customer service - delicious food, well-prepared
Joshua Holten
Food was amazing, beyond amazing actually! Prices are high only due to Bird flu so it’s hard not to be upset over that but other than that it’s a great deli!
Black Sheep Bagels makes some of the BEST bagels around! I would recommend Black Sheep Bagels to any guest or resident of Southold.
Kariane Chew
Last minute call for 2 dozen bagels to feed some hangry plow drivers/shovelers this morning-they had them ready and waiting within 10 minutes. ALWAYS a smile when you walk in, and literally the best bagels on the North Fork!!
Chris Ainsworth
Having lived in NY prior, we always look for new bagel places each visit. Black Sheep is the best - we all agreed. And the bagels are huge with overly generous cream cheese. A must stop if you are out on the North Fork!!
Thomas P
Best bagels on the North Fork. This is our go to spot whether we have guests in town or are looking for a few bagels for the house. They’re always soft and fresh and are still good the next day. The service is friendly and fast and I’m never waiting more than five or ten minutes no matter busy it is.
Mike R
My opinion, the “perfect” bagel period. We’ll be back.
This past weekend I had my daughters wedding and had Black Sheep cater the “getting ready” food for the guys and the girls Airbnb. There was not only an abundance of food but it was delicious! (Especially the stuffed cream cheese bagels). Chris was so easy to deal with and they were highly recommended by Natalie from RGNY! (So you know it is good) I truly highly recommend them. I don’t live out east but when I come out this way I am stopping in. Worth the drive!!!
Expensive but good
I am so happy my host recommended Chris. I was filming a movie in Mattituck and Chris provided lunch for my cast and crew every day (8 days). The food is healthy and delicious. He also accommodated my vegetarians. Thank you!
Delicious bagels especially the specialty ones! Favorite is cheddar jalapeño bacon with cream cheese. So good.
Bagels are good, cream is nasty, smells bad.....
Dynamic staff and owner. Great selection of bagels , wraps and so much more. They always make you feel welcome. I always leave with a smile on my face.
I love this place more. I’ll never eat another bagel outside of Long Island again. We got crumb cake, Cinnabons, jalapeño bagel, and coffee!!!!!
I love this place
THE BEST always always always
- consistently delicious
- amazing customer service
- delicious food, well-prepared
Food was amazing, beyond amazing actually! Prices are high only due to Bird flu so it’s hard not to be upset over that but other than that it’s a great deli!
Restaurantji Recommends
Black Sheep Bagels makes some of the BEST bagels around! I would recommend Black Sheep Bagels to any guest or resident of Southold.
Last minute call for 2 dozen bagels to feed some hangry plow drivers/shovelers this morning-they had them ready and waiting within 10 minutes. ALWAYS a smile when you walk in, and literally the best bagels on the North Fork!!
Having lived in NY prior, we always look for new bagel places each visit. Black Sheep is the best - we all agreed. And the bagels are huge with overly generous cream cheese. A must stop if you are out on the North Fork!!
Best bagels on the North Fork. This is our go to spot whether we have guests in town or are looking for a few bagels for the house. They’re always soft and fresh and are still good the next day. The service is friendly and fast and I’m never waiting more than five or ten minutes no matter busy it is.
My opinion, the “perfect” bagel period.
We’ll be back.
Loading...