My girlfriend and I dined at muscoot tavern for the first time on Wednesday evening. The entire experience was above average and wonderful. Not only was the quality of the food excellent, the service provided by staff was stellar and outstanding. Very friendly, polite, and gave us plenty of time to choose and decide on our meals. Not once did the servers make us feel rushed to place our orders. The glasses of water never went empty. And the hospitality lasted even longer. Great selection on the menu. A little of everything. Environment was cozy and not loud at all. We were impressed and will be dining at muscoot tavern more often. Thank you to the owner and entire staff for making our experience special. Vincent C.
Ginny
Most entrees pleased our group. I was skeptical of my “sushi grade” tuna as it was tough. The old farm building with crooked walls and floors has a cool character, but the place needs operational, adequate air conditioning. If we weren’t with guests, I would have left. The lack of AC plus a bothersome fly and the tough tuna don’t invite a return from me.
Peter Nekos
This place is great to go to! The prices are very good and the food is even better. I’d highly recommend going here for to eat.
The tavern atmosphere and the paintings on the wall add to the experience of the place.
My favorites are always the pasta with muscles because they really loaded up on muscles. I also really like the penne vodka!
Definitely go here if you have the chance
Anna Vasilevsky
place so dirty, food not grate, nothing like what it was before.
anna
Menu on website not exiting
Nick Grisanti
Historic place about 100 years old. Great burger!
Cespanotic
Obviously the place is kinda old..but the food and drinks are money!
Joe Mercado
I went to this quaint, restaurant with my friends and my wife. The food was great. The service was also good and the atmosphere was also good. Going to this restaurant was like going into the past.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smokehouse Burger
Donia Elgamal
We like coming here. Nice local little place. The food is delicious and the service is good. I especially love the smokehouse burger and the French onion soup.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Montauk Fish Soup, Smokehouse Burger
Larry Krauss
Really good food, prices, and atmosphere at this venerable Northern Westchester establishment.
We're locals and have been enjoying Muscoot for many years. The pizza could be the best in Northern Westchester. The Italians dishes are reliable family style and the burgers are pretty solid. All in all I'm so glad this classic haunt has withstood the test of time. Pro tip, combine a walk the Muscoot Farm and a hike on their trails before dining at the tavern. The classic combo!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ahhsha Crooks
Average establishment, but very friendly staff. I ordered 2 pizzas, wings, and dumplings. We spoke about the sauces for the dumplings for a while so Im surprised I still never received them. He even confirmed with me that I wanted both appetizers and I said yes. I don’t like having to repeat myself, especially when we confirmed twice. Food is good, I’d only comeback if I can get everything I ask for next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Bob Considine
How many times can you visit a tavern (in the US) that is 100 years old? (If you're over 6', mind your head entering.) This building hasn't changed much. Inside, you will get what you expect from an old farm building.
Quite a diverse crowd inside, friendly, and attentive staff. Food is what you would expect from tavern.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Bobby Clarke
Glad we stopped in,, quick service and a great meal,, we will stop back in a few weeks to try different foods
My girlfriend and I dined at muscoot tavern for the first time on Wednesday evening. The entire experience was above average and wonderful. Not only was the quality of the food excellent, the service provided by staff was stellar and outstanding. Very friendly, polite, and gave us plenty of time to choose and decide on our meals. Not once did the servers make us feel rushed to place our orders. The glasses of water never went empty. And the hospitality lasted even longer. Great selection on the menu. A little of everything. Environment was cozy and not loud at all. We were impressed and will be dining at muscoot tavern more often. Thank you to the owner and entire staff for making our experience special.
Vincent C.
Most entrees pleased our group. I was skeptical of my “sushi grade” tuna as it was tough. The old farm building with crooked walls and floors has a cool character, but the place needs operational, adequate air conditioning. If we weren’t with guests, I would have left. The lack of AC plus a bothersome fly and the tough tuna don’t invite a return from me.
This place is great to go to! The prices are very good and the food is even better. I’d highly recommend going here for to eat.
The tavern atmosphere and the paintings on the wall add to the experience of the place.
My favorites are always the pasta with muscles because they really loaded up on muscles. I also really like the penne vodka!
Definitely go here if you have the chance
place so dirty, food not grate, nothing like what it was before.
Menu on website not exiting
Historic place about 100 years old. Great burger!
Obviously the place is kinda old..but the food and drinks are money!
I went to this quaint, restaurant with my friends and my wife. The food was great. The service was also good and the atmosphere was also good. Going to this restaurant was like going into the past.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smokehouse Burger
We like coming here. Nice local little place. The food is delicious and the service is good. I especially love the smokehouse burger and the French onion soup.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Montauk Fish Soup, Smokehouse Burger
Really good food, prices, and atmosphere at this venerable Northern Westchester establishment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smokehouse Burger
Restaurantji Recommends
We're locals and have been enjoying Muscoot for many years. The pizza could be the best in Northern Westchester. The Italians dishes are reliable family style and the burgers are pretty solid. All in all I'm so glad this classic haunt has withstood the test of time. Pro tip, combine a walk the Muscoot Farm and a hike on their trails before dining at the tavern. The classic combo!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Average establishment, but very friendly staff. I ordered 2 pizzas, wings, and dumplings. We spoke about the sauces for the dumplings for a while so Im surprised I still never received them. He even confirmed with me that I wanted both appetizers and I said yes. I don’t like having to repeat myself, especially when we confirmed twice. Food is good, I’d only comeback if I can get everything I ask for next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
How many times can you visit a tavern (in the US) that is 100 years old? (If you're over 6', mind your head entering.) This building hasn't changed much. Inside, you will get what you expect from an old farm building.
Quite a diverse crowd inside, friendly, and attentive staff. Food is what you would expect from tavern.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Glad we stopped in,, quick service and a great meal,, we will stop back in a few weeks to try different foods
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Caprice, Smokehouse Burger
Amazing service! Pizza is fantastic and they always have a great specials menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...