So let me start by I don't eat a lot of subs. When I first went here they were $6, over time the price gradually increased now 1/2 subs are $7.50 (I don't eat meat, for me that's pricey)... but anyway, I watched this young gentleman making a sub and thinking I can't wait for mine...but the other gentleman that made my sub, had an odd technique one I didn't like. he built it in layers, bread, lettuce, cheese then folded it in half.. it felt like I was eating a cheese log, the bite of food was uneven!.. I know it sounds funny, but it just wasn't normal,.. maybe next time?
Scott Schatzel
Took the family there for subs while in Kingston. The staff were friendly, very efficient and quick. My sub had been a call in, so was ready when we arrived, but then we added 3 more to the bill; a foot long and 2 halves. These subs were made fast, so we were in and out quick. I had the "Brooklyn Club" and I have to say when that was handed off to me I was immediately surprised by the weight of it. It felt good and heavy in my hand. When I opened the wrapping there was what I would consider a very generous amount of turkey and bacon. They also went easy on the lettuce/tomato which other places will stuff a sub full of to fill it out. My sub was delicious. Our kids also commented about their smaller subs with more than a few "this is great" being heard from the backseat on the way home. They also sell Boylans sodas, among other beverages.Simply put, the food was good, made fast and the price was fair.We're going back.
Phil Lyons
Paulie Boys has always been on point, but not tonight. Called in my order at 4 pm and they were "sold out" of bacon. Pretty key ingredient for some of their signature subs. But anyways. I get there and a new guy is out front of the store on his phone instead of at Hannaford getting bacon. I bring 2 subs home and both are made wrong. Brooklyn club with onions, without onions (and bacon) and a cappicola sub with mayo on it. Didn't ask for mayo. Don't know why they put mayo on. Definitely going to think twice next time we're in the mood for subs.
Dawn Marie
Rude staff! I watched a man check out. He had a $100 bill. They said they didn't have change and that he had to go next door to get change. He asked them if they could break a $50 and they said probably not. He asked if they take credit and they said no. As he was leaving the lady who cashed him out yelled "tips are appreciated"This is not the first time I seen them being rude about tipping. Will not be going back.
Brian Carlozzi
The sandwiches are pretty good, and I'd go there more often if they had any decent sides, they just have tiny bags of chips and potato/macaroni salad or coleslaw. And they are SLOW.
Sedequa R
Lovely place! They cut the meat to a good thickness and put the proper amount of veggies on each sub. My favorite part, the fresh bread!Cookies and many beverage options... definitely will return. Thank you for the food!Vegetarian options: House special veggie sub!
Paul G.
I've been meaning to stop by and try one of their subs. I finally did. I ordered the Kingston Beef. Absolutely to die for. So juicy and delicious, and served on a perfectly soft roll. And they don't skimp on ingredients either. My sub was loaded with roast beef. I definitely will be stopping by again very soon to try some of their other subs. I hope this place sticks around for a long time. Kingston has been in dire need of a good sandwich shop for a long time.
Thomas S.
not for nothing a great Italian mix sub no b******** absolutely worth a shot! my next treat night ham Swiss boarshead of course!
Jeremy E.
Great sandwich shop does all the classics really well. I've had the Italian one and a hot beef one. Both delicious. Cash only but there's an ATM.
Joan Horton
This is a refreshingly old fashioned sandwich stop, with good quality deli meats and a nice friendly down-to-earth staff
The best! Great portions bacon is crispy not fat and chewy so clean and very friendly!
Brendon Hood
Sandwiches are very good & made with boars head meats & cheeses , mac & potato salads are also very good.Parking: Plenty of parking in the kingston plaza parking lot.
Jim Gooch
Got a whole Kingston beef hero to-go and it was huge, and messy, just the way it should be. The Meat was tender the sauce was good and the bread was soft. I normally finish anything you put in front of me, but I only ate half and took the rest home. The person making the order was friendly and efficient. She kept up conversation as she made the sandwich and I was in and out pretty quickly. I hope if I'm ever back in town I'll be revisiting this place again.
Tyler B
Incredible heroes at this shop. Got the Kingston Beef, which was loaded with a generous amount of roast beef. The tiger sauce was my favorite part - they do not skimp on the horseradish which made this a 10/10
Michelle Combs
No restroom, cash only, out of one of the toppings on their special, took forever and no greeting or direction when we came in. Other than that, the sandwiches were fine.
So let me start by I don't eat a lot of subs. When I first went here they were $6, over time the price gradually increased now 1/2 subs are $7.50 (I don't eat meat, for me that's pricey)... but anyway, I watched this young gentleman making a sub and thinking I can't wait for mine...but the other gentleman that made my sub, had an odd technique one I didn't like. he built it in layers, bread, lettuce, cheese then folded it in half.. it felt like I was eating a cheese log, the bite of food was uneven!.. I know it sounds funny, but it just wasn't normal,.. maybe next time?
Took the family there for subs while in Kingston. The staff were friendly, very efficient and quick. My sub had been a call in, so was ready when we arrived, but then we added 3 more to the bill; a foot long and 2 halves. These subs were made fast, so we were in and out quick. I had the "Brooklyn Club" and I have to say when that was handed off to me I was immediately surprised by the weight of it. It felt good and heavy in my hand. When I opened the wrapping there was what I would consider a very generous amount of turkey and bacon. They also went easy on the lettuce/tomato which other places will stuff a sub full of to fill it out. My sub was delicious. Our kids also commented about their smaller subs with more than a few "this is great" being heard from the backseat on the way home. They also sell Boylans sodas, among other beverages.Simply put, the food was good, made fast and the price was fair.We're going back.
Paulie Boys has always been on point, but not tonight. Called in my order at 4 pm and they were "sold out" of bacon. Pretty key ingredient for some of their signature subs. But anyways. I get there and a new guy is out front of the store on his phone instead of at Hannaford getting bacon. I bring 2 subs home and both are made wrong. Brooklyn club with onions, without onions (and bacon) and a cappicola sub with mayo on it. Didn't ask for mayo. Don't know why they put mayo on. Definitely going to think twice next time we're in the mood for subs.
Rude staff! I watched a man check out. He had a $100 bill. They said they didn't have change and that he had to go next door to get change. He asked them if they could break a $50 and they said probably not. He asked if they take credit and they said no. As he was leaving the lady who cashed him out yelled "tips are appreciated"This is not the first time I seen them being rude about tipping. Will not be going back.
The sandwiches are pretty good, and I'd go there more often if they had any decent sides, they just have tiny bags of chips and potato/macaroni salad or coleslaw. And they are SLOW.
Lovely place! They cut the meat to a good thickness and put the proper amount of veggies on each sub. My favorite part, the fresh bread!Cookies and many beverage options... definitely will return. Thank you for the food!Vegetarian options: House special veggie sub!
I've been meaning to stop by and try one of their subs. I finally did. I ordered the Kingston Beef. Absolutely to die for. So juicy and delicious, and served on a perfectly soft roll. And they don't skimp on ingredients either. My sub was loaded with roast beef. I definitely will be stopping by again very soon to try some of their other subs. I hope this place sticks around for a long time. Kingston has been in dire need of a good sandwich shop for a long time.
not for nothing a great Italian mix sub no b******** absolutely worth a shot! my next treat night ham Swiss boarshead of course!
Great sandwich shop does all the classics really well. I've had the Italian one and a hot beef one. Both delicious. Cash only but there's an ATM.
This is a refreshingly old fashioned sandwich stop, with good quality deli meats and a nice friendly down-to-earth staff
Restaurantji Recommends
The best! Great portions bacon is crispy not fat and chewy so clean and very friendly!
Sandwiches are very good & made with boars head meats & cheeses , mac & potato salads are also very good.Parking: Plenty of parking in the kingston plaza parking lot.
Got a whole Kingston beef hero to-go and it was huge, and messy, just the way it should be. The Meat was tender the sauce was good and the bread was soft. I normally finish anything you put in front of me, but I only ate half and took the rest home. The person making the order was friendly and efficient. She kept up conversation as she made the sandwich and I was in and out pretty quickly. I hope if I'm ever back in town I'll be revisiting this place again.
Incredible heroes at this shop. Got the Kingston Beef, which was loaded with a generous amount of roast beef. The tiger sauce was my favorite part - they do not skimp on the horseradish which made this a 10/10
No restroom, cash only, out of one of the toppings on their special, took forever and no greeting or direction when we came in. Other than that, the sandwiches were fine.