The Pizzeria of Lake Grove
342 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove
(631) 652-9987
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Pizza Slice with Cup and Char Crispy Pepperoni
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Upside Down Caputo Slice
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
Upside Down Caputo Pie
Vodka Margherita Slice
Margherita Pizza Slice
The Honey Pep Slice
Sweet Chilli Chicken
Pies
Regular Pie
Traditional New York Style Pie
The Uncle Benny Pie
Olive Oil Crust | Pizza Sauce | Fresh Mozzarella | Crumbled Sausage | Pepperoni | Hot Honey | Fresh Basil
Pepperoni Pie
Regular Pie with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Upside Down Caputo Pie
Our updated upside down pie featuring fresh mozzarella under seasoned marinara sauce and olive oil drizzle
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
Grandma Crust | Marinated Chicken in Sweet Thai Chili Sauce | Mozzarella Cheese | Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Grandma Pie
Sicilian Pie
Tri-Fecta Pie
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese | Vodka Sauce | Red Sauce | Pesto | Olive Oil Crust
Vodka Margherita Pie
Olive Oil Curst w/Fresh Mozzarella & Vodka Sauce
The Honey Pep Pie
Sicilian with Pepperoni, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle and Basil
Crumbling Vodka Pie
Fresh Mozzarella | Vodka Sauce | Crumbled Spicy Sausage | Grandma Crust
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Marinated Buffalo Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Buffalo Sauce
Margherita Pie
Our Sweet Red Sauce on Olive Oil Curst with Fresh Mozzarella
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Breaded Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and Ranch Dressing
BBQ Chicken Pie
Slices
Regular Slice
Traditional New York Style Slice
Vodka Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella, Homemade Vodka Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Thai Chili Chicken Slice
Square Crust Topped with Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Sicilian Slice
Traditional NY Style Sicilian Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Drizzle of our Homemade Buffalo Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Pronounced: "C.B.R." Breaded Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese and Ranch Dressing
Crumbling Vodka Slice
Grandma Style Crust with Crumbled Sausage, Vodka Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese
Grandma Slice
Square Crust with Mozzarella, Freshly Made Marinara Sauce and Seasoning
The Honey Pep Slice
Sicilian Pie Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni, Fresh Basil and Drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey
Pepperoni Slice
Traditional NY Style Slice Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Uncle Benny Slice
Our olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella, crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, Mike's hot honey and basil.
Tri-Fecta Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Pesto Sauce, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce
Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Our Red Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Upside Down Caputo Slice
Our Newly Elevated Upside Down Slice. Sicilian Crust Topped with Mozzarella Cheese Under our Homemade Marinara Sauce
BBQ Chicken Slice
Breaded Chicken with Cheddar and Mozzarella Cheese Blend Drizzled with BBQ Sauce
Specialties
Buffalo Knots
Beverages
20oz Coke
Apple Juice
20oz Diet Coke
20oz Dr. Pepper
Lemonade
20oz Sprite
Bottle Water
Smart Water
Pies
Regular Pie
Traditional New York Style Pie
The Uncle Benny Pie
Olive Oil Crust | Pizza Sauce | Fresh Mozzarella | Crumbled Sausage | Pepperoni | Hot Honey | Fresh Basil
Pepperoni Pie
Regular Pie with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Upside Down Caputo Pie
Our updated upside down pie featuring fresh mozzarella under seasoned marinara sauce and olive oil drizzle
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
Grandma Crust | Marinated Chicken in Sweet Thai Chili Sauce | Mozzarella Cheese | Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Grandma Pie
Sicilian Pie
Tri-Fecta Pie
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese | Vodka Sauce | Red Sauce | Pesto | Olive Oil Crust
Vodka Margherita Pie
Olive Oil Curst w/Fresh Mozzarella & Vodka Sauce
The Honey Pep Pie
Sicilian with Pepperoni, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle and Basil
Crumbling Vodka Pie
Fresh Mozzarella | Vodka Sauce | Crumbled Spicy Sausage | Grandma Crust
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Marinated Buffalo Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Buffalo Sauce
Margherita Pie
Our Sweet Red Sauce on Olive Oil Curst with Fresh Mozzarella
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Breaded Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and Ranch Dressing
BBQ Chicken Pie
Slices
Regular Slice
Traditional New York Style Slice
Vodka Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella, Homemade Vodka Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Thai Chili Chicken Slice
Square Crust Topped with Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Sicilian Slice
Traditional NY Style Sicilian Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Drizzle of our Homemade Buffalo Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Pronounced: "C.B.R." Breaded Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese and Ranch Dressing
Crumbling Vodka Slice
Grandma Style Crust with Crumbled Sausage, Vodka Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese
Grandma Slice
Square Crust with Mozzarella, Freshly Made Marinara Sauce and Seasoning
The Honey Pep Slice
Sicilian Pie Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni, Fresh Basil and Drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey
Pepperoni Slice
Traditional NY Style Slice Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Uncle Benny Slice
Our olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella, crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, Mike's hot honey and basil.
Tri-Fecta Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Pesto Sauce, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce
Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Our Red Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Upside Down Caputo Slice
Our Newly Elevated Upside Down Slice. Sicilian Crust Topped with Mozzarella Cheese Under our Homemade Marinara Sauce
BBQ Chicken Slice
Breaded Chicken with Cheddar and Mozzarella Cheese Blend Drizzled with BBQ Sauce
Specialties
Buffalo Knots
Beverages
20oz Coke
Apple Juice
20oz Diet Coke
20oz Dr. Pepper
Lemonade
20oz Sprite
Bottle Water
Smart Water
Pies
Regular Pie
Traditional New York Style Pie
The Uncle Benny Pie
Olive Oil Crust | Pizza Sauce | Fresh Mozzarella | Crumbled Sausage | Pepperoni | Hot Honey | Fresh Basil
Pepperoni Pie
Regular Pie with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Upside Down Caputo Pie
Our updated upside down pie featuring fresh mozzarella under seasoned marinara sauce and olive oil drizzle
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
Grandma Crust | Marinated Chicken in Sweet Thai Chili Sauce | Mozzarella Cheese | Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Grandma Pie
Sicilian Pie
Tri-Fecta Pie
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese | Vodka Sauce | Red Sauce | Pesto | Olive Oil Crust
Vodka Margherita Pie
Olive Oil Curst w/Fresh Mozzarella & Vodka Sauce
The Honey Pep Pie
Sicilian with Pepperoni, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle and Basil
Crumbling Vodka Pie
Fresh Mozzarella | Vodka Sauce | Crumbled Spicy Sausage | Grandma Crust
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Marinated Buffalo Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Buffalo Sauce
Margherita Pie
Our Sweet Red Sauce on Olive Oil Curst with Fresh Mozzarella
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Breaded Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and Ranch Dressing
BBQ Chicken Pie
Slices
Regular Slice
Traditional New York Style Slice
Vodka Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella, Homemade Vodka Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Thai Chili Chicken Slice
Square Crust Topped with Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Sicilian Slice
Traditional NY Style Sicilian Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Drizzle of our Homemade Buffalo Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Pronounced: "C.B.R." Breaded Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese and Ranch Dressing
Crumbling Vodka Slice
Grandma Style Crust with Crumbled Sausage, Vodka Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese
Grandma Slice
Square Crust with Mozzarella, Freshly Made Marinara Sauce and Seasoning
The Honey Pep Slice
Sicilian Pie Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni, Fresh Basil and Drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey
Pepperoni Slice
Traditional NY Style Slice Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Uncle Benny Slice
Our olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella, crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, Mike's hot honey and basil.
Tri-Fecta Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Pesto Sauce, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce
Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Our Red Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Upside Down Caputo Slice
Our Newly Elevated Upside Down Slice. Sicilian Crust Topped with Mozzarella Cheese Under our Homemade Marinara Sauce
BBQ Chicken Slice
Breaded Chicken with Cheddar and Mozzarella Cheese Blend Drizzled with BBQ Sauce
Specialties
Buffalo Knots
Beverages
20oz Coke
Apple Juice
20oz Diet Coke
20oz Dr. Pepper
Lemonade
20oz Sprite
Bottle Water
Smart Water
Pies
Regular Pie
Traditional New York Style Pie
The Uncle Benny Pie
Olive Oil Crust | Pizza Sauce | Fresh Mozzarella | Crumbled Sausage | Pepperoni | Hot Honey | Fresh Basil
Pepperoni Pie
Regular Pie with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Upside Down Caputo Pie
Our updated upside down pie featuring fresh mozzarella under seasoned marinara sauce and olive oil drizzle
Thai Chili Chicken Pie
Grandma Crust | Marinated Chicken in Sweet Thai Chili Sauce | Mozzarella Cheese | Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Grandma Pie
Sicilian Pie
Tri-Fecta Pie
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese | Vodka Sauce | Red Sauce | Pesto | Olive Oil Crust
Vodka Margherita Pie
Olive Oil Curst w/Fresh Mozzarella & Vodka Sauce
The Honey Pep Pie
Sicilian with Pepperoni, Mike's Hot Honey Drizzle and Basil
Crumbling Vodka Pie
Fresh Mozzarella | Vodka Sauce | Crumbled Spicy Sausage | Grandma Crust
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Marinated Buffalo Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Buffalo Sauce
Margherita Pie
Our Sweet Red Sauce on Olive Oil Curst with Fresh Mozzarella
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Breaded Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and Ranch Dressing
BBQ Chicken Pie
Slices
Regular Slice
Traditional New York Style Slice
Vodka Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella, Homemade Vodka Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Thai Chili Chicken Slice
Square Crust Topped with Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Topped with Thai Chili Sauce
Sicilian Slice
Traditional NY Style Sicilian Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Marinated Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese and Drizzle of our Homemade Buffalo Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Pronounced: "C.B.R." Breaded Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese and Ranch Dressing
Crumbling Vodka Slice
Grandma Style Crust with Crumbled Sausage, Vodka Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese
Grandma Slice
Square Crust with Mozzarella, Freshly Made Marinara Sauce and Seasoning
The Honey Pep Slice
Sicilian Pie Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni, Fresh Basil and Drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey
Pepperoni Slice
Traditional NY Style Slice Topped with Cup and Char Pepperoni
Uncle Benny Slice
Our olive oil crust with fresh mozzarella, crumbled sausage, cup and char pepperoni, Mike's hot honey and basil.
Tri-Fecta Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Pesto Sauce, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce
Margherita Slice
Olive Oil Crust Topped with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Our Red Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
Upside Down Caputo Slice
Our Newly Elevated Upside Down Slice. Sicilian Crust Topped with Mozzarella Cheese Under our Homemade Marinara Sauce
BBQ Chicken Slice
Breaded Chicken with Cheddar and Mozzarella Cheese Blend Drizzled with BBQ Sauce
Specialties
Buffalo Knots
Beverages
20oz Coke
Apple Juice
20oz Diet Coke
20oz Dr. Pepper
Lemonade
20oz Sprite
Bottle Water
Smart Water
Photos
+47 photos
+46 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Got some slices for lunch and I must say it's better than what I was expecting. For a pizzeria in a shopping mall food court, it's on par with some pizzas I've had from established standalone pizzerias. Garlic knots were okay but the slices were really good. I would recommend grabbing a slice if you're in the mall.
June 2024
Have been to the Bayport location many times and always 5 stars. Stopped in at the mall and was surprised to see these guys up here. Food and staff 5 stars here as well. They don’t miss!
February 2024
You May Also Like
Los Amigos Tacos - 313 Burr Ln
![]()
Mexican, Fast Food, Tacos
Yume Ramen and Cake - 350-4 Smith Haven Mall
![]()
Ramen, Vegan
Kong Dog - 334 Smith Haven Mall
![]()
Fast Food, Food Court, Hot Dogs
My family and I recently traveled out to The Smith Haven Mall from Nassau to have my son’s birthday at Game On. We ordered a package deal from The Pizzeria and I am so glad we did. The food was amazing! It way exceeded my expectations for mall pizza.
What really stood out to me though was the exceptional service we received. I forgot to bring something to cut...