Great find in our travels. Wonderful service and food. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Rosso Pizza
Kjersti
Not worth the price. Overpriced. Ordered drinks when we sat down and never received them. Finished eating and had to cancel the drinks bc apparently they were never coming. Had to ask for the bill three times. We were one of three tables at the time...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Seamus O'C
Great place, great atmosphere. Came with my uncle, a long time local, and really enjoyed the stone oven pizza. Very tavernesque, cozy style upstairs that's extremely aesthetic and inviting. Great food, better staff. Would 10/10 recommend if you're ever in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon A.
Had a great meal and friendly helpful service! Ambiance was warm and casual. Looking forward to a return visit.
youngg1201
Last day before we left Livingston Manor, my family and I were hungry so we looked up a few places and end up finding this spot. While seated, I overheard OUR server (out of everyone) say how she “hates people who come from NYC and wish they would just stay there” mind you she has us seated literally right next to the bar where she saying that. I couldn’t believe my ears. We were nothing but friendly, just looking for some pizza. The vibes were SO off in this place my wife was in a rush to leave. Food was okay. Love Livingston Manor, not this place. Those “people from NYC” that come to your beautiful town are supporting your local business.
Paolo Gaibani
We had dinner at this restaurant and ordered pizza and baked trout. Long waiting times. The pizza was acceptable while the trout was not very tasty and the vegetables were unseasoned. Good dessert but small portions. Not
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Robert Cardoni
Delicious pizza - the Margherita is amazing.Make a reservation in the winter. Indoor seating is
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Brook Trout Rillettes, The Manor Pizza
Eanca Canameti
As seasoned reviewers, my boyfriend and I recommend this Catskills pizza spot, giving it a commendable 8.2. The atmosphere, both indoors and outdoors, was superb. The staff was friendly, enhancing the overall experience. Our culinary journey included a wood-fired roasted trout appetizer, which, unfortunately, scored a 5 due to its mushiness and an incompatible onion-rice mix. As a non-garlic eater, the pesto was overwhelmingly garlicky. The Waterfowl folly Rueben sauerkraut pizza earned an 8 for its well-structured dough, while the Hawaii Five-Oh disappointed with an excessive amount of cheese and pineapple, resulting in a rating of 3. The drinks, particularly the "Lost in the Woods" cocktail and the draft beer, received an 8 and were truly delightful. The arugula salad stood out with a stellar rating of 9.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Arugula Salad with Apples and Walnuts
Julia Asprey
Another amazing meal at the Kaatskeller - our pizzas were delicious and our 2 year old son had the best time dancing to the music. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna B.
Great space, pizza and ambience! Always look forward to eating here when we visit in June!
Great vibe, great food, good service. Nice, chill music. Cozy and homey. They only thing that was odd is that the website says seating is "open and unreserved" but we walked in as 2 for dinner and were only able to sit at the bar despite tables being open at the time. So maybe call ahead.
Ryan Luck
Not that much room inside for huge groups, but they got a fire going for us and was awesome even better. Pizza is great and super cool spot. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alicia P.
This is my second visit. I love their pizzas, their arugula apple salad is delicious. They have the friendliest servers, come for their food and enjoy their outdoor garden. They have a fire pit too! You can keep warm while having a cocktail and pizza!
Megan Little
I went here on a Saturday night with my friends. They were out of multiple beers and the cocktail i wanted. My pizza was forgot about, and also my beer even though multiple people checked on it when i asked multiple times. Pizza was good but kind of wet. The seating was also really cramped. Overall this place overpriced but mid, i wouldn’t come back.
Amy M.
Everything was great! A must if you are in the area , wish we had more time ! you will love it ! Pizza was amazing and fresh and don't get me started on the apple pie ! And ofc the beer was soooo good ! Service was super nice and fast and the location is in the perfect spot ! Super worthy of its on your way!
Great find in our travels. Wonderful service and food. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Rosso Pizza
Not worth the price. Overpriced. Ordered drinks when we sat down and never received them. Finished eating and had to cancel the drinks bc apparently they were never coming. Had to ask for the bill three times. We were one of three tables at the time...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great place, great atmosphere. Came with my uncle, a long time local, and really enjoyed the stone oven pizza. Very tavernesque, cozy style upstairs that's extremely aesthetic and inviting. Great food, better staff. Would 10/10 recommend if you're ever in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a great meal and friendly helpful service! Ambiance was warm and casual. Looking forward to a return visit.
Last day before we left Livingston Manor, my family and I were hungry so we looked up a few places and end up finding this spot. While seated, I overheard OUR server (out of everyone) say how she “hates people who come from NYC and wish they would just stay there” mind you she has us seated literally right next to the bar where she saying that. I couldn’t believe my ears. We were nothing but friendly, just looking for some pizza. The vibes were SO off in this place my wife was in a rush to leave. Food was okay. Love Livingston Manor, not this place. Those “people from NYC” that come to your beautiful town are supporting your local business.
We had dinner at this restaurant and ordered pizza and baked trout. Long waiting times. The pizza was acceptable while the trout was not very tasty and the vegetables were unseasoned. Good dessert but small portions. Not
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Delicious pizza - the Margherita is amazing.Make a reservation in the winter. Indoor seating is
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Brook Trout Rillettes, The Manor Pizza
As seasoned reviewers, my boyfriend and I recommend this Catskills pizza spot, giving it a commendable 8.2. The atmosphere, both indoors and outdoors, was superb. The staff was friendly, enhancing the overall experience. Our culinary journey included a wood-fired roasted trout appetizer, which, unfortunately, scored a 5 due to its mushiness and an incompatible onion-rice mix. As a non-garlic eater, the pesto was overwhelmingly garlicky. The Waterfowl folly Rueben sauerkraut pizza earned an 8 for its well-structured dough, while the Hawaii Five-Oh disappointed with an excessive amount of cheese and pineapple, resulting in a rating of 3. The drinks, particularly the "Lost in the Woods" cocktail and the draft beer, received an 8 and were truly delightful. The arugula salad stood out with a stellar rating of 9.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Arugula Salad with Apples and Walnuts
Another amazing meal at the Kaatskeller - our pizzas were delicious and our 2 year old son had the best time dancing to the music. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great space, pizza and ambience! Always look forward to eating here when we visit in June!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great vibe, great food, good service. Nice, chill music. Cozy and homey. They only thing that was odd is that the website says seating is "open and unreserved" but we walked in as 2 for dinner and were only able to sit at the bar despite tables being open at the time. So maybe call ahead.
Not that much room inside for huge groups, but they got a fire going for us and was awesome even better. Pizza is great and super cool spot. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my second visit. I love their pizzas, their arugula apple salad is delicious. They have the friendliest servers, come for their food and enjoy their outdoor garden. They have a fire pit too! You can keep warm while having a cocktail and pizza!
I went here on a Saturday night with my friends. They were out of multiple beers and the cocktail i wanted. My pizza was forgot about, and also my beer even though multiple people checked on it when i asked multiple times. Pizza was good but kind of wet. The seating was also really cramped. Overall this place overpriced but mid, i wouldn’t come back.
Everything was great! A must if you are in the area , wish we had more time ! you will love it ! Pizza was amazing and fresh and don't get me started on the apple pie ! And ofc the beer was soooo good ! Service was super nice and fast and the location is in the perfect spot ! Super worthy of its on your way!